Gaza Strip evacuations evoke strong emotion on both sides


Images of Israelis wailing and protesting the evacuation of people from the Gaza Strip hit close to home for Zohar Ravid, Overland Park junior, who was born and raised on a kibbutz in Israel. Former classmates of his are in the Israeli army overseeing the pullout.

“One friend had to tell an older woman to move and she asked him to sit down and explain to her why he was doing this,” Zohar said. “My friend said ‘I have no choice, we have to do this.’”

On Aug. 15, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon ordered the Israeli army to have all Jewish settlers to leave their homes in the Gaza Strip and relocate peacefully within 48 hours. Sharon ordered the evacuation as a territorial compromise to Palestine.

For all Israelis abroad, the latest developments in Gaza continue to evoke strong feelings.

Ravid, who visits Israel every summer, was there a week before the evacuations began. He said the atmosphere throughout the country was intense. Popular opinion was almost evenly divided. Those who supported the pullout wore blue and those who were against it wore orange.

“Blue and orange were everywhere. The colors were on cars, buildings and clothing,” Ravid said. “The pull out was the only thing people could talk about.”

But Ravid said he supported the pullout because his friends in the Israeli army were trained to be peaceful and could not carry weapons during the process. The Israeli government worked to ensure that the settlers who were displaced did not encounter any financial losses.

“People were offered a house of similar value and a job offer in the places that they move,” Ravid said.

He said he agreed with the argument that because of security risks, it wasn’t worth it for Jewish settlers to remain in Gaza.

“The ball is now in Palestine’s court,” Ravid said.

But Kahlil Saad, Wichita senior and a Lebanese-American, said it was “ridiculous” to assume the Palestinian authority could take control immediately.

Saad said the evacuation was not about bringing stability to Gaza.

“Demographics are its biggest threat,” Saad said.

Saad is referring to comments Sharon made in a televised speech last week.

Sharon said that Israel could not hold on to Gaza because more than a million Palestinians live there and that the number doubles with each generation.

“The Israel government is actually setting up conditions contrary to that of a stable government,” Saad said. “Sharon wants to wash his hands from the responsibilities of the Gaza Strip but he is still required to protect basic human rights.”

But the withdrawal seems to be the first step in a long process for Palestinian stability in Gaza.

According to the CIA World Fact Book, the Gaza Strip has a population of 1,376,289, in an area that is little more than twice the size of Washington, D.C. Few natural resources add to the nation’s woes.

Saad said the evacuation actually defied provisions set forth by the Geneva Conventions by controlling economic development while neglecting to provide for the citizens’ welfare.

“Israel maintains control of water, sewage, telecommunications and electricity in Gaza,” Saad said. “But they also reserve the right to reinvade and continue to limit any sort of movement.”

In these conditions, factions such as Hamas rise to power. Hamas is a militant Islamist Palestinian organization that opposes the existence of Israel and favors the creation of an Islamic state in Palestine.

“A relative poverty and lack of opportunity for Palestinians in Gaza are one source of what seems to be the source of extremism and exclusivism in Gaza,” said Jonathan Boyarin, Jewish studies professor.

But Boyarin also stressed Palestinians “aren’t just a fanatical tribe.”

Boyarin urged understanding on all sides.

“Whatever the politics are, it seems a human imperative that the residents of Gaza be integrated into the region’s economy,” Boyarin said.

— Edited by Anne Burgard

 

Related articles

Students feel burden of conflict in Gaza

Despite the distance between KU and Israel, the Gaza crisis still reaches ...

/news/2009/jan/29/gaza/

Anderson: Palestine needs our help

Israel receives more money than the Caribbean, Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa ...

/news/2008/jan/25/anderson/

Letters to the Editor: January 30, 2007

These people have an opinion. The Kansan values it.

/news/2008/jan/30/letters_editor_january_30_2007/

Israeli denounces terrorists

/news/2005/apr/13/news_campus_dole/

Letter to the Editor: Wrong label

Negotiating with Hamas would be like negotiating with Al Qaeda.

/news/2008/apr/14/letter_editor/

Cohen: Beliefs about Gaza should be more ...

The conflict in the Middle East isn't as clear-cut as some people ...

/news/2009/feb/04/cohen_beliefs/

Event will educate public on Palestine

Voices of Palestine, a student group, will hold two days of workshops ...

/news/2009/mar/25/palestine/

Anderson: Weak link in Obama’s armor

Obama's support of Israel raises curious questions of Apartheid and human rights.

/news/2008/apr/11/weak_link_obamas_armor/

Protesters to march against killings

Solidarity Revolutionary Center volunteers protest both police killings and military occupations.

/news/2009/jan/30/march/

Kenny: Gazans overlooked in current border conflict

America's support of Israel is under-reported during this crisis.

/news/2009/jan/16/kenny_gazans/

Anderson: What we didn’t learn after September ...

/news/2008/dec/09/anderson_sept11/

Editorial Board: University’s study abroad restrictions justified

Program through University of Texas opens doors for travel

/news/2007/sep/25/editorial_board_universitys_study_abroad_restricti/

Jewish Studies takes new direction

The group welcomed an entirely new set of Hebrew instructors this year

/news/2010/sep/13/hebrew-instructors/

‘Jewish Jordan’ talks faith, basketball

Jewish Division 1 player who never played on holy days speaks tonight ...

/news/2009/oct/26/Jewish-faith-basketball/

Week’s events give insight to Israel

Hatikvah, a Jewish student organization, is celebrating two holidays Israeli this week ...

/news/2009/apr/24/israel_insight/

Al-Qaida leader bin Laden dead, body in ...

President Barack Obama confirms Osama bin Laden is dead in national address ...

/news/2011/may/01/new-york-times-cbs-confirms-osama-bin-laden-dead/

Retired University Professor will be remembered

Professor of Engineering passed away on Saturday, at the age of 82. ...

/news/2011/aug/30/retired-university-professor-will-be-remembered/

Editorial: Escapees should be allowed refuge

The Israeli government denied 50 African refugees admittance into Israel on Sunday. ...

/news/2007/aug/21/editorial/

No country for young men

Visa laws, refugee status and politics have contributed to one senior’s statelessness.

/news/2008/oct/02/no_country_young_men/

Speaker gives presentation on business in Israel

Dan Senor discussed the state of the economy in Israel provides a ...

/news/2010/apr/21/speaker-gives-presentation-business-israel/

Chabad Jewish Center celebrates Hanukkah

Hanukkah begins just as finals end, so the Chabad Jewish Center is ...

/news/2006/dec/11/chabad_jewish_center_celebrates_hanukkah/

Group celebrates and educates about Israel

Activities include reggae concert, Israeli food, speakers.

/news/2010/apr/19/group-celebrates-and-educates-about-israel/

Groups dispel myths about Middle East conflict

With KU students returning to Lawrence, campus groups prepare for an onslaught ...

/news/2006/aug/14/israel/

Regan: Ireland could set example for peace

After years of violence Ireland is starting to find its own peace.

/news/2009/jul/14/ireland/

Israeli funk group to play in Lawrence

Hadag Nachash will kick off KU Hillel’s celebration of Israel’s 60th anniversary ...

/news/2008/feb/06/israeli_funk_group_play_lawrence/

News Briefs: August 16, 2007

Additional news for August 16, 2007

/news/2007/aug/16/news_briefs_august_16_2007/

MULTIMEDIA: Musician’s passion leads to language study

/news/2005/apr/26/news_campus_passion/

Chabad student center expands celebration

Sukkot, a Jewish holiday, celebrates Jewish history and the outdoors.

/news/2007/sep/26/Chabad/

Malott Hall evacuated, reopened after reported chemical ...

The chemical smell was not unidentified but it dissipated enough for the ...

/news/2010/dec/06/malott-hall-evacuated-after-reported-chemical-smel/

Bear-ly defeated

/news/2005/feb/24/sports_basketball_womens_gamer/

Server of the Week

/news/2005/aug/25/server_week/

Talk back: The 2008 Olympic Games in ...

What students say vs. what we say.

/news/2008/apr/25/talk_back_2008_olympic_games_beijing/

Student's family affected by hurricane

/news/2005/aug/31/ne_hurricane_folo/

Hurricane Katrina hits home for students

/news/2005/aug/29/hurricane/

This weekend: aluminum entertainment

Because those CSI marathons are getting old.

/news/2010/feb/25/weekend-aluminum-entertainment/

Army ROTC students compete in war games

/news/2005/apr/25/news_campus_rotc/

Letter: US does care about Egypt and ...

A reader disagrees with our columnist's take on Egypt.

/news/2011/feb/09/letter-us-does-care-about-egypt-and-its-people/

Religious celebration attendance continues to expand

/news/2005/nov/07/shabbat_350/

Recent public administration, history graduate dies

Fall 2010 graduate Sharon Petrie died Jan. 1 in Overland Park.

/news/2011/jan/07/recent-public-administration-history-graduate-dies/

Chabad hosts Jewish holiday festivities

Purim events will include traditional readings and a circus-themed dinner celebration.

/news/2009/mar/10/chabad_purim/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment