Blog: Case Closed

Where Cupcakes Don't Belong

Posted on September 8, 2008

Cupcakes are supposed to be found at birthday parties – not stories about college football.

At an alarming rate, sports reporters are taking cupcakes out of the oven and placing them in their work. Turn on ESPN and you'll hear football analysts such as Mark May yelling about cupcakes. Open the paper and you’ll see articles in the sports section about cupcakes.

It doesn’t make any sense, right? Instead of describing a poor football opponent as a ‘bad team’ or ‘mismatched’, everyone resorts to using the dreaded ‘cupcake’ – or ‘tasty treat’ or ‘pastries’ or ‘creampuffs’.

Enough already. This isn’t an attack on any one channel or publication because nearly everyone is guilty. This is simply pointing out a cliché epidemic.

Its origins can’t exactly be traced. But somewhere along the line, really good football teams started playing really bad football teams by choice in their non-conference schedule. Think Kansas’ upcoming game against Sam Houston State.

Some sportswriter somewhere – who deserves to be slapped – must have gotten tired of explaining why the losing teams were so unsuccessful and how fun it was for the juggernaut to pummel them. So he came up with cupcake, which must mean the good team devoured the not-so-good team like a kid with a sweet tooth does to a frosting-topped cup of flour.

It probably sounded creative the first time it was used. Not so much after 5,477,884th time. If ESPN.com re-wrote this list from a few years ago, cupcake would have to be included.

Sportswriters cringe when coaches use clichés. Mark Mangino talking about taking it one week at a time or sawing wood is excruciatingly painful to us. Therefore, it’s hypocritical to turn around and use clichés in our writing.

Sure, it’s brought a few comical moments – such as this KUsports.com headline from a year ago or this blog entry. Overall, however, it has become arguably the most overused term in sports.

I’m not trying to come off as arrogant or holier-than-thou. I’m as guilty, if not more so, as anyone when it comes to using clichés in sports stories. It happens. But cupcake is simply the most irritating one at the moment. Someone has to speak up.

Cupcakes do not exist in college football. Underwhelming opponents do.


Discussion

The Kansan.com staff reviews comments regularly. Please be respectful of your peers. For our full user policy, click here.

September 10th, 2008
3:33 p.m.
Flag as offensive

Keefer, good call on this article. You probably saw it, but the KC Star had a graphic last week that also featured a cupcake for a KU story. That one got me mad. I would say my favorite overused cliche in sports has got to be -- they took the lead and never looked back.


September 10th, 2008
4:26 p.m.
Flag as offensive

Thank God someone finally called this out. As a fellow sports fanatic, and perhaps aspiring sports writer, I realize that cliches in sports are almost unavoidable. Cliches become what they because often they're written or blurted out because they've become such natural or accepted commentary or reactions. With that said, some if not most of them do need to go, in particular "cupcake." I admit that the metaphor behind the cliche makes sense and is actually quite creative--for the FIRST person who used it. The only reason cupcake worked is because it was new, unheard of and, at the time, original. Can't the big-time ESPN football analysts (Mark May) think of at least a dozen other words to describe an obvious blowout or underdog opponent? They should be able to--they're getting paid big bucks to. One last thing, excellent link to the "Sports cliches that must go." Ironically, under the cliche "Play within ourselves," Ernest Fagan of San Diego uses "cupcake" in his comment. Ridiculous.


Share your 2¢

(Requires free registration.)

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment: