Monday, August 29, 2005
I want to tell you about a friend of mine. His name is Timothy. Tim attends Louisiana State University in Baton Rouge. He’s an engineering student and loves to tell people that the “Timmy!” gag on South Park is based on him.
Tim’s a huge fan of football and the past few years have been pretty kind to him and his Tigers, but the only thing Tim ever wants to talk about is Florida State. You see, Tim is a member of the Seminole tribe from which FSU’s mascot takes its name.
By now, I am sure that everyone is somewhat familiar with the NCAA’s recent ban on the use of Indian mascots by universities. Advocates of minority and multicultural rights have long sought action that would prevent the use of mascots the NCAA deems “hostile” or “abusive,” and the NCAA has received much praise for its actions along with the expected criticism.
Tragedy struck last week. On Wednesday, the NCAA overturned its ban on Florida State’s mascot, reasoning that members of the Seminole tribe had a working relationship with the university.
Of course, FSU president T.K. Wetherell also threatened a lawsuit if the ban was not overturned. Let me repeat the important part of that sentence: the ban was dropped because the university threatened to sue.
Is this what our nation has come to? We’ll appease all those we can, as long as we don’t get sued? The NCAA’s overturning of its own ban is ridiculous.
The NCAA has been quick to emphasize that the ban was lifted because of FSU’s working relationship with the Seminole tribe. This is ludicrous. The United States of America has a “working” relationship with North Korea, so should we simply stop paying any attention to Kim Il Jong’s increasingly frightening actions? Of course not.
Proponents of Florida State’s right to use the Seminole as a mascot have also jumped on this bandwagon. I seriously doubt, however, that any of these proponents have spoken with anyone associated with the Seminoles, or that they could even tell you one legitimate thing about the tribe.
After conversing with Tim, I can say that this is not a universally popular move within the tribe.
Take a step back and think about this issue. It makes sense that Seminoles would be appalled by this action.
Most college mascots are animals, both real and mythical. The largest exception to this rule is the use of Indian mascots. These people are essentially being equated with animals. How would you feel if someone told you that you were no different from a tiger or a bulldog or a wolverine?
Another argument that supporters of Indian mascots use is the idea of historic context. The Seminole tribe is located in Florida, and thus it is logical to pay homage to them as mascots. I would have no problem with this argument if it was universally followed. As soon as the University of Alabama-Birmingham adopts “the Klan” as its mascot, I’ll acquiesce to this argument’s validity.
In my mind, there is no difference between the FSU Seminoles and the UAB Klan. Many African-Americans have been killed in Alabama, one of the most horrifying examples being the church bombing in Birmingham a few decades ago. What better way to preserve the memory of these unfortunate victims than by the renaming of a state university’s mascot?
Once again, this is ludicrous. I’d like to state in writing that I would never support such a plan as I have just lain out, and for the same reasons cannot support any school’s use of an Indian mascot.
I realize that my relationship with individuals such as Tim makes me more sensitive to this issue. Nonetheless, this is an issue of which everyone should make themselves aware.
The NCAA’s reversal of their ban is quite possibly this country’s most tragic disaster since 9/11. Not only is this an issue that has a large emotional and psychological impact on members of the Seminole nation, but it also affects our nation as a whole.
Most of us are at least vaguely aware of the atrocities the American government has historically committed against Native Americans; to this day it remains the poorest ethnic group in the country, by a significant margin. Allowing universities such as Florida State to continue their offensive use of Indian mascots is outrageous.
By repealing its ban, the NCAA has spit in the face of the Seminole nation, the larger community of Native Americans, and the country as a whole.
Good is an Olathe senior in English.
Letter to the editor: Garick's column belligerent, ...
Lysen: Schools shouldn't lose history because of ...
University of North Dakota could lose history and tradition because of its ...
Student Senate passes mascot resolution
Symposium showcases American Indian culture
The Dole Institute of Politics will hold the event, which focuses on ...
Native Americans seek student involvement
First Nation Student Association hopes to make the presence of Native Americans ...
Vernon: Ideal tournament matchups for the Jayhawks
Mike Vernon breaks down the Jayhawks March Madness prospects and tells why ...
Preservation or progression
Explore the perspectives of the Wetlands saga, from cultural identity to ecological ...
Unwritten rules of Big Jay
Two junior and two senior men share the identity of Big Jay. ...
Alumni group bashes new font
This summer the KU Athletics Department decided to adopt the official KU ...
Letter to the Editor
Mizzou designer explains position in ‘Scoreboard’ shirt
Native American students celebrate culture
Tribe members from as far as New Mexico attended the dance competitions ...
Kansas football opener will have instant replay
A question of identity
The Comanche Nation informed KU that a professor who claims he's Comanche ...
Jayhawk trailing in Mascot contest
Legalizing Love: the state of same-sex marriage ...
A look at the battle for marriage equality.
Behind the Beak
Morning Brew: Journalists not always malicious
Florida coach needs to reevaluate Sentinel writer’s intentions before banning him from ...
State bill could end local smoking ban
New legislation would overturn the long-established non-smoking ordinance in Lawrence.
Editorial: Statewide smoking ban would benefit Kansans
Health benefits alone are enough to warrant a ban.
Morning Brew: MLB could hire female GM
Kim Ng interviewed for the general manager position with the San Diego ...
All's fair in LARP and war
This art not thy mother's game of Scrabble — slay hard or ...
Demonstrators hope to stop wetland road talks
Students, locals at Strong Hall try to convince the University to preserve ...
Morning Brew: Jayhawk mascot not mean enough
Wartime KU mascot “The Warbird” strikes more fear in opponents’ hearts, should ...
White Owl in tears about rumors
White Owl, KU’s bearded mascot, thought he could be banned from campus.
Shorman: Smoking ban strips student rights
Banning sale of tobacco on campus is about more than blowing smoke.
Native American artifacts will be returned to ...
Historic attire: Two rival mascots and the ...
School mascots also linked to Civil War history.
Professor Profile: Beth Manolescu
Learn more about Professor Manolescu.
Exhausted teams battle in title game
Mascots on parade
Meet a few of KU’s other fictional figures
Stoops the familiar choice for Zenger
Sheahon Zenger is on the hunt for Kansas' next head football coach, ...
Long-distance relationships really can work
Grad student promotes work on C-SPAN 2
Through teaching and journalism, grad student fights stereotypes and underrepresentation of American ...
Sports Brief: November 2, 2007
Here is what is happening in Kansas sports for November 2, 2007
Raid rivalry shirt made for personal use
The Missouri alumnus who designed and printed four KU-MU rivalry T-shirts said ...
Hatching new ideas
In 1970 freshman student Amy Hurst premiered as the first Baby Jay. ...
Gaza Strip evacuations evoke strong emotion on ...
How We Met: Tim Clark and Rayyan ...
All great relationships had to start somewhere.
From left: Kimberlee Hinkle, Libby Johnson and Hannah ...
1 comment
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID