Editorial: Calling the race early

Media coverage of candidates focuses less on issues, more on electability

An already vocal lament about the 2008 presidential campaign, aside from its ridiculously early commencement, is the media’s focus on the hypercompetitive “horserace” aspect of it. Policy matters and substantive issues are largely ignored, displaced by endless polls, “favorable ratings,” and the imagery of battle.

But another aspect of the media’s coverage threatens to submarine a candidate before he even stands a chance: the predetermined declaration of who exhibits the best “electability.” Sunflower State native son Sam Brownback, his campaign in struggling infancy, is already a victim of this unfortunate trend.

Rarely will you see Brownback’s name in the media far from any number of demeaning adjectival terms: “fringe,” “long shot,” “little known,” et al. Because he lacks the name recognition of more prominent politicians like Rudy Giuliani, Brownback is relegated to the edges of the Republican field, far from those to whom the media ascribes “frontrunner” status.

nutgraf

There is no denying that Brownback lacks the celebrity of Giuliani or Senator John McCain.

We are thus presented with a vexing conundrum, electoral and semantic: to what extent does the media’s description of a candidate’s status simply reflect reality, and to what extent does it unfairly compel voters to dismiss a candidate based on his perceived lack of electability? Does the media’s description of a lesser known candidate in fact cement that candidate’s obscure standing, barring him from advancing toward possible election?

There is no denying that Brownback lacks the celebrity of Giuliani or Senator John McCain. But he is at least as accomplished as former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney, whose main credentials as a frontrunner seem to be a prodigious knack for raising money and an ever-evolving and politically expedient set of principles. However, the diminutive description of Brownback’s candidacy inherently prevents most voters from considering him, much less learning his stances of various policy areas.

For example, how many among us know that Brownback has been a vocal opponent of the troop surge in Iraq? Or that he is a leading supporter of aid to Darfur, the humanitarian cause du jour? He is often described as being ardently pro-life, but he also works to help children after birth, sponsoring bills to end sex trafficking and assist refugees. But these talking points are largely lost in the swirling media storm of polls, fundraising, and battleground states.

Take care to form your own opinions and interpretations of candidates and their platforms. Don’t let our preconceived election story angles—frontrunner, dark horse, long shot, etc.—define who you support or how you vote.

— McKay Stangler for the editorial board.

 

Related articles

Editorial: Presidential candidates seem stale

It's just the same old stories from many of the same old ...

/news/2007/may/09/stanglered/

Editorial: Voting a responsibility

Student Senate candidates spend countless hours in session and campaigning. As hard ...

/news/2007/apr/10/edvote/

Editorial: News an endless horse race

On and on they went, the Russerts and Schneiders of the world, ...

/news/2007/apr/09/mckayed/

Editorial: Campaign ideas disappoint

With student selections nearly upon us, this year's candidates have no new ...

/news/2007/apr/11/stanglered/

Editorial: U.S. should analyze Russia

Americans can get a good sense of where our democracy is headed ...

/news/2007/may/02/stanglered/

Editorial: Politicians sing sad song with poor

America’s middle class is wealthier than ever, yet citizens still worry about ...

/news/2007/feb/26/stanglered/

Editorial: Debates fail to fix problems

With most politicians bogged down in debates to see who can get ...

/news/2007/apr/25/stanglered/

Stangler: Manufactured outrage dooms radio

Statements on the radio run rampant when commentators are pressed to fill ...

/news/2007/apr/13/stranglered/

Editorial: We must stand tall

In the wake of the Virginia Tech tragedy it is only a ...

/news/2007/apr/18/stanglered/

Editorial: Votes need to count

Turnout in student elections remains low. Rather than ignoring the result, Student ...

/news/2007/mar/13/mckay/

Editorial: Trademarks probably not violated

The University has pending legal issues with Joe-College.com, which may be illegally ...

/news/2007/mar/08/strangler_ed/

Editorial: Bush’s ‘blind faith’ problematic

Bush’s veto of latest Democratic bill highlights the problems of the administration ...

/news/2007/may/03/stangler_ed/

Cohen: Gear up for caucuses

Politi-geek urges students to partake in elections

/news/2008/jan/29/op_cohen/

Third party candidates shake things up

Obama or McCain not speaking for you? Look at Nader or Barr.

/news/2008/nov/03/third_party/

Edwards, Giuliani abandon race

Democrat John Edwards and Republican Rudy Giuliani have dropped out of the ...

/news/2008/jan/30/edwards_giuliani_abandon_race/

Stangler: ‘Responsibility’ in danger

If an official takes ‘full responsibility’ for something, there should be no ...

/news/2007/mar/29/stangler_ed/

McKay’s bat powers Kansas to 2-1 weekend ...

The freshman has three home runs in four games.

/news/2012/mar/11/mckays-bat-powers-kansas-2-1-weekend-record/

Sen. Brownback addresses RNC delegates

He says Gov. Sebelius would lose Senate race for his seat, endorses ...

/news/2008/sep/05/convention/

/comments/cr/33/190/#c36

/comments/cr/33/587/#c164

Editorial: Positive war news overlooked

Iraq is bloody and violent, but there are positive advances being made. ...

/news/2007/mar/06/edmckay/

Stangler: Education policy needs revision

Bush's No Child Left Behind will be examined in the upcoming federal ...

/news/2007/feb/28/stanglered/

Compton: Looking ahead for state primaries

Chet Compton makes his predictions for Republican candidates.

/news/2010/may/03/compton-looking/

Editorial: Will the real Slim Shady please ...

The Editorial Board faces bigger issues as the Eminem maritial dispute continues ...

/news/2007/mar/30/edmckay/

/comments/cr/33/507/#c130

Editorial: Movies not a happy escape

You've heard it all before, but we swear it's true. Your relatively ...

/news/2007/apr/03/edmckay/

Three counties vote in Republican caucus, Huckabee ...

A crowded, but successful, Republican caucus brought hundreds of voters from three ...

/news/2008/feb/11/republican_caucus/

Using underwear to catch attention

For Sexual Violence Awareness Month the University is attempting to make students ...

/news/2009/apr/10/awareness/

Editorial: Afghanistan as important as ever

Pakistan, our nuclear-capable ally, is as precarious as ever, and a single ...

/news/2007/feb/27/mckay_ed/

Voters may not turn out

Even the historical nature of this year's election may not be enough ...

/news/2008/nov/03/turn_out/

Dole speaks at RNC event

The former senator and presidential candidate backs McCain, slams Obama

/news/2008/sep/04/dole_speaks_rnc_event/

Students learn self-defense tactics

TAKE program teaches protective skills for worst-case scenario attacks.

/news/2009/oct/21/students-learn-self-defense-tactics/

Editorial: Abstinence failing as sex education tool

A study commissioned by Congress proved the abstinence approach to sexual education ...

/news/2007/apr/20/mckayed/

Cohen: Dems’ indecision may cost them

The DNC needs to sort out the nomination, or it may regret ...

/news/2008/apr/29/cohen_dems_indecision_may_cost_them/

/comments/cr/33/507/#c133

A winter classic reborn

Don't let your inner Ebenezer let you miss this one. "Scrooged" updates ...

/news/2006/dec/11/winter_classic_reborn/

Democrats retain hope in wake of losses

Despite losing all major races, members of the Democratic Party said is ...

/news/2010/nov/03/democrats-retain-/

Live Blog: Midterm Elections

Follow our coverage of local elections from reporters and wire services throughout ...

/news/2010/nov/02/live-blog-midterm-elections/

University leaders see victory in state budget

Gov. Brownback’s proposal avoids additional cuts for higher education

/news/2011/jan/20/university-leaders-see-victory-state-budget/

Does gender matter in politics?

Kelly Cosby and Billy McCroy discuss women in politics.

/news/2011/oct/27/gender-doesnt-matter/

Comments

Yeah, Brownback is a joke. But I don't think that's what this guy is saying. It doesn't ever sound pro-Brownback. Just anti-media.

Brownback is around 1-2% in the polls. He is probably going to stay at that level because he is one of the worst candidates in the race.

Brownback does not stand a chance against Giuliani, McCain, Tom Tancredo, or even Ron Paul. Tancredo and Paul understand what the U.S. Constitution is--Senator Brownback does not.

Brownback is responsible for one of the most ridiculous, ANTI-FAMILY, UNCONSTITUTIONAL laws in the history of the United States. This pathetic bill cosponsored by Senator Brownback is known as the "International Marriage Broker Regulation Act" (or IMBRA).

This draconian bill, which became law on March 6th, 2006, implies that ALL Americans (mostly Conservative American men) are violent sexual abusers and wife beaters unless proven innocent. I DISAGREE!!!

IMBRA was discreetly attached to another bill, the 'Violence Against Women Act of 2005'. This law is better described as the 'International Romance Regulation Act', which is exactly what it is. Under Senator Brownback's outrageous law, all Americans (mostly conservative American men), must submit a detailed criminal background report in order to communicate with a woman in a foreign country. How absurd! The form is likely to get lost in the mail, and she will have no incentive to respond and send back her approval (again by postal mail) without a photo or bio. This law applies for all forms of communication including: e-mail, telephone, postal mail, text messaging, and in-person meetings. Penalties are severe: $25,000 fine and up to 5 years in prison for saying 'Hello'!

In order to drum up support for his atrocious bill, Senator Brownback along with other proponents (radical feminist group Tahirih Justice Center) concocted the sinister-sounding label 'marriage broker'. What is a 'marriage broker'? It is nothing more than an introduction or penpal service. So now all-of-a-sudden according to the U.S. Government, a penpal service will now be known as a 'marriage broker'. For your information Senator Brownback, nobody is getting married, and nobody is being 'brokered' when two consenting heterosexual adults decide to communicate.

This law also has also scrutinized ALL international marriages no matter how the couples actually met. Most international marriages do not involve sinister-sounding 'marriage brokers', but because the government has no way of knowing how a couple actually met (it is none of their business anyways), they decided to crack-down on visa petitioners. Now any irrelevant DUI's, misdemeanors, fraudulent protection orders, and even arrests not leading to any conviction must be disclosed to your fiancee, which is a good way to become un-engaged. This is exactly what Senator Brownback and the feminists want. Their goal was to shut down introduction agencies and to keep American men away from foreign women. This law is a SCANDAL based on fraud, deception, cooked statistics, 'manufactured' hysteria and propaganda regarding abuse and trafficking of foreign women to support ulterior motives. In reality, THERE HAS NEVER BEEN ANY CONVICTIONS FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING INVOLVING AN AMERICAN-OWNED INTRODUCTION AGENCY. And THERE ARE NO DOCUMENTED CASES OF ABUSE OF FOREIGN WOMEN BY AMERICAN MEN PRIOR TO MARRIAGE.

On December 16th, 2005, Senator Brownback told his colleagues in the Senate that the "Tahirih Justice Center are frontline experts" and that customers of 'marriage brokers' (a false label) "need to clean up their act". No Senator Brownback, you "need to clean up your act". After he was elected, he took an oath to uphold the Constitution. But his draconian law violates the 1st, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, 9th, and 10th Amendments to the Constitution.

Senator Brownback claims to be Pro Life, yet for this bill he teamed-up with radical left wing Senator Maria Cantwell (D-WA) who openly supports the murder of human fetuses. He claims to support traditional marriages, yet his asinine bill criminalizes communication and love letters by heterosexuals. He has partnered with a wacko feminist not-for-profit organization named after an Iranian martyr: the Tahirih Justice Center. Senator Brownback has alot of explaining to do.

He as an embarrassment to the Republican Party and he has NO possibility of winning the nomination.

Freedom-- While your tirade against all things Brownback is impressive, I'm not sure it fits as a response to this column. If you reread the column, you will see that at no point is support for Brownback advocated, or even alluded to. The point is that the media tend to decide for themselves the standing of candidates, even before they enter a race and even after they start changing their status. This column tries to remind voters, using an example of a local candidate, that it is essential to decide your voting preferences on your own.

The list of Brownback policies is not meant to support him, nor does it do so. It merely shows that his background is deeper than what his media designation implies, which is always simply some variation of "long shot, pro-life, darling of conservatives," etc.

Your litany against him shows that you have gone beyond the surface description and investigated him for yourself-- the exact embodiment of the column's point. Let's hope we all do the same.

Sign in to comment