Wednesday, September 5, 2007
Land of the free, home of the brave. All men are created equal. These are just a few phrases that are often used to describe the freedom that is experienced here and that is desired by so many. But has this and does this always hold true? And if it doesn’t, why is that? We all know that immigration and the presence and status of non-white Americans has always been an issue. Within the past six years since Sept. 11, people and politicians alike have continued to express their concern regarding the presence of immigrants and minorities in the United States, or rather the presence of illegal immigrants.
The terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and then the war in Iraq has further heightened Americans’ awareness of those around them, mainly minorities and immigrants. As a society, we tend to focus on certain aspects pertaining to who commits these heinous acts and other various crimes. Those aspects include race, gender, religion and place of birth. As logical as that sounds, I remember reading about the tragic events that happened at Virginia Tech. As the identity of the gunman was made public, I kept thinking to myself, “They need to quit identifying him as a South Korean immigrant.” As important as that is to the police and maybe even the families, the public does not need to know that. People focus on nationality and race enough without the media’s help. All that does is to further cloud the already-mixed thoughts and feelings that Americans harbor toward immigrants and minorities.
More recently, the deaths of three Newark college students has brightened the light that has always been focusing on another group of immigrants, Hispanics. Two of the suspects are illegal Hispanic immigrants. What is inconceivable to me is that amidst all these tragic events and loss of young life, cold-hearted politicians have used those events as leverage in their political campaigns to promote support for anti-immigration and stricter border policies. If they are going to fight for stricter border control and policies, use something other than those deaths to do so.
By labeling the suspects as illegal Hispanic immigrants, it again focuses on nationality. You often hear about violent crimes in which people are mutilated and murdered by a loved one. A man in Kansas City dropped his sick and elderly wife off of a balcony, but the media didn’t identify the man as being the white suspect from Kansas City.
Although I’m not the biggest advocate of deportation and strict immigration policies, that to me is not the issue at hand. The issue is how the media’s labeling further perpetuates these anti-immigration feelings that are harbored by so many. Last year in my ethics class, I discovered that many of my fellow classmates here at KU felt negatively towards Hispanic immigrants. As a Mexican-American student on a Minority Scholarship, I remember being particularly offended when a student expressed that they were not fond of the idea of scholarships being ‘handed’ to students just because they are minorities.
All these feelings of malcontent that are used in political campaigns are being passed on to the younger generations. If you do agree with stricter border policies, do so for a logical reason, not because you’re afraid of everyone from the Middle East or because you don’t like the fact that Jose can’t speak English muy bien.
McNaughton is a Topeka junior in journalism.
McNaughton: Immigration about more than give and ...
Some people have ignored the reasons behind immigration, letting their biased views ...
Letter to the Editor: Immigration problems fueled ...
Controlling illegal immigration should be confronted at both federal and local levels.
Arguing immigration
Many factors influence voters' positions on immigration.
Nine students oppose tuition law, seek relief ...
University kicks off Hispanic Heritage Month
Kobach addresses illegal immigration in speech
Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach addressed the effects of undocumented immigrants ...
McNaughton: Diversity still lacking
Diversity is often placed on the back burner in today’s society. Students ...
GTA reproaches Minutemen
Voices of dissent intend to be heard ...
Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach will visit the Lied Center on ...
Editorial: Student body deserves opportunity to ask ...
By not allowing audience members to engage in direct dialogue with him, ...
Celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month
KU students and members of the Lawrence community raise cultural awareness
Improbable Dream
Every day, the immigration issues infiltrate the news. This is the story ...
Strong recruiting increases minority enrollment
SUA hosts forum on immigration issues
Members of the panel expressed dismay at recent Arizona immigration bill.
Onions: Immigrants should be valued as job ...
With so many immigrants creating new businesses, America must renew its values ...
Spotlight on Organizations: HALO
Hispanic American Leadership Organization provides an outlet for students to learn about ...
Program gives voice to HALO issues
McNaughton: Readers should look beyond best-seller’s Christian ...
Focusing on a book's religious inconsistency misses its point.
Council seeks to spur Hispanic enrollment
Provost creates council to attempt to draw in more minority students.
McNaughton: Reflection on proper use of speech ...
Question causes reflection speech and sensitivity.
Letter to the Editor: Inappropriate to run ...
McNaughton: Fear of ‘the others’ still exists
Many still hold racist or prejudice views towards peers.
Science departments seek minority students
The University is working with other universities and designing its own programs ...
Professor discusses politics abroad
Burdett Loomis traveled to several countries talking about the U.S. government. He’s ...
McNaughton: Time to modify our image of ...
Spate of assaults should concern students.
Black Love Week is here
Anti-bullying bill in works
A New Jersey senator proposed legislation to prevent harassment in federally funded ...
Police to step up patrolling temporarily to ...
The patrol increase is part of a national two-week program.
Credit or no credit for graduate students?
Potential policy change would offer graduate students credit or no credit option.
Director of Multicultural Affairs resigns
Robert N. Page Jr. announced his resignation because of personal matters.
Film festival expands students’ horizons
This year, the Center of Latin American Studies is showing four documentaries ...
Editorial: KU needs stronger policies on alcohol
The Kansan supports establishing tighter controls on underage drinking.
First Amendment, controversial protests up for debate
'Is Nothing Sacred?' inspects the free speech case Snyder v. Phelps.
Senate, HALO boost bill
Study shows Hispanics have lower cancer risk
Living in limbo: Raul
Raul is pictured on a KU recruitment poster that says "You have ...
Some students receive in-state tuition despite being ...
KU will not forward letters from RIAA
The University is modifying its three-strikes policy for illegal download activity on ...
From left: Kimberlee Hinkle, Libby Johnson and Hannah ...
1 comment
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
Comments
McNaughton: Profiling never acceptable
I won't profile by race, nationality or gender as long as you don't profile when selecting a sexual partner.
McNaughton: Profiling never acceptable
Hey... Is the town still blurry?
"Land of the free, home of the brave. All men are created equal. These are just a few phrases that are often used to describe the freedom that is experienced here and that is desired by so many. But has this and does this always hold true? And if it doesn’t, why is that?"
Why are you asking me questions? You're the columnist.
Overall, I agree with the point you are making, but the article is just pointless. You basically just are saying "profiling is bad." Profiling IS bad. It's necessary to say (as you always notice) that a person is a white male, etc., when they are being looked for as a criminal. I realize what you are trying to say, but at times, it is necessary to maybe try and write it a little better...
McNaughton: Profiling never acceptable
while the first column by the author was atrociously pointless, i was pleasantly surprised by this one. it had a thought-provoking message and evidenced a much clearer writing style. i too often wonder why a person's race is brought up so many times in connection with crime - especially when the suspect is already found and a description is not necessary. the examples she mentioned were excellent. and she was dead-on by noting the animosity towards immigrants. the irony is of course that everyone except Native Americans are immigrants, so if anyone has a right to be anti-immigration, it is definitely the Native Americans. but i digress...the point of the matter is this article was very good, especially considering the fact that the op-ed pieces this year have been mostly unremarkable so far.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID