Monday, October 22, 2007
We’ve all been taught that the draft was terrible, and a last resort in a case of extreme military emergency or some such thing. But I beg to differ. Now there is something inherently bad about a forced recruitment, but it’s not the fact that it forces people to enter the army.
What’s bad about it is that we would ever be in a position that we need any people to fight, much less so many people that we have to force other people to fight as well.
People don’t want to go to wars themselves. People don’t want their kids to go to wars. And if it was a possibility that either they or their kids could be forced to go and possibly die in the name of something, then people are going to pay a lot more attention to, and be far more critical of, these attempted causes for military action.
nutgraf
The draft would scare the hell out of a lot of people our age, more so than any movement on the chameleon scale at Homeland Security.
As is, the military is fairly distant or a lot of people. So it’s pretty easy to decide that they should go out to another country and fight, and then say how much you appreciate it with a bumper sticker or Toby Keith CD.
So we end up with this situation where we get into military conflicts more easily and probably placidly without a draft, which in turns creates a greater need for soldiers, which then may lead to even more conflicts, via a sort of Madeline Albright, “if you got it, use it” foreign policy. Or we could reinstate the draft, which would make a lot of people angry.
But in the powerful, justified and important kind of angry that actually causes changes.
The draft would scare the hell out of a lot of people our age, more so than any movement on the chameleon scale at Homeland Security. And it would probably have the opposite effect. People would search a lot harder for ways to get out of our sticky situations and to, in the future, do everything we can to avoid any kind of mire, quag or not.
But the draft that our predecessors railed against would not really be effective to this end. To spread practical pacifism we need to have the range be broad and all inclusive.
Men and women, across all classes and occupations, between 18 and 30 years old, should all be eligible, with no exceptions. No deferrals for school, and especially no nepotistic exemptions for congressional family members.
If war was real a real possibility for everyone, then the Man is going to have to try a lot harder to convince us of any actions real worth.
White is a Colorado Springs, Colo., junior in journalism.
New Joint Chiefs Chairman visits Leavenworth
Newly Appointed Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Adm. Michael Mullen ...
Minster: Military activity should be voluntary
Draft damages morale and hurts efficiency.
Anderson: As U.S. activates its military, others ...
A generation ablaze
Forty years ago today, the Kansas Union burned during one of the ...
A look at KU's changing face of ...
University's turbulent past has evolved into a somewhat tranquil state of activism.
Thompson: What war means for the rest ...
McLeod: War hits home
Iraq conflict is personal for Marine’s fiance
Politically Correct: The ethics of torture tactics
Our panelists offer their opinions on whether torture should be permitted in ...
Weighing the collateral damage
Iraqi war veterans have trouble justifying civilian casualties on urban battlefields in ...
Students to soldiers
Facing possible deployment to Iraq or Afghanistan after graduation, 81 University students ...
Nobel Peace Prize Winner discusses student activism
Jody Williams, who won a Peace Prize for work on banning landmines, ...
Name of the game shows principle
‘The Border War’ became ‘The Border Showdown’ after the start of the ...
KU vets see potential in Obama administration
Veterans at the University hope Obama’s and his cabinet picks can bring ...
Bornstein: Battling with — and under — ...
Prohibiting openly gay men and women from participating in the military benefits ...
The Department of Defense heads to KU ...
Blogs are helping better inform people about the military
Salsbury:Imagining the United States without the military
Costa Rica doesn't have a military and seems to be doing just ...
Once warriors, now students
Veterans wounded in combat fight to find a "normal" life on college ...
Bennett: Freeing Libya and the world is ...
Congrats on your "freedom," Libyans, but Obama's war on Libya was unconstitutional ...
Protestors should be prepared with informed opinions
Letter to the Editor
Draft is not a path to enlightenment
KU ROTC honors veterans with ceremonies
KU ROTC gives ceremonies to at the three memorials and an address ...
Forum series offer student insight on war ...
The Dole Institute of Politics invites experts on the Irag war to ...
Week of events promotes Veterans Day
Holiday observed with programs, opening of study hall in Burge Union.
Counterpoint: Humanitarian crisis in Syria
The U.S. has a moral duty to intervene in Syria.
Bush’s reasons for Iraq war all excuses
Letter to the Editor: No pride in ...
Stories of measures taken to avoid draft during the Vietnam War are ...
George H.W. Bush receives award, answers questions ...
The former president visited the University to receive the Robert J. Dole ...
Petterson: Darfur not the only global catastrophe ...
Bangladesh’s woes comparable to more media-genic cause.
The realities of the military
A lack of exposure to the military creates dissonance between the perceptions ...
Panelists discuss women’s leadership roles in the ...
Four panelists will speak about how women’s roles in the military have ...
Unlicensed: A T-Shirt Tale
Meet Larry Sinks, the man behind JoeCollege.com and its controversial T-shirts.
Q&A with Bryce Avary — The Rocket ...
Because we have questions. Celebrities have answers.
Blog: Basic Training
Reporter Kelly Stroda is spending six days at Ft. Leavenworth and Ft. ...
Lowell: How are borders drawn on the ...
The World Wide Web is redefining international threats to security.
Guest Column: As it continues, the Iraq ...
Sustained combat, lack of foreseeable end offer grim prospects for the future
Letter to the Editor: Blind faith doesn't ...
Dodging the draft was more than skirting service.
Q&A with Congressman Kevin Yoder
Rep. Kevin Yoder, KU alumnus answers questions after a lecture at the ...
From left: Kimberlee Hinkle, Libby Johnson and Hannah ...
1 comment
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
Comments
White: Draft would change war proponents’ minds
I have some troubles with your opinion on the draft. The majority of Americans are currently against the wars which we are in. They are not subject to the risk of a draft though. Millions of Americans were supportive during World War II, but they were subject to the draft. Both of these situations that have actually happened contradict your thesis which doesn't have an actual test market. What we need to avoid armed conflict has nothing to do with the people at home. Just because someone is a pacifist doesn't mean they won't get hurt. Rather, we proper defenses can prevent a serious armed conflict. In this regards, our all volunteer military is one of the best, probably the best in the world. The reason is that the soldiers can trust each other because the majority want to be there. If we just grab people off the streets, it won't really matter if they get amazing training or not, they will not be as effective as someone who voluntarily entered the service. To best defend ourselves, we need to avoid the draft.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID