American journalism all fluff, no substance

American journalism is in trouble. This summer, while images of the “runaway bride” were splashed across our television screens, Turkey was denied entry into the European Union and the future of the EU stood on shaky grounds. Although this event would have lasting effects on the American economy and diplomatic relationships, the American press barely stirred.

That same summer, a Senate panel grilled professional baseball players about the use of steroids. As George Henson of Dallas said in a letter to the New York Times in August of 2005, “All the feigned shock and awe about Rafael Palmeiro’s steroid use is about as newsworthy as the runaway bride.” One couldn’t turn on the television without seeing concerned, paunchy white men frowning down at gargantuan athletes.

There has been a slow, almost imperceptible, movement of the American media to focus on the fluff and ignore the substance. And, the forecast on the horizon is bleak. The traditional newsroom is becoming a relic. Large corporations have slowly gobbled up papers across the nation, and bit by bit have gutted newsrooms and left reporters to wallow in their own entrails, so to speak.

Corporations tend to shy away from controversial stories, so the fluff is played off as “hard-hitting” news. Fewer reporters means fewer chances for journalists to catch a scandal. Increased tripe means we’re more likely to alienate readers fed up with “infotainment.”

The Michael Jackson trial saw swarms of reporters, hitting on such “late-breaking news” as Jackson showing up in pajamas. With all the reporters clamoring and braying questions at Jackson from behind a fence, it wasn’t so much a media circus as a media zoo.

We, as journalists need to get back to our roots. Perhaps not in the style of writing of the 1930s and 40s, but to the core of what the fourth estate is all about: Hard news that affects the public.

Journalism has to evolve if we want to stay relevant. But, we cannot lose our values along the way. A newspaper is not the place for headlines trumpeting the break up of flash-in-the-pan celebrities. The newspaper is a vehicle to change minds, to inform the public and to be the guardians of the people.

It’s a profession that once harbored bulldogs like Woodward, Bernstein and H.L. Mencken. We’ve never been popular, but now we’re openly mocked. Now we have Geraldo.

A revolution must come from within the journalistic community. It’s time to hit the streets, dig for information and let people know what is happening in the world and how it affects them.

Paris Hilton doesn’t matter. Michael Jackson doesn’t matter. The runaway bride doesn’t matter. Celebrity doesn’t necessitate a front page, above the fold article.

For God’s sake, President Theodore Roosevelt gave us the name “muckraker” because reporters were willing to crawl on their hands and knees through the filth to get the story. What the hell happened to that?

It is a knife my heart to see readership declining in newspapers. It makes me nauseous to see the break of Brad and Jen as the second headline on BBC.

It doesn’t have to be sensational; it doesn’t have to send the country into turmoil like the Watergate stories. It can be as simple as preventing a city commission from screwing over the “little guy.” Carl Hiaasen, Miami Herald columnist, often bemoans the dangers of not being a watchdog for the people that your paper serves.

The journalistic community owes it to readers. We are a waypoint between point A and point B, and it’s high time for a new golden age of journalistic integrity. For the rest, let them read People.

Vierthaler is a Dodge City junior in journalism.

 

Related articles

CITIZEN DOLPH: A rare look at the ...

You may not recognize his name, but Dolph Simons Jr., chairman of ...

/news/2006/apr/04/dolph/

Editor's note: No slight meant against the ...

/news/2005/nov/17/caster/

NCAA steroid testing needs closer look

/news/2005/may/04/sports_column_rains/

Renowned journalist visits campus

Hersh, who exposed the torture at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq with ...

/news/2008/feb/08/hersh/

Garrison: Mental illness must be discussed openly

Tragic consequences of depression cannot be prevented by ignoring its prevalence.

/news/2010/sep/17/mental-illness-should-be-discussed-openly/

Blakeborough: Japanese lives should matter more than ...

Tragedy in Japan trumps weather reports in California.

/news/2011/mar/13/blakeborough-japanese-lives-are-more-priority-us-i/

Holtz: The end of international correspondents?

Uncertainties in international journalism reflect fears about entire industry’s future.

/news/2010/jun/07/holtz-end-international-correspondents/

Boultinghouse: Finding value in trivial news

Every story has two sides.

/news/2009/sep/03/finding_value_trivial_news/

Journalism School awards 63rd annual William Allen ...

John Carroll, former Pulitzer-Prize winning editor, was this year's award recipient.

/news/2011/feb/11/journalism-school-awards-63rd-annual-william-allen/

Goble: Montana coach shuns student media

Players are forbidden from talking to student newspaper after assault report was ...

/news/2009/oct/21/goble-montana-coach-shuns-student-media/

What in the world

/news/2005/sep/08/what_world/

KU doesn't echo NCAA's tough stance on ...

A positive drug test with the NCAA results in a one-year suspension. ...

/news/2007/jan/19/drug_testing/

McNaughton: Reflection on proper use of speech ...

Question causes reflection speech and sensitivity.

/news/2010/sep/30/mcnaughton-reflection-proper-use-speech-always-nee/

HOPE Award winner loves job

Since coming to teach at the University of Kansas in 2003, Edward ...

/news/2007/nov/28/hope_award_winner_loves_job/

Hawktopics: April 6, 2006

/news/2006/apr/06/jp_hawktopics/

Kansan regrets unfair headline

The statement that Kansas football’s 2007 season was a ‘fluke’ was inaccurate ...

/news/2008/nov/18/unfair_headline/

Music guy

Your guide to music utopia

/news/2008/apr/24/music_guy/

No. 1 only matters to some

Past seasons show that No. 1 ranking doesn't ensure postseason success; some ...

/news/2011/feb/13/no-1-only-matters-some/

Editorial: Health of high school journalism important ...

Changes in how high school journalism programs are funded in Kansas will ...

/news/2010/sep/21/editorial-health-high-school-journalism-important-/

Fire and brimstone alienates mainstream American public

/news/2006/jan/26/vierthaler_opinion/

Award-winning journalist featured speaker for Editors Day

Dotson tells the story of ordinary people with extraordinary experiences.

/news/2007/sep/21/dotson/

Q&A with KU Alumnus Luis Santos, Sr.

The Kansan spoke with Luis Santos, Sr. about his retirement and what ...

/news/2010/nov/22/q-ku-alumnus-luis-santos-sr/

Q&A: Leonard Pitts Jr.

Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist to receive award at KU Friday.

/news/2010/feb/05/leonard-pitts/

The Kansan partners with Politicalfiber.com

The University Daily Kansan partners with a political news site affiliated with ...

/news/2012/jan/23/kansan-partners-politicalfibercom/

Olympic athletes ready to shine at Relays

The Gold Zone returns to the Kansas Relays Saturday afternoon.

/news/2007/apr/20/olympic_athletes_ready_shine_relays/

KU panel discusses your brain, on food

Studies at KU Life Span Institute look to answer questions about the ...

/news/2009/feb/13/brain_food/

Editorial Board: Colorado State editorial went too ...

Issue of respectable purpose comes into question.

/news/2007/oct/18/Editorial_Board/

Campus club touts benefits of marijuana

NORML wrapped up the semester with a film screening about medicinal marijuana.

/news/2010/nov/29/campus-club-offers-benefits-marijuana/

Music review: Corpse Bride Soundtrack

/news/2005/sep/29/music_review2/

Letter: Checking the facts

/news/2008/sep/23/letter_checking_facts/

Students take risks trying to get a ...

Risk and dangers surround snorting bath salts, which are now classified as ...

/news/2011/jul/01/students-take-risks-trying-get-cheap-high/

Boultinghouse: News we'll never forget

Media coverage ignores real stories for sensational stories.

/news/2009/oct/30/boultinghouse-news/

Mangiaracina: America tops list of most incarcerated

The large number of people behind bars puts weight on culture and ...

/news/2008/apr/11/america_tops_list_most_incarcerated/

Wacker: The best is yet to come

/news/2006/feb/09/sp_wacker/

Alumna changes career goal, sees success in ...

Ellyn Angelotti is the youngest employee for the Poynter Institute.

/news/2010/apr/29/alumna-changes-career-goal-sees-success-online-med/

Journalism students sweep national competition

Matt Erickson and Megan Hirt took the top two spots in the ...

/news/2009/jan/27/journalism_competition/

Gonzo: The Life and Work of Hunter ...

/news/2008/aug/21/gonzo_life_and_work_hunter_s_thompson/

De Oliveira: Animated documentary offers new take ...

'Waltz With Bashir' offers unique insights into the conflict in the Middle ...

/news/2009/mar/11/de_oliveira/

Working together: media and the military

Students interview soldiers from Leavenworth for joint military and media program.

/news/2009/oct/02/military/

Stage Presence: The Runaway Sons

Feel free to swoon.

/news/2011/sep/14/stage-presence-th-runaway-sons/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment