Thompson: What Ralph Nader should be working on

Independent presidential candidate Ralph Nader spoke to a welcoming crowd of about 400 at Abe and Jake’s Landing Oct. 9. He was introduced by Adam Wood, a candidate for student body president this past April and an avowed Ron Paul aficionado.

“We’ve had enough of Democrats,” he insisted. “We’ve had enough of Republicans. They do the same things. They’re the same thing.”

Every third party candidate must rehash the obligatory rhetoric of our nation’s bankrupt two-party system. But this year Americans actually do have a significant choice between the two major party’s candidates. The quadrennial ritual of Nader’s candidacy seems ineffectual and strikingly out of place.

About 40 minutes into Nader’s meandering speech, the large projection screen behind his lectern reverted from the Nader-Gonzalez logo to the soothing constellations of a Windows screensaver. It was a tragically appropriate symbol of his latest campaign for president.

His passion for consumer advocacy and political reform has become an admirable but unrealistic endeavor. This year’s campaign will have even less of an influence than it has in the past. Nader’s relentless insistence on the “two-party dictatorship” detracts from the more plausible and practicable positions he advocates.

All of us owe Nader for introducing crucial political issues into mainstream discourse. His challenge to the pernicious influence of corporations in politics remains as relevant today as it ever has been.

And this is precisely the positive role that third parties can play in American politics. They have been able to introduce new issues into the national discourse that the major parties have neglected. Take, for example, Eugene Debs’ socialist party with its demands for workers’ rights, many of which were eventually implemented in the New Deal.

The problem is that Nader advocates the dismantling of the two-party system, not simply a change in the two parties’ policies. It would take a drastic reworking of our government to achieve the type of European-style proportional representation that he champions.

The two-party system is inextricable from the type of single seat plurality and winner-take-all elections that we have used in the United States since this nation was founded. This won’t change now. It won’t change in 100 years.

I disagree with Adam Wood: Democrats and Republicans are not the same thing, and certainly not in this election.

But even if he were correct, he should challenge the two parties to change instead of challenging the premise of the system.

— Thompson is a Topeka senior in economics and political science.

 

Related articles

Nader speaks to Lawrence crowd

Independent presidential candidate Ralph Nader reminded listeners at Abe and Jake's Landing ...

/news/2008/oct/10/Nader/

Third party candidates shake things up

Obama or McCain not speaking for you? Look at Nader or Barr.

/news/2008/nov/03/third_party/

/comments/cr/215/228/#c3392

/comments/cr/215/228/#c3381

Letter: How Ralph Nader actually represents change

/news/2008/oct/20/letter_how_ralph_nader_actually_represents_change/

Ron Paul grants private interview to KU ...

Paul is speaking in Minneapolis this week at the ‘counter convention’ he ...

/news/2008/sep/03/convention/

University student sets sights on Kansas House ...

William Stewart-Starks, Whittier, Calif., senior will run as a Libertarian in the ...

/news/2008/jun/19/representative/

Editorial: How to make votes in Kansas ...

/news/2008/nov/06/editorial/

Anderson: Two-party politics lean toward fascism

The form of democracy in the United States has become a parody ...

/news/2008/feb/22/anderson/

Dole speaks at RNC event

The former senator and presidential candidate backs McCain, slams Obama

/news/2008/sep/04/dole_speaks_rnc_event/

/comments/cr/33/8217/#c3972

Poole: Republicans' VP pick shattered the mold

By choosing Gov. Sarah Palin, Sen. John McCain proved that he is ...

/news/2008/sep/09/poole_republicans_vp_pick_shattered_mold/

Three counties vote in Republican caucus, Huckabee ...

A crowded, but successful, Republican caucus brought hundreds of voters from three ...

/news/2008/feb/11/republican_caucus/

Cohen: Dems’ indecision may cost them

The DNC needs to sort out the nomination, or it may regret ...

/news/2008/apr/29/cohen_dems_indecision_may_cost_them/

White: Two-party system is like an abusive ...

Lacking enthusiasm after democratic caucus, one columnist develops own political philosophy.

/news/2008/feb/11/white_twoparty_system_provides_america_two_abusive/

Thompson: Facts speak for themselves

Columnist rebuts fellow Kansan columnist Chet Compton's arguments from last week.

/news/2009/nov/20/thompson-facts-speak-themselves/

/comments/cr/215/228/#c3374

Both parties agree on student debt issue

Both GOP candidates and Obama are working out strategies to reduce student ...

/news/2012/feb/07/parties-agree-student-debt/

Cohen: Sebelius should stay on for now ...

A Cabinet post would be great, but the governor is needed more ...

/news/2009/feb/18/cohen_sebelius/

KU Young Democrats to attend Obama visit

Campus Democrat’s new president hopes to gain members and become active in ...

/news/2011/dec/04/ku-young-democrats-attend-obama-visit/

Governor’s departure poses problems

Sebelius’ acceptance of HHS secretary leaves Kansas’ future and Obama’s health care ...

/news/2009/mar/03/governors_departure/

Student delegate details Democratic Convention

Clarissa Unger has spent time across the country campaigning for Barack Obama.

/news/2008/sep/02/student_delegate/

Mark Halperin of ABC News visits University

Halperin came to discuss issues as well as promote his new book ...

/news/2006/dec/07/halperin/

Dole Institute 'winds up' for Nov. 2

/news/2004/oct/26/dole_institute_/

Beecher: Why voting for a new chant ...

It’s time for this generation to step up and kick the apathy.

/news/2008/oct/22/column_beecher/

McCroy: Santorum's exit changes Romney's focus

As Sanotrum drops from the race, the Republican candidate Romney must change ...

/news/2012/apr/12/mccroy-santorums-exit-changes-romneys-focus/

Accomplished California politician speaks at Dole

Former mayor and State Assembly Speaker Willie Brown brought balance and understanding ...

/news/2010/feb/24/accomplished-california-politician-speaks-dole/

A.G. Six running for reelection

Six is facing two Republicans in the November election.

/news/2010/jun/03/g-six-running-reelection/

Does Sebelius really have the veep potential?

/news/2008/aug/21/sebelius/

Hawk Topics

News you can use

/news/2007/nov/08/hawk_topics/

Cohen: Debates didn’t show us anything new

/news/2008/oct/06/cohen_debates_didnt_show_us_anything_new/

Editorial: Why students should vote for Obama

The Kansan editorial board's endorsement

/news/2008/oct/29/obama/

Kansas Republicans assemble for first presidential caucus ...

Republicans who registered by Jan. 25 can caucus on Saturday, Feb. 9, ...

/news/2008/feb/05/kansas_republicans/

Holmes: Svaty is best pick for Democrats’ ...

Holmes on the best man for the left.

/news/2009/sep/09/svaty_best_pick_democrats_next_gubernatorial_candi/

Big spending for a big election

Kansas political parties and the Douglas County government have committed substantial amounts ...

/news/2008/oct/21/big_spending/

Letter: Criticism toward Democrats is misguided

Response to criticism of Democratic leaders.

/news/2011/sep/28/letter-criticism-toward-democrats-misguided/

Professor to give lecture on campaign ads

The lecture will cover Barack Obama’s and John McCain’s campaign advertisements and ...

/news/2008/oct/10/campaign_ads/

KU Greens withers away

/news/2005/feb/21/news_campus_greens/

And the candidates are...

Candidates are outlined for each race with platform statements and general information.

/news/2010/oct/31/and-candidates-are/

Kansan bloggers' take on the prolonged primaries

Joshua Anderson, Andy Greenhaw and Kelsey Hayes discuss the ramifications of the ...

/news/2008/jun/13/kansan_bloggers_prolonged_primaries/

Comments

I would have liked to see nader focusing more on consumer advocacy- like he did in the past. I think he would have been a better speaker if he came to the university and spoke about political reform and consumer advocacy, instead of going to a bar to campaign for disenchanted democrats, independents and republicans. Mr. Nader is a smart man, with many years of activism under his belt. Maybe he should focus on teaching people how to do that...

I think Nader made a good point at his rally, and I have to disagree with Dan. The Democrats and Republicans alike have decided to do nothing about the issues that matter in this country.

Both candidates voted for the $700,000,000,000 bailout, when government regulation was the problem in the first place.

Both candidates are ignoring civil liberties issues and neither candidate has pledged to repeal the USA PATRIOT act, Military Commissions act, or anything of the sort.

Both candidates want perpetual warfare, and even Obama wants to keep military spending at the same level, if not raise it. We have bases in 130 foreign countries, none of which either candidate wants to shut down.

Neither candidate wants to end the war on drugs, which is unconstitutional, a tremendous waste of federal funds, and a waste of jail space.

To quote Biden, "that's not change, that's more of the same."

The two main candidates are only superficially different, plus we have four good third party candidates. In Kansas, where the electoral votes will surely go to McCain and neither candidate will campaign here, voting for McCain or Obama would be more of a wasted vote than one for a third party.

The debates between McPalin and O'Biden are sterile platitudes that are scripted by the spin doctors who direct the subject matter to the most popular concern of the day. The debate commission is charged with keeping our two party system just that. The two party system. Thus silencing voices of dissent. We need to think outside the box, or become the drones they want. Both candidates vote for the bailout, excuse me, "Rescue Package", did not object to granting, "Prince Henry", extensive powers over the economy, both plan to keep a military presence in the middle east, to direct the distribution of the resource produced in that part of the world, (oil), they both represent corporate interests, (Men behind the curtain), the whole issue is "Business as usual". I just don't see an appreciable difference. Vote Sanity, Vote Nader

When one candidate is substantially more likely to draft me into Iran, I think that my choice is clear, and it's going to be a pragmatic one, too. That would be an even greater civil liberties violation than those that have been racked up by both parties so far.

Nader has no reason to be president. He was, at one point in his life, a great advocate for consumer rights, but those days are long gone. I don't buy into the flawed logic of "Well, here's why these other two more established candidates are bad" argument, as it still does not present to me WHY RALPH NADER WOULD MAKE A GOOD LEADER OF THE MOST POWERFUL COUNTRY ON THE PLANET.

Ralph Nader wants single payer health care to help middle class Americans and our coporations to compete with foreign corporations whose governments provide it.Obama doesn't.McCain doesn't. I'll stick with Nader.

Sign in to comment