Friday, November 14, 2008
I would like to point out the erroneous reasoning in Hirschfeld’s piece on a possible “gay school” in Chicago to address the needs of an under-served population of LGBT youth.
The author improperly equates the admission policy of the new School for Social Justice with the "separate but equal" policy. Separate but equal mandated segregation; this school allows any student to attend, regardless of race, sexual orientation, etc., with particular consideration to LGBT youth.
The author blows way out of proportion the effect of one high school in a city of more than 120 public high schools (according to the Chicago Public Schools Web site) and nearly 3 million people. Even if every student attending this school were LGBT (likely not to be the case), the number of LGBT students “removed” from every other high school in Chicago, and thereby removing the possibility of teaching intolerant students “tolerance and acceptance,” would be minute. The mass exodus of LGBT students from every other high school in Chicago implied by the author exaggerates both the intentions of LGBT youth in Chicago and the limited capacity of this school.
Third, the author makes mention of, and yet misunderstands, the intention of this school. There are those students who cannot learn in an environment in which they are continually harassed, much less learn or benefit from “surviving such adversity.” To them “such adversity” is not an edifying experience, it is a debilitating experience. These students need four formative years in an accepting, educational environment in order to surmount the harassment they will face down the road.
Fortunately, the author did not need this type of school. Some students do.
— — Aaron Olsen is a senior from Overland Park.
Hirschfeld: Could gay schools be ‘separate but ...
Queers and Allies strive for student equality
Queers and Allies are forming its own version of the program It ...
Anti-bullying bill in works
A New Jersey senator proposed legislation to prevent harassment in federally funded ...
Free: Make sure it does get better ...
Progressive Perspective takes a look at the difficulties facing gay teenagers and ...
Letter: LGBT policies strong
Student responds to LGBT policies at KU.
Letter: Gay students shouldn't attend separate schools
Project uplifts LGBT youth
Dan Savage, the founder of the "It Gets Better" project, spoke to ...
Cosby: ‘Gaypril’ offers a time to ask ...
Queers and Allies has set aside April to bring awareness to LGBT ...
A look at KU's changing face of ...
University's turbulent past has evolved into a somewhat tranquil state of activism.
Lavieri: Sports can succeed where legislation can't
Sports can help create acceptance of gay communities.
Three students share their coming out stories
Growing up in the conservative Midwest, some students find Lawrence a place ...
Hirschfeld: TV shows don't represent the LGBT ...
Bus tour promotes LGBT equality
A bus tour draws attention to LGBT issues in states that do ...
Events raise awareness during Hate Out Week
‘Tunnel of Oppression’ and ‘Bullied’ call attention to importance of tolerance on ...
Striving for parental acceptance
Gay and lesbian students at the University of Kansas have revealed their ...
Helped Out
KU Queers & Allies provides a safe place for everyone.
Free: Court ruling a victory for equal ...
The LGBT scored a major victory earlier this month in the overturning ...
Event works to eliminate hate
The Multicultural Resource Center’s Hate Out Week promotes unity, tolerance and understanding.
Overworked students' dangerous race against time
Is too much work and too little time putting students' health at ...
Free: Those against equality share in deaths
Anyone who works against equality for LGBTQ youth shares responsibility for the ...
Legalizing Love: the state of same-sex marriage ...
A look at the battle for marriage equality.
Letter: Comic authors respond to accusations
After recent comic caused controversy, authors respond.
Bisexuals face additional challenges
Students struggle for acceptance in LGBT communities.
Editorial: Pride Week is a time to ...
The student group Queers and Allies formed 20 years ago at the ...
Bledowski: When 'love' crosses the line
April is Sexual Harassment Awareness Month, but the issue is relevant all ...
Cosby: Iowa Supreme Court judged on specific ...
Removal of Iowa judges is worriesome.
Study reports on same-sex relationships in Kansas
Douglas County has the fifth highest total with 239 same-sex couples reported.
Groups comes out for day on Hill
Students and staff from Queers & Allies will observe National Coming Out ...
Softball player sues University
Editorial: Health education reduced to Paris Hilton
"What 16-year-old is going to focus on the cognitive impairment of alcohol ...
Negative lyrics devalue education
Hirschfeld: It’s not always bad to be ...
National T-shirt campaign visits campus, promotes acceptance
Editorial: Equality policy change important
The University’s nondiscrimination policy now includes gender identity and gender expression.
KU Medical School keeps tight admissions standards
School of Medicine maintains same number of accepted applicants despite nationwide shortage ...
University issued "red-light" for freedom of speech
The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education gave Kansas and 260 other ...
Get to know your freshman Student Senate ...
Here are the freshmen running for Student Senate. The polls open on ...
Let's talk about sex, baby, and not ...
Asexuality is an often overlooked sexual orientation.
Events remember transgender murders, suicides
Students will have a chance to learn about prejudices facing transgender people ...
Facebook adds new relationship status options
Domestic partnerships and civil unions can now be officially recognized on Facebook.
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Letter: Effect of ‘gay school’ exaggerated, intention misunderstood
I think you're exaggerating Hirschfeld's article much more than he exaggerated the issue. This is the second high school that's been created that is meant to be a haven for gay teenagers meaning it's becoming a trend. No, there won't be a "mass exodus of LGBT students" attending the school, it will only be a portion of the students which any reasonable person would infer. Hirschfeld was making the point that every gay student who attends that high school (which won't be a great number) will not be able to help make changes in their current high school concerning gay people. When I was in high school, I would have loved to attend an LGBT-friendly high school, but instead I was able to make changes in my bigoted small hometown by helping start a gay-straight alliance and got people talking about the harassment that was so often not addressed by administration. My skin's a lot tougher now, I'm stronger and feel more equipped to deal with the real world because of my experiences in high school. Your third point is the only one that I think has any legitimacy, some teens are at such a great risk that it's necessary to give them an alternate. But Hirschfeld also makes the point that if we have schools like this then the high schools they come out of will take a much greater amount of time becoming more accepting of the LGBT population. I thought the article was great, Matt. Please keep writing things like this.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID