Robinett: Rivalry shirts get uglier

Missouri’s new shirt contains message insulting to more than just Kansas fans

Let’s tally the score for recent classless T-shirts inspired by the rivalry between Kansas and Missouri.

— Kansas’ Muck Fizzou shirts, which suggest offensive language: one to the Jayhawks.

— Missouri’s new Quantrill’s Raid shirt, which was posted by Nathan Fowler on his AOL sports blog on Monday and portrays Lawrence burning to the ground with “SCOREBOARD” underneath the picture: somewhere between 150 to 200 to the Tigers.

That’s how many people died that morning in early August 1863. No one is sure of the total, said Jennifer Weber, assistant professor of history.

“It was cold-blooded murder,” she said.

Lawrence was the headquarters of the Kansas abolitionist movement and the most prominent anti-slavery city in the state. The Civil War was two years underway, and five years had passed since Bleeding Kansas died down.

A federal law made it illegal to aid confederate guerillas — of course, this was aimed to stop Quantrill and his men. In turn, all the wives, mothers and sisters of these men were rounded up and jailed in Westport. The jail collapsed, killing four women and one girl. Weber said that Quantrill claimed the deaths were the immediate cause of his infamous raid.

“Quantrill came with people in mind who he wanted to kill,” Weber said. But he didn’t get any of them.

Instead, his raiders swept through Lawrence on horses, killing any man they found. Many of the victims were shot in the back as they tried to run away, defenseless. Then Quantrill, the man who taught outlaw Jesse James his trade, took a torch to the business district and was on his way by noon.

On the back of this controversial T-shirt, which MU students thought up, is a Quantrill quote: “Raise the black flag and ride hard, boys. Our cause is just and our enemies many.”

More surprising than the T-shirts themselves is that everyone I called at Missouri on Wednesday and Thursday — the athletics department, the multicultural department, three history professors and Missouri’s student newspaper, The Maneater — either hadn’t heard about the shirts or didn’t call me back. A Missouri logo is in clear view on the front of the shirt, and more than a day had passed since the shirts surfaced on the Web.

“Obviously we wouldn’t be endorsing something of that nature that definitely steps over the lines of good taste,” said Chad Moller, Missouri’s assistant athletic director for media relations. “If a shirt like that has an official MU mark on it, then what we would do is turn to our licensing people on campus.”

Apparently some Missouri fans think it’s OK to make T-shirts that glorify a band of murderous racists.

Their cause was slavery. Their enemies were abolitionists. They took the lives of many without regret and wanted to keep freedom away from men like Gus Rigdel, who in 1950 was Missouri’s first black student, and Norris Stevenson, who in 1957 was Missouri’s first black football player.

If Quantrill’s politics had prevailed, these two would have been in shackles instead of earning college degrees. The same goes for every black student at Missouri today, especially those who are NCAA student athletes. Can fans cheer them on by celebrating Missouri’s racist history?

“Unfortunately, Missouri has that cloud hanging over its head,” said Carol Anderson, a professor of history at the University of Missouri, who provided me with information about Rigdel and Stevenson.

Missouri’s violent pro-slavery past should be discussed in history classes rather than plastered on a T-shirt.

At Kansas, our mascot is based on the Kansas militants, known as Jayhawkers, who fought for slavery’s abolition. That’s something to be proud of.

Would any right mind argue the contrary today? Perhaps these insensitive Missouri fans, who will wear their new T-shirts and think them clever, but I hope fans of both schools disagree. Otherwise, what has this sporting event become? For the people wearing the shirts, it’s not just a rivalry or an opportunity to display poor sportsmanship, ala Kansas and Muck Fizzou, and it’s definitely not a joke. It’s pure hatred.

“It’s certainly in questionable taste, I would say, and it’s certainly insensitive,” Weber said. “It also suggests how out of control some people get with sports. There are no limits.”

— Edited by Tara Smith

 

Related articles

Border Showdown's roots run deep

Rivalry linked to Civil War-era conflicts.

/news/2009/nov/17/border-showdowns-roots-run-deep/

Raid rivalry shirt made for personal use

The Missouri alumnus who designed and printed four KU-MU rivalry T-shirts said ...

/news/2007/nov/20/raid_rivalry_shirt_made_personal_use/

KU vs. MU begins in heated rivalry

KU fans have taken many traditions from the competition, which originated with ...

/news/2009/nov/17/ku-vs-mu-begins-heated-rivalry/

Kansas, Missouri rivalry heats up

With the heightened stakes riding on this Saturday’s game, the trash talking ...

/news/2007/nov/20/kansas_missouri_rivalry_heats/

Erickson: Remind me: Which state are we ...

/news/2008/oct/22/erickson_remind_me_which_state_are_we_again/

Documentary examines Kansas—Missouri “Border War”

An alum’s film explores the rivalry — one that is rooted not ...

/news/2008/nov/18/border_war/

University to replace ‘Muck Fizzou’ slogan

Last year, ESPN announced that it would not show KU students wearing ...

/news/2007/oct/25/Shirts/

Border rivalry renamed ... again

/news/2005/apr/01/features_tib_rivalry/

Winning T-shirt slogans revealed

The contest to create new slogans to replace the “Muck Fizzou” shirt ...

/news/2007/nov/12/Shirt/

Historic Murphy-Bromelsick House now open to public

John Speer built the house and advocated for University and rebuilding Lawrence ...

/news/2009/jul/13/house/

Students clean historic battlefield

The Center for Community Outreach is traveling to Baldwin City to clean ...

/news/2007/nov/09/black_jack/

Former Kansas students make YouTube hit

The video focuses on the history of the Kansas-Missouri rivalry.

/news/2012/mar/28/former-kansas-students-make-youtube-hit/

Letter to the Editor

Mizzou designer explains position in ‘Scoreboard’ shirt

/news/2007/nov/20/letter_editor/

Museum to commemorate anniversary of raid

Local historians will host a tour of downtown locations to discuss William ...

/news/2010/aug/20/museum-commemorate-anniversary-raid-40-char/

Joe-College.com faces off with Athletics Department in ...

Local apparel store’s famous T-shirts “Muck Fizzou” may become a thing of ...

/news/2008/jun/26/joecollege/

Missouri natives feel rivalry’s heat

For some KU students, the Border Showdown hits closer to home

/news/2009/nov/17/missouri-natives-feel-rivalrys-heat/

Nelson: Rivalry will be missed

Missouri's decision to leave the Big 12 has unfortunate effects on the ...

/news/2011/nov/09/nelson-rivalry-will-be-missed/

Editorial: Missouri betrays long-standing traditions

With Missouri's choice of money over regional values, Kansas students need to ...

/news/2011/nov/06/editorial-missouri/

"NMT" post ignites false Twitter controversy

A post on a popular Missouri message board sparks backlash throughout Jayhawk ...

/news/2012/jan/29/-post-ignites-false-twitter-controversy-border-/

Buser: Rivalry builds school spirit

Illinois senior reflects on four years of participation in Border Showdown

/news/2009/nov/17/buser-rivalry-builds-school-spirit/

Jury rules against Joe-College.com

The T-shirt retailer must pay the University more than $100,000 and desist ...

/news/2008/jul/14/joecollege/

Editorial: Shirts hurt University’s image

The University of Kansas is linked with many outstanding people and accomplishments. ...

/news/2007/mar/08/riggins_ed/

Don’t muck with my T-shirt

The Student-Athlete Advisory Committee held a meeting Monday night to begin work ...

/news/2007/sep/25/dont_muck_my_tshirt/

History "En Mass:" Lawrence Rising

Today's epicenter of student recreation, Massachusetts Street, is a long way from ...

/news/2012/mar/29/history-en-mass-lawrence-rising/

Morning Brew: Don’t waste 2009 T-shirts

KU should follow the lead of a Tennessee football T-shirt donation.

/news/2010/jan/14/brew-dont-let-2009-football-shirts-go-waste-se/

McLeod: T-shirt issue borders on censorship

Offensive or not, the “Muck Fizzou” shirt is still embodiment of student ...

/news/2007/oct/01/Censorship/

Minster: KU athletics greedy for revenue

The KU athletics department wants to bring down Joe-College.com for not paying ...

/news/2007/mar/15/minster/

Showdown brings unique rivalry beyond athletes

Team rivalries go beyond universities.

/news/2009/nov/17/showdown-brings-unique-rivalry-beyond-athletes/

/comments/cr/33/5337/#c1171

Filmmaker remembers historic raid

Nearly 150 years ago, William C. Quantrill led an attack on Lawrence ...

/news/2007/aug/22/raid/

Editorial Board: T-Shirt controversy could be a ...

Students should promote class, not hatred

/news/2007/sep/27/Editorial/

He’ll always be a Jayhawk

Former head football coach Don Fambrough will never lose his love for ...

/news/2009/oct/08/hell-always-be-jayhawk/

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Bryan Wheeler talks about what to expect from the 2008 Kansas football ...

/news/2008/aug/29/column/

Historic attire: Two rival mascots and the ...

School mascots also linked to Civil War history.

/news/2009/nov/17/historic-attire-two-rival-mascots-and-stories-behi/

Border Showdown represents old rivalry

The year-long competition based on a point system continues the competition between ...

/news/2009/nov/17/border-showdown-represents-old-rivalry/

Voting open for traditions T-shirts

The contest is modeled after Notre Dame’s yearly shirt, which students and ...

/news/2008/nov/06/voting_open_traditions_tshirts/

Morning Brew: Alum's documentary offers Border War ...

/news/2008/sep/25/morning_brew_alums_documentary_offers_border_war_p/

Letter to the Editor

Game day and rivalry shirts should reflect positive spirit of KU. Slogan ...

/news/2007/nov/08/letter_editor/

Letter to the Editor: Tiger in the ...

Mizzou fan reflects on the positives from the three years spent on ...

/news/2009/dec/07/letter-editor-tiger-phog/

Women's basketball supports breast cancer awareness

The women’s basketball team will participate in the annual Jayhawks for a ...

/news/2011/feb/17/support-breast-cancer-awareness/

Comments

While I agree that the Mizzou shirts are over the line, I can't help but point out the fact that the Kansas Jayhawkers were doing the exact same things in Missouri that Quantrill did over here. That is why it's called the Border WAR (not the PC "Showdown")

anyone see the shirts we made to fight back?

John brown, gun and bible in hand, with text tht reads "Kansas, keeping America safe from missouri since 1853"

Now that, is a classy come back...

Sign in to comment