Controversy surrounds cloned meat

Despite FDA claims that it is safe, some students unsure

The future of cloning is here, and it ties into the production of food.

A farmer in Wisconsin collects a skin cell from his prize cow. He then transplants the nucleus from the skin cell to an unfertilized egg, which he implants into the uterus of a host mother cow. Nine months later, the host gives birth to a calf that is genetically identical to the original cow. When it grows up, it could find itself in the deli of your local grocery store.

photo

Students are unsure whether cloned meat is safe, but the FDA doesn't see a problem.

After seven years of evaluating the risks involved, the Food and Drug Administration concluded Jan. 15 that meat and milk from clones of animals were as safe to eat as food from conventionally bred animals, an FDA press release said.

The FDA doesn’t expect a significant number of clones to enter the food supply. Instead, the sexually reproduced offspring from the clones will be the ones used for food production.

Some students, like Yonatan Gizaw, Ethiopia senior, welcome the idea of cloning animals for food production.

“I think it’s a cool scientific development,” said Gizaw. “I wouldn’t be opposed to eating it.”

Other students, like Melanie Weilert, Humbolt junior, are skeptical about the FDA’s findings.

“I probably wouldn’t consume it because I’d be concerned about the chemicals going into my body,” Weilert said.

pullquote

I probably wouldn’t consume it because I’d be concerned about the chemicals going into my body.

-Melanie Weilert, Humboldt junior

Erik Lundquist, associate professor of Developmental Neurobiology, said there is absolutely nothing to worry about.

“I think a lot of people are apprehensive because it’s a very technical process and cloning holds a very powerful connotation, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the meat,” said Lundquist. “You’re not adding chemicals, altering genes, or adding hormones.”

In fact, Lundquist even encourages the idea of cloning animals for meat. If a specific animal has all the desirable characteristics a farmer is looking for, he said that breeding the animal the traditional way would only give you half the characteristics of the original, while cloning the animal would create a genetic copy.

Jack Dekkers, professor of Animal Science at Iowa State University, agrees with Lundquist, but doesn’t expect producers to begin cloning animals for food production just yet.

“Right now it is not cost effective to clone animals specifically for food production,” Dekkers said. “The technology is still in development and I think it will be years before it becomes a cost-efficient practice.”

Students like Ryan Koerner, Andover Junior, can’t wait for the market to jump on the new trend.

“If they find the best tasting cow and clone it, then hell – I’m all for it,” said Koerner.

—Edited by Samuel Lamb

 

Related articles

A new meat market

Animals could become obsolete in meat production.

/news/2008/aug/21/new_meat_market/

/photos/2008/jan/24/1297/

Grass-fed cows are what’s for dinner

Mel and Joyce Williams raise grass-fed cows as opposed to grain-fed, and ...

/news/2008/jun/17/grassfed_cows_are_whats_dinner/

Editorial: Dangers of scientific food production extend ...

A response to John Kenny's column.

/news/2009/mar/27/editorial_dangers/

Greening it

Your guide to greener living

/news/2008/feb/21/greening_it/

Gross: Cutting organic confusion worth time

Information on organic food can be confusing but quality information is worth ...

/news/2010/sep/22/gross-cutting-organic-confusion-worth-time/

Food Revolution

From the farmers to the restaurant to the consumer, learn how local ...

/news/2012/apr/11/food-revolution/

Student group focuses on animal rights

Compassion for All Animals, or CAA, works to raise awareness of the ...

/news/2011/may/03/student-group-focuses-animal-rights/

Keith: What happens when we cut the ...

Brain fart: One cow emits 240 liters of methane daily. Are you ...

/news/2008/apr/29/keith/

Udder confusion

/news/2005/feb/03/jayplay_features_milk/

Film sheds light on farming industry

“Food, Inc.,” showing at the Kansas Union tonight, encourages people to buy ...

/news/2009/nov/18/film-sheds-light-farming-industry/

Veggie tales

Meat free— the way to be?

/news/2007/aug/23/veggie_tales/

Living the green life

Earth Day is just one day of 365 that this senior is ...

/news/2009/apr/24/living_green/

Pred: Pink slime unacceptable in food production

Pink Slime. Sounds and looks like radioactive waste from a sci-fi movie ...

/news/2012/mar/30/pred-pink-slime-unacceptable-all/

The pheromone phenomenon

Using a sixth sense to smell a lover.

/news/2009/dec/10/pheromone-phenomenon/

Drug remains legal despite concerns

K2 mimics the high of marijuana and is available in Lawrence stores.

/news/2009/nov/11/drug-remains-legal-despite-concerns/

Gluten-free, way to be

Gluten intolerance can be life-changing but should not go undiagnosed.

/news/2010/mar/05/gluten-free-way-be/

McConnell: Why the U.S. meat industry hasn’t ...

/news/2008/sep/10/mcconnell_why_us_meat_industry_hasnt_had_cow_about/

Grants fund Dyche Hall upgrades

Two awards will allow the Kansas Biodiversity Institute to make renovations to ...

/news/2010/oct/11/grants-fund-dyche-hall-upgrades/

Letter to the Editor: Cheap foods may ...

Spending more on fresh produce means paying for quality, while helping animals.

/news/2010/apr/12/letter-editor/

HPV vaccine recommended for men

The shots decrease the risk of developing genital warts and cancer.

/news/2010/feb/04/hpv-vaccine/

The Merc challenges people to eat local

Eating locally produced foods is healthier, tastier and good for the environment, ...

/news/2008/sep/12/merc/

Holtzen: Organic food option not always attractive

Organic benefits not as good as they appear.

/news/2010/nov/29/holtzen-organic-food-option-not-always-attractive/

A turkey-less Thanksgiving?

Vegans and vegetarians get creative to enjoy a usually meat-filled holiday.

/news/2011/nov/14/turkey-less-thanksgiving/

/comments/cr/33/14829/#c11735

The not-so-sweet side of sweeteners

What you need to know about artificial and natural sweeteners

/news/2011/apr/07/not-so-sweet-side-sweeteners/

Holtzen: Herbal supplements escape needed regulation

Popular supplements slip under the radar of federal regulators.

/news/2010/oct/08/holtzen-herbal-supplements-escape-needed-regulatio/

Face scrubs can harm environment, health

Facial microbeads are made of plastic that can pollute water supplies.

/news/2009/mar/11/face_scrubs/

Letter to editor: Sticking with organic foods

Proof in the pudding for the benefits of chemical-free grub

/news/2009/oct/05/sticking-organic-foods/

Faculty members raise concerns on U.S. food ...

Experts from three different departments came together yesterday to discuss America's unhealthy ...

/news/2010/jan/26/faculty-members-raise-concerns-us-food-culture/

Where your waste goes after it’s disposed

Follow the process your trash and recyclables go through after they’re tossed ...

/news/2009/mar/03/where_waste/

Doing Without: Eating Meat

Absence makes the heart grow...?

/news/2011/dec/01/doing-without-eating-meat/

Swing low, fly high: Bipolar disorder affects ...

From trying to fly from atop Fraser Hall to swallowing a bottle ...

/news/2006/may/08/bipolar/

Science and art unite in modern dance

Liz Lerman Dance Company’s performance explored issues surrounding genetic research.

/news/2009/nov/09/science-art/

HPV vaccine approved for use in men

Watkins Health Center plans to order Human Papillomavirus vaccines for men who ...

/news/2009/oct/28/hpv/

That’s disgusting: Bugs in food

Dude..gross.

/news/2010/oct/07/s-disgusting-bugs-food/

Evanhoe: Organic foods are more appealing

/news/2006/may/10/opinion_evanhoe/

Crash diets can prove to be unhealthy

Homemade cleansers and crash diets aren't a substitute for sensible eating and ...

/news/2010/mar/04/crash-diets-can-prove-dangerous/

Spring Eats

Celebrate the return of nice weather with fresh, healthy meal ideas

/news/2007/apr/26/spring_eats/

Caring for Critters

One student steps up to help during Operation Wildlife’s busiest season

/news/2007/apr/12/caring_critters/

Comments

That is one nasty-looking burger.

Sign in to comment