Tuesday, August 21, 2007
The genocide in the Darfur region of Sudan will likely be the prevalent human rights cause of our generation. Organizations all over the world have sought to bring attention to the slaughter of non-Arab Sudanese civilians at the hands of the government-backed Janjaweed militia. Yet, as refugees from the region flood into other parts of Africa and the Middle East, there are states that would wrongly deny them sanctuary.
Sunday, Aug. 19, Israel rejected admittance through their borders to roughly 50 African refugees. Their reasoning: It is against Israeli law to allow refugees from enemy states entry to the country. Sudan’s government is classified as an enemy of Israel. The fact that these refugees are also the enemy of the Sudanese government (which doesn’t officially carry out genocide, but supports those who do) apparently held no sway.
The refugees had traveled through Egypt on their way to Israel, and been allegedly subjected to brutality on the part of the Egyptian military, charges which Egypt has yet to respond to. However, Israeli military officials claim to have witnessed Egyptian officials executing and brutalizing refugees. The asylum-seekers who were turned away from Israel will likely be forced to return to Egypt, where they may be killed.
This is not a case of immigration for economic or even political prospects. The people escaping Darfur are literally running for their lives. Laws are generally the glue that holds societies and nations together, but in this case, Israeli law is unjust.
Many Israelis agree. Members of the Knesset, Israel’s legislative body, are signing petitions, urging the government to allow Sudanese refugees to remain in the country. Civilian volunteer workers are trying to help the 400 or so refugees who have been allowed to stay in Israel find housing and employment.
In an increasingly hostile region, Israel should have been a beacon of light to those whose livelihoods had been destroyed in Darfur. Instead, as has occurred all too often in this conflict (which has been going on since 2003), Israel turned out to be another dead end. It does not have to be this way.
Israel has the opportunity to do right by these asylum-seekers, and must remember that “the enemy of my enemy is my friend.” Its citizens and areas of its leadership seem eager to accept these people; now the government as a whole must become as progressive as its population.
Besides the fact that taking in these refugees is far and away the right thing to do, Israel stands to better its image with black African Muslims. While earlier civil conflicts in Sudan dealt primarily with religious strife (pitting Muslims against Christians and Animists), the Darfur massacre is mostly one of racial cleansing; according to the United Nations, most of its victims are Muslim.
Israel is usually in the news for its conflict with Palestinians. It could, however, grab notoriety for assisting numerous desperate people in their time of need. That, we maintain, would be a vast improvement.
Letters to the Editor: January 30, 2007
These people have an opinion. The Kansan values it.
Cosby: Sudan shouldn't focus on dress code
Sudanese women are forced to abide by a strict dress code.
Petterson: 2008 ‘Genocide Olympics’ a disgrace
China was selected as the site for the 2008 Olympic games, despite ...
Students feel burden of conflict in Gaza
Despite the distance between KU and Israel, the Gaza crisis still reaches ...
Letter to the Editor: Wrong label
Negotiating with Hamas would be like negotiating with Al Qaeda.
Cosby: Importance of foreign elections shouldn't be ...
Upcoming Sudanese elections represent larger fight for democracy.
No country for young men
Visa laws, refugee status and politics have contributed to one senior’s statelessness.
Former U.S. ambassadors to present “Genocide: What ...
Robert Beecroft and Edward Brynn will speak Thursday at the Robert J. ...
Cohen: Beliefs about Gaza should be more ...
The conflict in the Middle East isn't as clear-cut as some people ...
Kenny: Gazans overlooked in current border conflict
America's support of Israel is under-reported during this crisis.
Letter: US does care about Egypt and ...
A reader disagrees with our columnist's take on Egypt.
Anderson: What we didn’t learn after September ...
Jawhari: U.S. government should show more concern ...
America's diplomacy with Egypt shows little compassion for revolutionaries.
Activist speaks on issues in Sudan
Bobbie-Frances McDonald traveled to Africa eight years ago, witnessed conflict first hand.
Editorial Board: University’s study abroad restrictions justified
Program through University of Texas opens doors for travel
Sudanese genocide tests humanity of everyone
Al-Qaida leader bin Laden dead, body in ...
President Barack Obama confirms Osama bin Laden is dead in national address ...
This weekend
Rally to end the genocide in Darfur
Brinker: A democratic beginning does not guarantee ...
Seeds of liberal democracy may not spring exactly what Americans want to ...
Anderson: As U.S. activates its military, others ...
D.C. conference puts Darfur in the spotlight
The group Students Taking Action Now: Darfur, will hold its first national ...
Brinker: Arab people need help and support ...
History shows that democracy movements in authoritative countries rarely succeed. However, the ...
Letter to the editor: Egypt has the ...
The Egyptian people do not perceive the United States as being a ...
Anderson: Weak link in Obama’s armor
Obama's support of Israel raises curious questions of Apartheid and human rights.
Gaza Strip evacuations evoke strong emotion on ...
Cosby: Revolution must consider women’s rights
The Egyptian revolution provides an opportunity to advance women's rights.
Egyptian activist challenges students to go against ...
Egyptian feminist, psychiatrist and author, Nawal El Saadawi, shared with students Wednesday ...
Letter: Social media has fueled North African ...
New media has proven vital in Egyptian and Tunsian protest.
Anderson: Palestine needs our help
Israel receives more money than the Caribbean, Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa ...
Speaker gives presentation on business in Israel
Dan Senor discussed the state of the economy in Israel provides a ...
Groups dispel myths about Middle East conflict
With KU students returning to Lawrence, campus groups prepare for an onslaught ...
Hawk Topics
Raine Reviews: News You Can Use
Editorial Board: Delta Force platform reviewed
Former ambassadors discuss genocide, war
Former U.S. Ambassadors Edward Brynn and Robert Beecroft spoke to students about ...
Sandal: Drone missions counter-productive in war on ...
Bombing Pakistan with unmanned drones exacerbates poverty, which leads to extremism.
$1.4 million grant adds Amharic language to ...
Amharic is the official working language of Ethiopia but is offered by ...
Cosby and Adams: Is social media good ...
In light of the recent Egyptian Revolution sparked by social media, two ...
App helps advocate for peace in the ...
Falling Whistles visits the University, introducing its new app "FW+Faces" on Wednesday.
Jawhari: Egypt deserves US support in effort ...
The recent wave of popular uprising in North Africa should be a ...
Cosby: Future of Sudan relies on cessation ...
Intensified disagreements over cessation vote could derail progress in Sudan.
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Editorial: Escapees should be allowed refuge
The editorial states:
"Israel is usually in the news for its conflict with Palestinians. It could, however, grab notoriety for assisting numerous desperate people in their time of need. That, we maintain, would be a vast improvement."
I wish that were true. The good that Israelis have done for Sudanese victims has largely gone unnoticed and underappreciated. I hope that this criticism is not the very first time that the Kansan has mentioned Israel’s involvement with Sudanese refugees.
Israelis have provided international aid – whether for desperate Sudanese, hungry Muslims in Central Asia or impoverished African families – because it is the right thing to do, not because they might get a quid pro quo such as “notoriety.” When Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs launched international aid programs in the 1960’s, Foreign Minister Golda Meier knew full well that Israelis would probably reap no diplomatic benefit, but Israelis and their government helped newly decolonized Africans to feed themselves anyway, even after their new African governments failed to support Israel when she came under military attack.
During the Holocaust, Jews asked no single country to take all European refugees. Israelis should not be blamed for failing to solve the Darfur problem single-handedly. Nor should the very real security risks to Israelis involved in welcoming citizens of a hostile country be discounted. Israelis have helped many Sudanese families and will continue to do so. Other nations and even the UN must help as much as possible, too.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID