Thursday, September 27, 2007
Oklahoma State coach Mike Gundy’s three and a half minute long post-game tirade on Saturday hit close to home for a graduate of the University of Kansas School of Journalism.
Jenni Carlson, a former University Daily Kansan columnist and sports editor, was the reporter on the receiving end of Gundy’s rant.
Carlson wrote a column, printed last Saturday in The Oklahoman, suggesting OSU quarterback Bobby Reid was benched for his attitude and not his play. The column insinuated, through an anecdote about Reid’s mother feeding him chicken near the team charter, that Reid was coddled and didn’t possess the mental or physical toughness for the position.
Gundy lashed out at Carlson at a press conference after OSU’s 49-45 victory against Texas Tech. When he was finished, he stormed out of the room without taking any questions.
In the clip, which can be found on YouTube, Gundy said three-fourths of the column was “fiction” and called the newspaper “garbage.”
On Monday, Carlson had her first chance to ask Gundy for a clarification. During the coach’s Monday news conference, Carlson asked, “You contended three-fourths of that column was inaccurate; could you tell me what those factual errors were?”
Gundy responded, “I don’t have to.”
Carlson continued by saying, “Our paper has a policy of correcting errors, and I can’t do that if I don’t know what the errors were.”
“I don’t have to,” Gundy said again. “I’d rather just let it go.”
Lawrence Journal-World sports reporter Tom Keegan, who covered Major League Baseball for 18 years and now writes about KU sports, said Gundy’s overreaction showed how much the coach had been spoiled by local media.
“I think it’s interesting that he said three-fourths of the story is wrong, she asks him what the errors are, and he isn’t able to come up with anything,” Keegan said. “His inability to point to one single thing shows that not one thing in the story was wrong.”
Keegan said Gundy’s actions were “completely out of bounds.” He did say, however, that he doesn’t cover amateur athletes in the same way as professional athletes.
“Right or wrong, my way of doing it, I am not as critical of the college athlete as a professional athlete because they aren’t getting paid,” Keegan said. “I’m analytical and critical of the performances, but I do it a different way.”
Keegan is no stranger to tongue lashings. While covering the Dodgers, Tommy Lasorda once chewed him out while, ironically, eating chicken.
“I actually swallowed some of Tommy Lasarda’s chicken spittle,” Keegan said.
Gundy said in Monday’s press conference that he was just “shooting from the hip.” He took issue with Carlson’s portrayal of a “good kid” who had been “doing everything right,” both on and off the field.
On Saturday, Gundy called the editor of the article “garbage,” and said the situation “makes me want to puke.”
Carlson responded in a front-page Tuesday column in The Oklahoman by writing, “I will not stand on the sidelines and allow someone to attack my credibility.”
She also wrote, “I feel as adamant about the facts in that column as Gundy did in his belief that his player shouldn’t have been so scrutinized.”
Carlson declined The University Daily Kansan requests for comment.
In a Tuesday interview with ABC’s Good Morning America, Carlson said, “It was unbelievable that this was happening. I just was really not expecting that there was going to be this sort of outrage.”
The Oklahoman has stood behind Carlson and the column.
— Edited by Rachel Bock
Future KU student dies during trip to ...
Cowboys ready after difficult offseason
Business School moving beyond controversy
While searching for new dean, School of Business is addressing problems.
NEW: Giles transfers to Oregon State
Giles was kicked off the Kansas men's last fall, but has joined ...
OSU wide receiver to challenge Jayhawks
The Jayhawks haven’t forgotten their last matchup against Bowman, who scored four ...
Big 12 football teams rearrange line-ups
Check out an update of Big 12 school football player selections.
Texas-sized showdown highlights Big 12 games
Red Raiders try to upend Longhorns as Missouri and Oklahoma look to ...
Big 12 Football Wrap-Up
This week brought debate over the new, shorter play clock, and the ...
Big 12 Football Media Days: Addressing Realignment
The Big 12 Football Media Days have the whole Big 12 family ...
Slow start, but victory ensues
Seniors anchor linebacker position
Rising coaching salaries leave Mangino behind
What these high-dollar salaries do to universities and student-athletes is interpreted differently ...
Aggies’ practices belie game-time performance
Coach Mike Sherman addresses the loss, suggests likely personnel changes.
Jayhawks make comeback against Bears
Coach Ritch Price calls tonight’s win “the weirdest game he has ever ...
Thievery plagues the art and design building
Frequent complaints of stolen art supplies lead students to practice extra caution.
OSU coach sidelined by car accident
Conference report: the latest Big 12 news
There have been some last minute changes for the Big 12 teams.
Big 12 prepares for rule change
40-second play clock will now be used in effort to reduce the ...
Hold the presses: Talib’s back
Coming into Saturday’s game, junior cornerback Aqib Talib hadn’t grabbed an interception ...
Jayhawks succeed, break records in Kansas Relays
High school and college athletes, along with world-class Olympians, competed last week ...
Mangino addresses allegations on radio
Coach takes to airwaves to discuss investigation.
Investigation not a surprise to many Jayhawks
Current and former players react to the accusations of mistreatment by coach ...
Hall Center to hold lecture with T.R. ...
Writer and NPR regular will talk health care in the U.S. compared ...
Nystrom: Judging a coach by his cover
Mark Mangino has done wonders for KU’s football team, but offers from ...
Montemayor: Remark on Mangino unfit to print
Column should have centered on KU coaches’ handling of fight, using the ...
Suffering Jayhawks to face Tigers
After losing seven of its last eight matches, the Kansas volleyball team ...
Big 12 Media Day: Overview of Big ...
See how next Football seasons looks before it starts.
Morning Brew: Know the value of Vick
Vick deserves a second shot at football, despite past errors.
Big 12 football wrap up
Cowboys lost without Gundy, Leach criticizes officials
Kansas’ ability to create turnovers shows strength, ...
10-0 Jayhawks are one game closer to championship and bowl berths.
Meier to return to practice
Sales of the death men (part 2)
Only three people in Lawrence have had a green burial, despite the ...
A run to remember
Former Jayhawk Billy Mills won the impossible gold in the 10-k race ...
Band returns for two shows at the ...
Assembly of Dust brings "hick funk" to Wakarusa music fans.
Carmichael: A day in the life of ...
Compare your snow day with the adventures of Chance Carmichael.
Wiccan, not wicked
These witches don't ride on broomsticks or conjure potions
Mangino’s sideline rant goes public
At the end of his 77-yard punt return touchdown against Central Michigan, ...
Athletics Department reaches NCAA graduation goal
The Athletics Department released Graduation Success Rate data for its athletes on ...
Gill has high hopes, but are they ...
Despite a difficult season ahead, the Jayhawks still seem to ‘Believe.’
KU not commenting on Nutt
Ole Miss coach Houston Nutt is rumored to have been offered they ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID