A new meat market

Take another look at that chicken sandwich you had for lunch. Soon that meat could come from a chicken that never lived.

This doesn’t mean “living” in the existential sense. It means the chicken would simply be a hunk of flesh, cultivated in vitro in a lab, which is an idea being pushed by the animal rights organization People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, better known as PETA.

The group recently challenged the scientific community by offering a $1 million dollar prize for creating the first lab-grown meat. Not a soy or micro-protein product, but real meat, grown from a lab procedure and not from a live animal. PETA’s challenge has brought to the forefront controversial questions of the ethics and the dangers of genetic science.

According to an article published in April on the National Public Radio Web site, www.npr.org, in order to win PETA’s prize, the lab-grown meat “must have a taste and texture indistinguishable from real chicken flesh, be produced in sufficiently large quantities to be sold commercially, and successfully sold at a competitive price in at least 10 states.”

What are the implications of lab-grown meat for the average consumer? While it’s unlikely that such a product would hit the shelves anytime soon, the success of Boca, Morningstar and other brands of “fake” meats hints that this could be a viable industry.

“I think it’s an interesting idea,” says recent KU graduate Mikey Fletcher, who has been a vegetarian for the past five years. “I don’t think it will get many vegetarians to switch, though. There are already a lot of fake meat products out there, and many vegetarians aren’t looking to get meat back into their diet.”

Fletcher says he likes that people who had not considered vegetarianism before might be turned on to it through PETA’s work. However, Fletcher says going vegetarian is just one part of the larger puzzle of being environmentally conscious and caring about animal rights.

Danica Pollard, a chef at Lidia’s in Kansas City, Mo., says the idea is too weird for her to try. “But restaurants would definitely use it,” Pollard says. “There are cutting-edge places that would want to be the first to offer that kind of choice.”

Pollard says that while she wouldn’t eat it, she does like the idea that lab-grown meat could reduce animal suffering and lower the risk of diseases, such as the bird flu and mad cow disease, for consumers.

The United States has historically been a leader in technological innovation, and this would mark a milestone in food production. The impact of alternative meat could affect layers of society and could create new financial markets and rewards for newly created companies.

University of Kansas anthropology professor Don Stull explores the topic of meat packing workers and the problems hovering around the industry in his 2003 book Slaughterhouse Blues. Many slaughterhouse workers are immigrants and are often paid low wages for their repetitive, gruesome and grueling work.

Slaughterhouse Blues examines how the American meatpacking industry has changed since the 1970s. The location of the industry has switched to rural areas and many people are disconnected from their food’s source.

The book focuses on the historical perspective of the meat industry. It investigates modern meat production and the industrialization, which has encouraged factory farming in place of family-run farms. This effect can be measured by workers and the so-called, “Human Price of Our Meat.” Stull and co-author Michael Broadway noticed the trend for low-paid workers (salaries often under $20,000 per year) and injuries on the job.

The PETA challenge questions the ethics and practices surrounding the meat industry. From Burger King to The Jungle, people respond to investigative reporting that sheds light on sensitive subjects. But not everyone is optimistic about the announcement.

Animal rights activist Tyler Davis thinks PETA is missing the point. He says that while it was good for PETA to be focused on the smaller goal of getting people to stop consuming meat, PETA was overlooking the dangers of aligning themselves with companies such as Boca and Morningstar who are owned by Phillip Morris. Plus, they would be tampering with the food supply, the consequences of which would need to be studied over a period of many years to know if the modified food was truly safe.

Davis said he would much rather see PETA support sustainable farms.

“I would like to see PETA highlight the real alternatives like small, sustainable farms and show people the real problems with the meat industry,” Davis says. Not just animal cruelty but the health concerns with meat and the lack of transparency in the industries that deal with meat and alternative meat products.

KFC Canada has implemented “vegan” chicken into some stores after protests about cruelty in slaughterhouses that KFC was connected with. The events that play out in the next few years could shape the future of food in America.

 

Related articles

Greening it

Your guide to greener living

/news/2008/feb/21/greening_it/

Student group focuses on animal rights

Compassion for All Animals, or CAA, works to raise awareness of the ...

/news/2011/may/03/student-group-focuses-animal-rights/

Viva Vegetarian!

Campus offers a variety of options for vegetarians and vegans

/news/2011/feb/24/feature-vegetarian/

Veggie tales

Meat free— the way to be?

/news/2007/aug/23/veggie_tales/

Letter to the Editor: Cheap foods may ...

Spending more on fresh produce means paying for quality, while helping animals.

/news/2010/apr/12/letter-editor/

Schumaker: Please don’t yell at me for ...

PETA's intentions may be good, but their approach is laughable.

/news/2011/mar/18/eating-meat/

Greening it

Your guide to greener living

/news/2008/mar/13/greening_it/

Letter to the Editor: Shed light on ...

Students should be aware of treatment of animals.

/news/2010/mar/01/letter-editor/

Film sheds light on farming industry

“Food, Inc.,” showing at the Kansas Union tonight, encourages people to buy ...

/news/2009/nov/18/film-sheds-light-farming-industry/

Gentry: Vegetarians deserve people’s respect

Overall, Lawrence is friendly, but some could be more understanding

/news/2007/oct/23/gentry/

Blog: Vegging Out

Doing Without Eating Meat

/news/2011/nov/30/blog-vegging-out/

McConnell: Fish-eaters should stay alert

Is that salmon on your plate a delicious menu item, or an ...

/news/2009/jan/22/mcconnell_fisheaters/

Gross: Vegetarian diets don't limit athletic excellence

Some world-class athletes succeed with vegetarian diets.

/news/2010/feb/25/gross-vegetarian/

Nichols: Doubling Down may be ticket to ...

KFC's new "Double Down" sandwich may contribute to a new wave of ...

/news/2010/apr/12/nichols-doubling/

McConnell: Why the U.S. meat industry hasn’t ...

/news/2008/sep/10/mcconnell_why_us_meat_industry_hasnt_had_cow_about/

A turkey-less Thanksgiving?

Vegans and vegetarians get creative to enjoy a usually meat-filled holiday.

/news/2011/nov/14/turkey-less-thanksgiving/

Soy: superfood or super health risk?

Could the vitamin-packed, once-touted bean actually be hurting your health?

/news/2009/oct/08/soy-superfood-or-super-health-risk/

Former student spent month purchasing local produce

Living life as a locavore meant only buying food within a 100-mile ...

/news/2010/nov/07/locavore/

Holtzen: Organic food option not always attractive

Organic benefits not as good as they appear.

/news/2010/nov/29/holtzen-organic-food-option-not-always-attractive/

Editorial: Dangers of scientific food production extend ...

A response to John Kenny's column.

/news/2009/mar/27/editorial_dangers/

Sandal: Animal slaughter for human consumption is ...

Meat eating violates the basic human principle of causing pain for another's ...

/news/2011/mar/11/sandal-animal/

Keith: What happens when we cut the ...

Brain fart: One cow emits 240 liters of methane daily. Are you ...

/news/2008/apr/29/keith/

Lawrence residents find benefits in local food

The Lawrence Farmers’ Market has become a popular shopping option for local ...

/news/2008/apr/21/locavore/

Controversy surrounds cloned meat

In response to an announcement by the FDA that meat from cloned ...

/news/2008/jan/25/cloneburger/

Evanhoe: Organic foods are more appealing

/news/2006/may/10/opinion_evanhoe/

Staying healthy with healthy eating

Vegetarians and vegans take special steps to get their nutrients

/news/2008/mar/13/staying_healthy_healthy_eating/

Excessive meat consumption could pose health risk

Dieticians say students should balance diets and avoid high-fat red meats.

/news/2009/apr/01/excessive_meat_consumption_could_pose_health_risk/

Restaurant review: Tenth Street Vegetarian Bistro

The taste of town one meal at a time.

/news/2010/apr/08/restaurant-review/

City Commission stops chickens from crossing the ...

Lawrence residents bring up the lack of city regulations on chickens and ...

/news/2008/dec/08/chickens/

Vegetarians and vegans deserve more meal options ...

Lytton explains why students need organic food selections at the University.

/news/2009/aug/28/vegetarians_and_vegans_deserve_more_meal_options_c/

Blog: Saving the planet a movie at ...

Green movies, like exercise, take time and repeated implementation to change a ...

/news/2009/nov/30/blog_saving_planet/

KU students get hands dirty

Student farm teaches about agriculture, while also offering real products.

/news/2010/sep/21/ku-students/

Turkey day review

All you need to know this Thanksgiving

/news/2007/nov/15/turkey_day_review/

Bregman: Thanksgiving tricky for vegetarians

The Conscientious Consumer tackles the challenges of Turkey Day for friends and ...

/news/2010/nov/22/bregman-thanksgiving-tricky-vegetarians/

McConnell: When breast isn't the best

/news/2008/oct/07/mcconnell_when_breast_isnt_best/

KU Dining Services supports local foods

University’s effort to save money, support sustainability includes rooftop garden and local ...

/news/2009/sep/17/ku_dining_local_foods/

From the farm to your plate

‘Food miles,’ pesticides and water affect how ‘green’ your food is.

/news/2009/may/07/farm/

Restaurant offers organic options

/news/2005/sep/06/healthburger/

Doing Without: Eating Meat

Absence makes the heart grow...?

/news/2011/dec/01/doing-without-eating-meat/

Out and about

One random question, several random answers.

/news/2011/feb/16/out-and-about/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment