Editorial: Debates fail to fix problems

Country's real issues, like war, remain unsolved

Trouble is brewing in our nation’s capital — so goes the storyline of our national press corps, anyway.

The current debate over the pending war spending bill, the symbolic battleground for President Bush and his Congressional opponents, is being billed in the national media as a “showdown” of titanic proportions, a “fierce clash” between opposing ideologies that will determine who holds sway in post-midterm Washington. In short, it’s a legislative skirmish that will alter our war policy for the foreseeable future.

nutgraf

Meanwhile, the actual war drags on and on, mostly out of sight and mind for American voters, a product of the almost total absence of shared sacrifice.

Unfortunately for those engaged in an actual, tangible clash overseas, this debate is a showdown in name only, a nominal and semantic fight over who can make the best case to the voters in 2008. The Democrats, their bill already laden with the kind of earmarked pork they promised to purge from Congress, see the installation of benchmarks and timetables as the best way to become the party that supports soldiers the most. President Bush, apparently psychologically incapable to accept any kind of compromise, lest he be seen as conceding, promises to veto any bill that includes those benchmarks. This “debate” is nothing more than an electoral chicken run, with each side hoping the other bails first.

Meanwhile, the actual war drags on and on, mostly out of sight and mind for American voters, a product of the almost total absence of shared sacrifice. Most of us are asked to give little to nothing to the war effort, keeping us from emotional investment beyond the ideological. New tactics are rolled out every few months by war planners in an effort to stem the tide of violence, a sort of New Coke way of policymaking that is so far failing. Futile strategies become little more than pop culture buzzwords for myopic planning, while touring politicians praise the “openness” of street markets as they are protected by scores of accompanying soldiers.

As we have disturbingly seen so many times before, what was supposed to be political debate has instead devolved into political theater, a scripted competition between two sets of performers. Each side jockeys for linguistic position, speaking in lofty platitudes about the “signs of progress” and “failure of leadership,” while each clamors to be seen, in carefully refined voter research, as the party with the most support for troops.

Young people are weary of the war, and not simply because we grew up in what has been termed a “holiday from history.” We are depressed instead by the shifting foundations, absence of feasible ideas and prospects for the future. While our elected leaders bloviate, the hopes of young citizens grow dimmer and dimmer.

— McKay Stangler for the editorial board

 

Related articles

Editorial: Voting a responsibility

Student Senate candidates spend countless hours in session and campaigning. As hard ...

/news/2007/apr/10/edvote/

Editorial: Bush’s ‘blind faith’ problematic

Bush’s veto of latest Democratic bill highlights the problems of the administration ...

/news/2007/may/03/stangler_ed/

Editorial: Votes need to count

Turnout in student elections remains low. Rather than ignoring the result, Student ...

/news/2007/mar/13/mckay/

Editorial: Calling the race early

Coverage of the 2008 presidential race often looks at the noteriety of ...

/news/2007/mar/28/stanglered/

Editorial: Positive war news overlooked

Iraq is bloody and violent, but there are positive advances being made. ...

/news/2007/mar/06/edmckay/

Editorial: Politicians sing sad song with poor

America’s middle class is wealthier than ever, yet citizens still worry about ...

/news/2007/feb/26/stanglered/

Editorial: News an endless horse race

On and on they went, the Russerts and Schneiders of the world, ...

/news/2007/apr/09/mckayed/

Stangler: Education policy needs revision

Bush's No Child Left Behind will be examined in the upcoming federal ...

/news/2007/feb/28/stanglered/

Editorial: Presidential candidates seem stale

It's just the same old stories from many of the same old ...

/news/2007/may/09/stanglered/

Editorial: U.S. should analyze Russia

Americans can get a good sense of where our democracy is headed ...

/news/2007/may/02/stanglered/

Editorial: Afghanistan as important as ever

Pakistan, our nuclear-capable ally, is as precarious as ever, and a single ...

/news/2007/feb/27/mckay_ed/

Editorial: Will the real Slim Shady please ...

The Editorial Board faces bigger issues as the Eminem maritial dispute continues ...

/news/2007/mar/30/edmckay/

Editorial: Trademarks probably not violated

The University has pending legal issues with Joe-College.com, which may be illegally ...

/news/2007/mar/08/strangler_ed/

Editorial: We must stand tall

In the wake of the Virginia Tech tragedy it is only a ...

/news/2007/apr/18/stanglered/

Editorial Board: Iraq’s success dependent own government

When all is said and done, the government set up in Iraq ...

/news/2007/sep/07/editorial_board/

Stangler: Manufactured outrage dooms radio

Statements on the radio run rampant when commentators are pressed to fill ...

/news/2007/apr/13/stranglered/

Editorial: Abstinence failing as sex education tool

A study commissioned by Congress proved the abstinence approach to sexual education ...

/news/2007/apr/20/mckayed/

Stangler: ‘Responsibility’ in danger

If an official takes ‘full responsibility’ for something, there should be no ...

/news/2007/mar/29/stangler_ed/

A winter classic reborn

Don't let your inner Ebenezer let you miss this one. "Scrooged" updates ...

/news/2006/dec/11/winter_classic_reborn/

Bornstein: Battling with — and under — ...

Prohibiting openly gay men and women from participating in the military benefits ...

/news/2010/apr/16/bornstein-battling/

Editorial: Movies not a happy escape

You've heard it all before, but we swear it's true. Your relatively ...

/news/2007/apr/03/edmckay/

Editorial: Campaign ideas disappoint

With student selections nearly upon us, this year's candidates have no new ...

/news/2007/apr/11/stanglered/

McKay’s bat powers Kansas to 2-1 weekend ...

The freshman has three home runs in four games.

/news/2012/mar/11/mckays-bat-powers-kansas-2-1-weekend-record/

/comments/cr/33/190/#c36

Thompson: What war means for the rest ...

/news/2008/oct/05/thompson_what_war_means_rest_us/

De Oliveira: Calling an end to the ...

President Obama needs to avoid the confrontational nature of former President Bush.

/news/2009/jan/29/de_oliveira/

Brinker: The great American rant

Everyone is angry, but where are the fingers really pointing?

/news/2010/feb/03/brinker-great/

KU student ID cards to work at ...

Student voting will become easier as ID cards will be considered a ...

/news/2012/mar/14/voting/

Politically Correct: The ethics of torture tactics

Our panelists offer their opinions on whether torture should be permitted in ...

/news/2010/mar/05/politically-correct/

Using underwear to catch attention

For Sexual Violence Awareness Month the University is attempting to make students ...

/news/2009/apr/10/awareness/

Weighing the collateral damage

Iraqi war veterans have trouble justifying civilian casualties on urban battlefields in ...

/news/2009/mar/26/stewart/

McCroy: Scotland's independence

If a group decides they want to break away from a mother ...

/news/2012/jan/26/mccroy-scotlands-independence/

Ron Paul takes hold of youth vote

David Conway spent six months discovering Ron Paul and his supporters after ...

/news/2012/feb/15/ron-paul-youth-vote/

KU ROTC honors veterans with ceremonies

KU ROTC gives ceremonies to at the three memorials and an address ...

/news/2008/nov/07/veterans/

Students to soldiers

Facing possible deployment to Iraq or Afghanistan after graduation, 81 University students ...

/news/2008/may/01/students_soldiers/

Letter: Don't be too uptight about Sex ...

/news/2008/sep/23/letter_dont_be_too_uptight_about_sex_hill/

A generation ablaze

Forty years ago today, the Kansas Union burned during one of the ...

/news/2010/apr/20/generation-ablaze/

Once warriors, now students

Veterans wounded in combat fight to find a "normal" life on college ...

/news/2011/jul/27/once-warriors-now-students/

/comments/cr/33/587/#c164

Talk back: The 2008 Olympic Games in ...

What students say vs. what we say.

/news/2008/apr/25/talk_back_2008_olympic_games_beijing/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment