Monday, October 6, 2008
A few weeks ago, as everyone knows, our campus newspaper’s editors decided to publish an edition of “Sex on the Hill” whose cover featured a full-page photo of people having sex in our WWII memorial.
The editors are within their rights to publish trash like this, and we have the option to take it or leave it. But when pushing the envelope means desecrating a war memorial, they have clearly crossed a line.
Our editors at the University Daily Kansan have stood up for this piece by issuing a half-hearted apology, explaining that they didn’t know it was a memorial (must have missed the names as they walked in) and by publishing piece after piece defending their right to publish what they choose.
Yet the biggest irony of all is they have offended most the very people who have given them these rights. There are WWII veterans alive today, and they, without a doubt, take offense to this. These men and women who saw our country on the edge of defeat and wondered if they would make it home as they saw their friends killed by the thousands in battles like Normandy and Iwo Jima have a problem with our student paper turning their memorial (not ours) into a porn background.
These soldiers, sailors and Marines, many of whom actually visit the memorial and remember those they lost have a problem with our paper turning their service into a joke.
I have a close friend whose late father served in WWII, and she is a Navy veteran herself. Although she has never attended KU, I’ve talked to her at length about what has been going on here. As for the “Sex on the Hill” issue not being a big deal or offending a very small segment of the population, she had this to say, “Enjoy your freedom of speech. Our family bleeds for it. We die for your right to degrade us, spit on us and burn our flag. Enjoy all the freedoms that you have that many countries don't that we earned for you and you enjoy without lifting a finger for but would die without. Enjoy what you did not earn but are given freely without any question from us and our families. Enjoy biting the hand that feeds you.”
Next time our editors at the Kansan decide to put out some highly offensive trash, call it journalism and hide behind the First Amendment when the fallout starts, maybe they should think about where these freedoms come from.
— — Adam Vieux is a junior in civil engineering from Groton, Conn.
McLeod: T-shirt issue borders on censorship
Offensive or not, the “Muck Fizzou” shirt is still embodiment of student ...
Welcome to The University Daily Kansan
On behalf of the entire news staff, Erick R. Schmidt extends a ...
Editorial Board: Colorado State editorial went too ...
Issue of respectable purpose comes into question.
Letter from the Editor
Staff did not intend to offend anyone by printing Sex on the ...
Editorial: Restrictions suppress student journalism
The University Daily Kansan has joined 32 other universities in support of ...
Letter to the Editor: Placement could have ...
Collegiate Veterans Association should have been notified about memorial.
Nichols: Parties require bigger, elaborate themes
Making up for bad high school party themes.
To hell and back
A fight outside Naismith Hall began Thor Nystrom's year-long journey into the ...
Kealing: Nothing stops the newspaper
Despite a storm that blew out the Internet and power, Tthe University ...
Free For All: Sept. 18, 2007
Screw the K-State Power Towel. If you’re going to the KU, K-State ...
Shorman: Preserving student code protects rights
KU students are fortunate to enjoy freedom that other schools don't have ...
Burch: Unfair restrictions on feeding the homeless
The recent Florida ruling against feeding the homeless violates First Amendment rights.
CITIZEN DOLPH: A rare look at the ...
You may not recognize his name, but Dolph Simons Jr., chairman of ...
Not forgotten
Bitch and Moan
the scarlet list
Jonathon Bourgeois doesn’t wear a visible scarlet “A” on his chest as ...
Letter to the Editor: Sex education reform ...
Abstinence-only education leaves out vital information.
Legalizing Love: the state of same-sex marriage ...
A look at the battle for marriage equality.
Bank accounts cause discussions
A generation of sex symbols
The accepted level of sexuality in the media has changed drastically from ...
Slipke: More issues of The University Daily ...
An additional 15,000 copies were printed and will be available for purchase ...
Nichols: What happens when your evil twin ...
Editorial: How Budig turned into a ‘waste’ ...
Malicious Intimacy
Four students' experiences with domestic violence.
Stroda: A makeover for the student voice
The UDK isn't just a newspaper, it's more.
Lawrence streetpaper receives grant
The quarterly newspaper founded by KU alumnus Craig Sweets is in its ...
Letter to the editor: Kivett
Students would be better off with formal sex education rather than graphic ...
Letter to the Editor: Sex is sacred
So what does abstinence in a committed relationship look like? For my ...
Bledowski: Sex talk climbs, actual sex falls
Students like to talk about sex. Having sex, not as much.
Cosby: Veterans deserve support upon return home
Addressing PTSD is matter of community support.
Robinett: Oklahoma City roadtrip notes
If I could, I would write 2,000 words about the game. But ...
Jayhawk Dirty Talk
This week Peter helps a woman with a scheduling problem.
Letter from the Editor: A new Kansan.com
Check out the redesigned Web site with more interactive content.
Free For All: Sept. 17, 2007
I just saw van slam into a car, and it was awesome.
Editorial: When words don’t do justice
Honoring former Kansan staffer Drew Anderson, an admirable friend.
Mangiaracina: Why insignificant news trumps the real ...
Senate votes to keep Kansan funding
Senators approved an amended bill that includes a separate Kansan subscription fee, ...
Garrison: New ways of covering news provide ...
A word from the Kansan editor on a new semester, new challenges ...
Stewart: Newspaper shouldn’t back the University’s demands
Minster: Kids growing up faster and faster
Third graders in Georgia took the reaction of frustrated students into the ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Listen, in defense of the liberal-biased media, they don't have two brain cells to rub together. They wouldn't know a memorial from a kegstand, and they'll defend their "right" to be offensive right up until the point at which it becomes an actual defense, with something at stake. That's when the real heroes appear. They can keep trashing conservatives, but in the end that's who they'll call for help. You already mentioned the half-baked backhanded apology, and the "1st amendment!" meme that "journalists" spout, but it still bears repeating that ɜɽᵼʰɯ.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Dean LeeRoy Broyles, Malcolm James Brumwell, Sam Bernard Bruner, Frank J. Buck, Henry Siddon Bunting, Robert Luther Burchinal, Howard Reynolds Burnett, Curtis Andrew Burton, Ernest William Bye, Kendall Carl Campbell, Paul Alexander Cannady Sr., Alvin George Carsten, Donald Houston Caylor, Richard Payne Chenoweth, Robert Eugene Chilson, Russell Junior Chitwood, Raymond Lewis Clapper, Dean Edward Cochran, Robert Langden Coleman, Paul Robert Conway, Joseph Dillard Conwill, James Eugene Cook, Samuel Donald Coulter, George T. Cronemeyer, Robert Thomas Crowder, Robert James Crutcher, Joseph Junior Dague, Dean Herbert Dalton, Nolan James Day, Grover H. Delinger, Foster Leonard Dennis, John Kingsbury Detwiler, James Hungate Dodderidge, Caryl John "Jack" Dodds Jr., Victor Donald Dolecek, Mary Elizabeth "Bess" Doty, Paul Francis Dunham, Morel Francis Dunham, John Taylor Dyatt, Lance Carroll Dyer, Fred Curry Eberhardt, Raymond Albert Eberhart, Charles Ansel Eckert, Daniel Frank Elam, Donald Lee Evans, John Dee Ewers, Allan Roderick Ewing, Leonard E. Fasholtz, Keith Hilton Fedde, James Hapgood Ferguson, Herbert Stewart Finney, Rodney Leroy Ford, Keith C. Foster, Holmes Chiles Fowler, John Brandon Franks, Thomas Samuel Freeman, Raymond Lester Friedson ,R. Earl Fromm, Don Bernard Fullmer, Arthur Oakland Furfey, Verne Leroy Gibb, Julius Thomas Gibson Jr., Donald Deal Gill, John Richard Goheen, John Burton Goins, William Herman Graves, John James Green, John Joseph Griffin Jr., Norman Bertrand Griggs,
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Calton B. Grissom Jr. Harold Lynn Hackler Fred Scott Hall Fred. C. Hamilton William McAdoo Hanna Kenneth Wayne Harley Melvin Ray Hartley Jr. James Samuel Hartzell Herman Heubner Hauck Robert Albert Haynes Darl Jay Heffelbower Donald Dean Heitman John Adams Hettinger Robert Lee Hoisington Bernard David Hotchkiss Dean Howard Howell Bernice Francis Humphrey Frederick George Humphrey Thomas Pitt Hunter Jr. Francis V. Huycke Robert Ernest Innis Robert Keith Jelinek William Lawrence Jepson Harold Adelbert Jimerson Lawrence R. Johnston William Pilcher Johnston Charles Osburn Jordan John Dillman Keeling Robert Webster Kehr Charles Norton Kelley Kenneth Lee Kelly Hillis Alan Kennard Leland White Kesler Jr. Deane Warren Kiefer Jack Kinell William Marshall Knight George Richard Koehler Jr. Kemper Jay Kost Wilber Paul Kroeker George Owen Kunkle Francis Claude Laird Joe Ralph Laird Fred Wrightman Lake Jr. Vernon Jay Landon Paul Albert Lark Daniel Seward LeShelle Jack Marchant Lee James Robert Lewis Solon Russell Lindsey Alfred Daniel Linley. Lawrence Sidney Smythe Linscott Jr. Ernest Alvin Lombard G. Max Louk Benjamin L. Love James Keith Loveless Earl George Lowe Jr. Lynn Meredith Mahannah Robert John Marshall Howard Allen Martin Robert Lester Mathews John Bridger Mayhugh Curtis John McCoy Jr. William Weldon McCrum Lawrence Gene McGinnis Stanley Whiteford McLeod James Leslie McNaughton Marian McShea Norman Richard Meeks Walter William Meininger Robert Clarence Mitschele Glen Tucker Mize Arthur Junior Moody Ralph E. "Red" Morrison Johnny "Jack" Musselman Raymond Tardin Napier Charles Wayne Nees Eugene Harold Nirdlinger Jack Noble Jr. John Herman Nuttmann P. Joseph O'Connor Jr. Robert Eugene Ode Frank Woodrow O'Flaherty Edward Kern Olsen Stanley Randolph Olson Bert L. Overcash Jr.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Stanley Leach Paine George Milton Paris Francis Holmes Paronto Elmo Lemont Patterson Charles Edwin Paxton Jo Wade Payne Jr. John Elliott Penner Neil Pennington Otis Oscar Perkins Herbert Mathias Peters John Starks Phillips William Wilson Phillips Jr. Charles Franklin Pierson John Albert Pierson Harold C. Place Albert Plotkin Donald Boyd Pollom Fred Rollin Powell William Samuel Prout John Thomas Puckett Vernon John Razak Glessner Woodrow Reimer James Andrew Reinhart Jr. Earl Boice Reynolds Dean Haberly Rice James Clark Richardson Browder A. Richmond Jr. Deane E. Richmond Floyd Lewis Riederer Carroll G. Riggs John Rolland Riisoe Irvin Edmund Rink Clarence Junior Robinson Walter Willard Rodgers Hal Russell Ruppenthal Herbert Kazoo Sadayasu Lloyd Irvin Savely Howard Iden Schlingloff James Edward Seibel William Wilson Seitz Rodney Walden Seufridge Howard Eugene Sellards Abe Shafer III Evan Homer Shaible Robert Jackson Siddons Niles Raymond Siebert Francis Bernard Smith Jr. Glen Bradley Smith James Cunningham Smith Raymond Tracy Smith Glenn Howard Soellner John Glenn Somers Jr. John Burroughs Stahl Wayne Clifford Steele Paul Ramsey Stephens John Wheless Stephenson Thomas Grier Stewart Vern V. Stewart Raymond C. Stiles Robert Ellsworth Stoddard Lawrence Iver Stoland Elmer Jackson Stone Thomas William Stone John Elmer Strand James Phillip Stratton Jean Thomas Henry Foxall Thorne Charles Raymond Toberen James Coleman Traw Robert Emery Trekell Wallace Augustine Trued John Peter Van Rixoort Francis Montgomery Veatch Pierce Leroy Veith Walter Harold Verbanic Cranston Gorgon Vincent Harold DuMont Waldecker Victor Griesa Walling Joseph Edwin Walsh Jr. William Edward Walter John W. Waterbury Jr. Lucien Andrew Watkins William Louis Weber Ray Gunther Wenzel Chevey Schaeffer White Robert William Whitehead Fred Ordway Wickham Albert Joseph Wieland Jr. Joe Lawrence Wieland Clyde Williams Robert Samuel Wilson Gilbert Leslie Worley Jr. Ralph Milton Wyatt John Henry Yoder Paul Bernard Young Herman H. Ziegenbusch James Munroe Zoellner
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Since these men and women don't have a voice, I've decided to list their names here, in the hope that we will all remember those brave men and women from KU who paid the ultimate price for the freedoms we so clearly enjoy today.
Thanks for reminding us, em1.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
I am also apalled by what was done by the UDK at our WWII memorial. However, I am also offended that the graphic nature of the photos were allowed regardless of where they were taken. The UDK became playboy, but instead of having to seek out a copy of the UDK like playboy does they give it out to everyone on campus. I really hope the staff learned a lesson but I really don't think its going to change anything, and that is truly sad.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
That is not the point. The point is, that you are descecrating the memorial to those who GAVE YOU THOSE FREEDOMS. Had the military not succeded in WWII, we would be under Japanese emperial rule or the Nazi regieme and have no freedoms in the first place (the Japanese did think they were a superior race and crushed those against them).
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
This country could easily become a great country again if people only put the country first, instead the United States of America is quickly becoming the Me First America. "I have this right, and I have that right. No one else matters but me." How sad. If that was the majority attitude in the 1770's we would be British right now.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
We should all feel sorry for lingup_the_grammar_robot. He obviously was never able to play sports as a child. If he had, he would know that, while you have every right to try to score every goal on your own, it is better for the team to swallow your pride and pass the ball to someone else and let them actually score a point. His team will always lose.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Alright. If my view is SO shallow........ Who gave you those freedoms? They didn't just come about. They don't still stand because those vets sat back and didn't do anything whant the US was attacked, preventing our being taken over by a facist empire.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
desecrate transitive verb meaning: 1. to violate the sanctity of. 2. to treat disrespectfully, irreverently, or outrageously. Ask the WWII vets what they think of Sex on the Hill. They will tell you differently.
One of the things that make America great is our ability to make choices. I have several rights that I CHOOSE not to use on a daily basis. Just because I have the right to do something doesn't mean I have to run right out and do it. There are many people that are holding back right now, I can guarantee that.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
So, they fought for those freedoms, and yet the Kansan should feel guilty for taking advantage of them? Then what was the point of the sacrifices made by the people the Campanille is dedicated to?
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
This is a respect issue. Respect goes both ways. Does no one understand the meaning of respect and desecrate anymore? I was taught to respect things as a child, not necessarily agree with them. Respect your elders, even if it's in the form of a statue. Forget the fact that public nudity is illegal, committing lude acts (sex) in public is illegal. The public went crazy mad when an American Idol contestant took "racy" pictures of herself in front of a WWII memorial in 2007, and she wasn't even having sex. No one could see this outcry coming after that?
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
Of course, that trashy stuff is protected speech, but just because you CAN say it doesn't mean you ought to. "Sex on the Hill" was designed to be shocking and titilating and to "prove" that the UDK is "holding the line" and "bearing up the Standard" for Free Speech. Then when people complained, the staff could preen and speechify about their right to free speech. Baloney. It was offensive and unnecessary and in poor taste. The university paper ought to hold itself up to higher standards than that. If you want to make a stand for free speech, make it for a good reason. The ability to print pictures of people having sex just because you can isn't a good reason. Disrespecting the Memorial isn't a good reason.
Grow up.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
I thought liberals were supposed to have an open mind, even if they didn't agree with it. This is completely about respect. Open your mind. Just because you want a fight, doesn't mean there is one. ALL veterans are glad that they fight and die for your rights. We are offended that you CHOOSE to exercise your rights in a way that disrespects us. People who won't fight for our country should respect those that do and did, since we respect you enough to die for you.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
You're right. I'm a facist. And so is anyone that respects and honors those who have gone before.
And this completely has to do with respect. Would you disrespect your dead grandmother by having sex on her grave and then post pictures of it everywhere? I would hope not. Why? Human decency.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
They fought for the defense of this country. That defense of our constitution, of our bill of rights. One of those being freedom of speech. That freedom for you guys to yell and bicker and argue among each other over whether or not they would or would not approve or be offended of something. But the basic fact is, you both have the right to keep a closed mind, that's what those bill of rights guaranteed. I hope that this continues for you both to be bitter and close minded because if that is so then our rights are still there, those rights that anybody should be able to exercise however and wherever they want.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
well... they weren't really having sex...
but i wonder how many people actually have. i've heard it is a pretty popular spot.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
I just want to point out that criticizing the entire staff of the paper is unfair. Most of the people who work at The Kansan knew nothing about the upcoming issue of Sex on the Hill and those people don't deserve to be grouped with 10 people on staff who did know.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
I don't think anyone is being fascist here, really.
There is a difference between pointing out that something is disrespectful/shouldn't have been published and saying that speech like this should be banned. I haven't really heard anyone call for the latter.
However, I have heard people call for the banning of offensive photographs brought on campus by anti-abortion groups.
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
When did the act of sex become something with such a negative connotation?
Letter: Remember why we have the First Amendment
I agree completely with you Ms. Chambers, and I hope if you aren't connected with the sex on the hill edition, you don't feel that you're under the fire as much so to speak.
It is unfortunate in some ways, but a fact of life, that many times the carelessness or blatent mistakes of a few make many others look bad. Case in point the recent plagerizer at the NYT who got fired a couple years ago, and made the whole paper look less credible. It sucks, but that whole organization took a hit for what was really just an individual problem in a lot of ways, and in every other way was limited to very few others who knew about the problem. Addtionally, I'm not allowed to call out individuals in an editorial piece, so I address the paper as a whole. I as an individual understand that some at the UDK may be opposed to this issue for a number of reasons, and I certainly respect that.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID