Why aren’t people afraid of reading books about murder?

I once developed a wonderful method of killing someone with a tea bag. I was making tea at the time, standing by the sink with a dripping packet of Raspberry Zinger dangling from one hand, when inspiration dawned on me.

“Hey,” I said to my roommate. “I just thought of the greatest way to murder someone with a tea bag.”

After that, I don’t think she was eager to drink tea with me again. But the excuse for my somewhat eccentric line of thought was an overdose. Not, as might be assumed, a tea overdose, but rather a far more dangerous drug: mystery novels.

Author Agatha Christie recently lured me into the genre, and after devouring her I moved on to others without pause. It took about 120 murders or so before I realized how I was entertaining myself. I was whiling away time with death.

If the result of my addiction is a future as an ax murderer, at least I’ll have company. The mystery genre is intensely popular. It may have begun in the 19th century with Edgar Allen Poe’s “Murder in the Rue Morgue,” but the genre is still going strong in the 21st. It’s evolving, too: In the “Library Journal” Random House declared mysteries their most popular audiobooks.

The ever-steady demand for the genre seems odd, given that most mystery novels concern what few want to think about: death.

“The better fictional homicides today are accomplished — like those in real life — by shooting, strangling, stabbing, pushing (off cliffs and buildings and into water), bashing, and poisoning; not necessarily in the order named,” Howard Haycraft writes in “Murder for Pleasure,” a study of the mystery genre.

Writers have quite the menu of murder options, but no matter what the method homicide is still nasty. So why do we revel in doing away with our own kind?

Perhaps the genre’s modern success is rooted in its exploding variety. Today’s mysteries, like magazines, cater to niche demographics. Murder is committed in 17th century Japan and space stations in the future. The detectives are anything from hardened cops to elderly women.

“The mystery genre is just enormous and can satisfy anything you’re looking for,” said Lisa Stockton, a KU student and one of the owners of The Raven bookstore in downtown Lawrence, which specializes in selling mystery novels.

Stockton offers another reason for the genre’s popularity, saying, “There is a grisly aspect to it, but you regain a sense of order and justice” at the end.

The clue to the mystery genre’s success, then, is that ultimately the mystery is always solved. In a mysterious world with few explanations and death perhaps the most inexplicable of all, it’s reassuring to know that at least in mystery novels it will all make sense in the end.

As for my own brilliant murder method, I’ll discuss it with anyone interested over a nice cup of tea.

Blankenau is a Lincoln, Neb., sophomore in journalism and English.

 

Related articles

Time for Tea

Tea was discovered in 2737 B.C. by a Chinese Emperor. The world ...

/news/2006/apr/20/jp_timefortea/

Blankenau: Discovering the weird world of French ...

/news/2008/sep/04/blankenau_discovering_weird_world_french_cinema/

Capital punishment: Death to the death penalty

/news/2005/nov/14/capital_punishment/

More than a drink with jam and ...

America doesn’t embrace tea like much of the world, but increased domestic ...

/news/2007/nov/01/more_drink_jam_and_bread/

Holopirek: What’s next for Harry?

In honor of the recent release of the art for “Harry Potter ...

/news/2007/apr/09/jodi/

Performance art exhibit closes today

Ten music videos and recordings of 10 other performance art pieces play ...

/news/2008/dec/09/performance_art/

Harris:The death of bin Laden strikes differently ...

After serving in Iraq, a different feeling settles upon me in the ...

/news/2011/may/03/harris-death-bin-laden-strikes-differently-veteran/

Letter to the Editor: Hate crimes increasing

If the treatment of a community’s most vulnerable members represents society, then ...

/news/2007/apr/16/letter_ed/

Holtzen: The science of near death experiences

Scientific evidence doesn’t bode well for claims that NDEs require explanations beyond ...

/news/2010/nov/03/holtzen-science-near-death-experiences/

Kansas could abolish death penalty to cut ...

Hoping to reduce state spending, the Senate Judiciary Committee is considering a ...

/news/2010/jan/27/kansas-could-abolish-death-penalty-cut-costs/

Blog: Life and Music

Music: It's All Around You.

/news/2011/nov/30/blog-life-and-music/

Reviews

/news/2005/oct/20/reviews/

Cosby: Death to the death penalty

Capital punishment is inhumane and costly.

/news/2009/oct/14/cosby-death-death-penalty/

Stewart:Embarrassing secrets include Angela Landsbury

Writer’s ‘Murder She Wrote’ fix developed over the summmer

/news/2007/sep/06/stewart/

Schumaker: The Twilight Zone needs improvements

Advice on how to help turn the popular Sci-Fi show into a ...

/news/2011/oct/25/twilight-zone-needs-improvements/

Film Face-Off

/news/2005/feb/10/jayplay_movies_film/

McNaughton: Readers should look beyond best-seller’s Christian ...

Focusing on a book's religious inconsistency misses its point.

/news/2009/feb/23/mcnaughton_readers/

Free for All: May 8, 2007

My roommate just lost her shoe in the river on Tennessee.

/news/2007/may/08/free_all/

16-year-old could be tried as adult in ...

Kellam Jones now charged for one homicide instead of two.

/news/2008/jul/03/kellam/

Students enroll in unusual classes

The University offers some fun and unique courses to take.

/news/2009/jul/28/classes/

Folmsbee: A chiropractic reformation

Chiropractic must adjust ideology to be considered legitimate.

/news/2009/dec/04/chiropractic/

Lysen: Cliched television dramas meet their match

Comedian Paul Scheer's new show mocks the conventions of cop dramas and ...

/news/2011/sep/07/cliched-tv/

KU starting safety a fan of ‘Saw’ ...

Football player and humanitarian discusses the cleverness of Jigsaw’s method of rehabilitation.

/news/2008/oct/31/morning_brew/

James Gunn’s science fiction offers brave new ...

The professor emeritus of English has taught at University for decades, published ...

/news/2008/nov/13/james_gunns_science_fiction_offers_brave_new_world/

Osterhaus: Natural herb flavors students' day

For students seeking non-alcoholic alternatives, Kratom tea provides all that is needed ...

/news/2008/jan/23/osterhaus_natural_herb_flavors_students_day/

Williams: Don’t let stereotypes make up your ...

We should avoid making assumptions based on appearances.

/news/2007/aug/30/Williams/

Wanting a haunting?

A review of all the scary new kids on the block

/news/2007/oct/25/wanting_haunting/

Two Jayhawks experience family tragedies

Stewart and Jackson said they appreciated the their teammates’ and each other’s ...

/news/2008/feb/25/basketball_deaths/

A staggering tragedy

Friends and family look for answers while struggling to cope with an ...

/news/2009/apr/28/staggering_tragedy/

Movie review: 'The Lovely Bones'

Hollywood hits, indie flicks and everything in between.

/news/2010/jan/28/movie-review-lovely-bones/

Coldham: Hip-hop grows up

The era of southern gangster rap is being replaced with more modest ...

/news/2009/sep/10/coldham_grows_up/

Alumna author visits campus

University of Kansas alumna Laura Moriarty visists campus today. She will read ...

/news/2007/oct/17/alumna_author_visits_campus/

Don't call them 'sci-fi' enthusiasts

Science fiction writers, fans clear up differences; meet for summer workshop.

/news/2007/jul/11/dont_call_them_scifi_enthusiasts/

Muselmann: Go out, dress up, celebrate Halloween

Even if we’re too old to trick-or-treat, today is a rare opportunity ...

/news/2007/oct/31/muselmann/

Panel speaks out against book censorship

‘60s artists warn against the controlling of information.

/news/2010/sep/27/panel-speaks-out-against-book-censorship/

Coldham: Hip-hop balances differing styles

‘Gangster’ and ‘conscious’ rap contribute equally to hip-hop’s popularity.

/news/2009/nov/30/coldham-hip-hop/

Ghost

/news/2005/oct/27/ghost/

Dykman: Vonnegut’s death has left void

The death of the famous author still hurts today but it is ...

/news/2007/apr/19/dykman/

Movie review: 'Scott Pilgrim Vs. the World'

Hollywood hits, indie flicks and everything in between.

/news/2010/aug/19/movie-review-scott/

Letter to the editor: Hall Center lecturer ...

Alexander McCall Smith kept humble opinions of writing style

/news/2007/sep/27/letter_editor/

Comments

I enjoyed reading your article. I'm a UK Crime Writer of marine mysteries featuring my flawed and rugged DI Horton, and the author of two thrillers and obviously have a long term fascination with the genre. I know from my own reading experience and my reader feedback that what people like is a puzzle to solve, a mystery to pit their wits against, a thrill, lots of action and the psychology of characters. Yes, in fiction justice is indeed served and the results neatly tied up, not like in messy real-life.

Sign in to comment