McLeod: T-shirt issue borders on censorship

As an institute of higher learning, KU believes that the freedom for a student to express him or herself is paramount to the development of a diverse and educated mind. That is, until the student wears an almost vulgar T-shirt on national television. In numerous repeat offenses freedom of student speech has undergone scrutiny, questioning exactly how far that freedom extends. Campuses around the U.S. are addressing the same question that KU now must ask itself: how much censorship is too much?

Last week College Republicans at Colorado State University called for the resignation of the campus paper’s editor-in-chief because he published a column entitled, “Taser This: F--- Bush” on the opinion page as a response to the Tasering of a University of Florida student. The blatant “F--- Bush” free speech stunt was harshly criticized by conservative students at CSU. Businesses that invested in the college paper have already pulled more than $30,000 worth of advertisements, afraid of bad publicity.

In 2004 a stink was raised at Texas A&M about a T-shirt that read “F#%k John Kerry.” (Spelling and use of expletives is correct.) The plaintiff’s argument was based on the accusation that the shirt promoted rape.

nutgraf

Mizzou sells a T-shirt with an upside-down Jayhawk on the front, and above it is written “Flip the Bird.” Should ESPN be concerned that even though the shirt isn’t actually flipping off KU, it is still suggesting the offensive action?

True, wearing suggestively vulgar shirts isn’t classy, but it is a tradition in sports rivalries. Other popular versions of the shirt include “Wuck Fazzu,” “Muck Fichigan” and “Tuck Fexas.” Those shirts are simply stating an opinion that “I Hate _____” wouldn’t do justice for.

Mizzou sells a T-shirt with an upside-down Jayhawk on the front, and above it is written “Flip the Bird.” Should ESPN be concerned that even though the shirt isn’t actually flipping off KU, it is still suggesting the offensive action?

It is foolish and reprehensible for the University itself to condemn the Muck Fizzou shirts, taking a dangerous step down the slippery slope of violating students’ First Amendment rights. Censorship is designed to protect people from potentially harmful slurs that would directly incite riots or violent behavior, directly provoke discrimination and directly offend mass groups of people. It is not, however, designated as the baby-sitter, putting children in time-out for having a potty mouth.

Should we start wagging our fingers at every potentially offensive thing printed on a T-shirt or in a newspaper? Should we not be allowed to wear anything controversial when there is a possibility of being on national TV? Or maybe the parking department could take on the additional task of ticketing people who utter any sort of fighting words.

Case in point, students should be able to wear what they want, provided that any sort of message stays within the protectable boundary of the constitution. The University knows that, and should be fighting to keep it that way instead of fighting to keep the athletic department’s revenue flowing from ESPN ads and publicity. Muck you, ESPN. Leave my T-shirt alone.

McLeod is an Overland Park senior in journalism and Middle Eastern Studies.

 

Related articles

/comments/cr/33/4480/#c936

University to replace ‘Muck Fizzou’ slogan

Last year, ESPN announced that it would not show KU students wearing ...

/news/2007/oct/25/Shirts/

Editorial Board: T-Shirt controversy could be a ...

Students should promote class, not hatred

/news/2007/sep/27/Editorial/

Winning T-shirt slogans revealed

The contest to create new slogans to replace the “Muck Fizzou” shirt ...

/news/2007/nov/12/Shirt/

Joe-College.com faces off with Athletics Department in ...

Local apparel store’s famous T-shirts “Muck Fizzou” may become a thing of ...

/news/2008/jun/26/joecollege/

Don’t muck with my T-shirt

The Student-Athlete Advisory Committee held a meeting Monday night to begin work ...

/news/2007/sep/25/dont_muck_my_tshirt/

Robinett: Rivalry shirts get uglier

A T-shirt celebrating a victory for racism tarnishes the tradition more than ...

/news/2007/nov/16/robinett/

Two journalism students win Hearst Awards

The foundation has given more than $500 million in grants and awards.

/news/2008/jan/17/hearstbrief/

/comments/cr/33/7627/#c2964

Joe-College.com company may be shut down

Swimming team shirts with sperm on them are not the kind of ...

/news/2007/mar/06/lawsuit/

/comments/cr/33/4480/#c937

Athletics Dept. wants to get that $*@#ing ...

Officials are again asking students to stop chanting a popular phrase at ...

/news/2008/sep/09/chant/

Cohen: Let the fans speak for themselves

T-shirts and chants are just part of the atmosphere

/news/2007/oct/23/cohen/

/comments/cr/33/11760/#c8466

/comments/cr/33/8213/#c3934

/comments/cr/21/265/#c2777

/comments/cr/33/7394/#c2778

Jury rules against Joe-College.com

The T-shirt retailer must pay the University more than $100,000 and desist ...

/news/2008/jul/14/joecollege/

Editorial: Shirts hurt University’s image

The University of Kansas is linked with many outstanding people and accomplishments. ...

/news/2007/mar/08/riggins_ed/

Letter: Why I decided not to shop ...

/news/2008/dec/09/letter_joecollege/

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Bryan Wheeler talks about what to expect from the 2008 Kansas football ...

/news/2008/aug/29/column/

Voting open for traditions T-shirts

The contest is modeled after Notre Dame’s yearly shirt, which students and ...

/news/2008/nov/06/voting_open_traditions_tshirts/

Vulgar kickoff chant draws criticism

‘Muck Fizzou’ is on its way out, and the Athletics Department thinks ...

/news/2007/oct/09/vulgar_kickoff_chant_draws_criticism/

Border rivalry renamed ... again

/news/2005/apr/01/features_tib_rivalry/

Editorial: Encyclopedia project deserves objectivism

To be effective, WiKUpedia should be run by an independent student group.

/news/2008/feb/15/editorial/

Student to share experiences of trip to ...

David McLeod will give a lecture tonight about his research on frogs ...

/news/2008/oct/01/frogs/

/comments/cr/33/11760/#c8468

Minster: KU athletics greedy for revenue

The KU athletics department wants to bring down Joe-College.com for not paying ...

/news/2007/mar/15/minster/

/comments/cr/33/4872/#c1042

Yesterday's losers, today's trendsetters

/news/2005/aug/17/opinion_mcleod/

Morning Brew: Don’t waste 2009 T-shirts

KU should follow the lead of a Tennessee football T-shirt donation.

/news/2010/jan/14/brew-dont-let-2009-football-shirts-go-waste-se/

Unlicensed: A T-Shirt Tale

Meet Larry Sinks, the man behind JoeCollege.com and its controversial T-shirts.

/news/2008/dec/08/joecollege/

How to...

/news/2005/mar/16/festures_apartments_fixes/

/comments/cr/33/8227/#c4020

/comments/cr/33/4395/#c917

Battle over unlicensed T-shirts proceeds

The University sited trademark infringement against a local T-Shirt vendor in a ...

/news/2007/aug/30/Joe_college/

Letter: Other places on campus are vulgar, ...

/news/2008/oct/22/letter_other_places_campus_are_vulgar_too/

Letter to the Editor

Game day and rivalry shirts should reflect positive spirit of KU. Slogan ...

/news/2007/nov/08/letter_editor/

Student-led initiative tackles kick-off chant

Student leaders are looking for an alternative to the offensive phrase.

/news/2008/oct/09/studentled_initiative_tackles_kick_chant/

Robinett: T-shirts go to waste

Some students can’t reap benefits of free T-shirts because there are rarely ...

/news/2007/apr/17/robinett/

Comments

If Betsy McLeod and I have been reading the same articles, and have the same information about the problem with Muck Fizzou T-Shirts - Then I think she is missing the point.

The University of Kansas is not condemning the T-Shirts. They are not trying to take first amendment rights away from student. As far as I know, the T-Shirt campaign has absolutely nothing to do with the University itself, but rather student groups with University interests in mind.

ESPN also has its viewers in mind when they decide to censor T-Shirts like "Muck Fizzou" or other similar expressions. Knowing this, it would be plain ignorant to continue wearing offensive shirts because we would rather express our prefabricated message of hatred towards Mizzou, rather than wear something that actually promotes the great University we all attend.

You can muck ESPN all you want, but it is important to remember that it is a privilege, not a right, to have our games nationally televised. I for one, do not want to be the person that plays a part in taking that privelage away.

I agree that being censored slightly impairs our freedom of speech. However, it is also ESPN's freedom of press to omit things that they deem offensive. And ESPN did not have to tell us, that they are not going to air the students wearing shirts they deem offensive. We could have been left in the dark. So why not take this opportunity to our advantage, clean up our act and use our shirts to show off what kind of students we are at KU? I'm not saying that we have look like a bed a roses, but we could certainly be more creative than "MUCK FIZZU".

Sign in to comment