Thursday, October 23, 2008
Every morning during my internship with a non-profit insurance association last semester, I would log into my company e-mail, my personal e-mail and, most importantly, Facebook. After more than seven months of being able to learn what couple broke up or browse my friends’ photos while getting paid $13 an hour, one fateful morning, I was greeted with “the rat,” the company’s nickname for a prohibited Web site. My Facebook usage had finally caused my employers to block the Web site. I was frustrated that they took my favorite time-waster away from me, but then my rational side took over and I asked myself, “Shouldn’t I be working, anyway?”
With some companies going as far as creating recess periods during the workday, many have noticed a general trend in the new crop of young employees. According to a study by Roger Hill at the University of Georgia and Susan Fouts at Western Carolina University, employers from the baby-boomer generation have grown increasingly frustrated with their young employees, noticing a lack of work ethic and overall laziness when it comes to work.
When describing her own work ethic, Chelsea Rutrough, Salem, Va., freshman, admits the amount of work she puts in is dependent on how important the outcome is to her. In general she works hard, but if she doesn’t care much, Rutrough says she doesn’t put in as much effort.
“I work hard and put in as much as I need to get what I want out,” Rutrough says. “Students don’t want to be stuck at work. They would rather go to work, do what they have to, and leave as soon as they can.”
In her article, “The Work Ethic, in a Modern Guise,” Joanne Ciulla, author and professor at Jepson School of Leadership Studies at the University of Richmond, says recent college graduates enter the workforce with three qualities that set them apart from older generations: a sense of entitlement to a do-over, expectation of rewards based on time put into work and not the quality, and feeling they are above average compared to their peers.
“These aren’t necessarily bad qualities,” Ciulla says. “It’s just that every generation, every change gives employers different challenges in terms of what they have to work with.”
Ciulla cites the current education system as a significant contributor to these behaviors, and she says grade inflation is the main culprit.
“Grade inflation is the saddest failure of education system,” Ciulla says. “If students go through college getting As and Bs all the time, they end up thinking they’re pretty good, and the problem is that some of them really aren’t. I don’t believe in blaming students. It’s an education issue.”
In her article, Ciulla calls this the “Lake Wobegon effect,” which is based on a fictional town created by author Garrison Keillor in which all the children believe they are above average despite evidence to the contrary. Having such an attitude can lead to students working less but expecting more. Even worse, Ciulla says, is that young workers do the bare minimum in order to keep their paychecks, and getting fired is of little concern because they can always get another job.
Others point the finger at more general offenders, such as the student’s family or the community where he or she grew up. If a student is raised in a home in which the parents are unsatisfied with their jobs, it will be difficult for the student to become attached to a job as well.
“How much would you really worry about career opportunities with a company if you’re planning on getting a better job in a year anyway?” says Brandon Dekosky, Overland Park senior.
Dekosky says he thinks that, for students, the interest is more in the dollar figure on the paycheck than advancements in a career. Because of such priorities, Dekosky says employers would most likely complain that students don’t show enough dedication to their jobs.
However, not all employers see student workers as lazy workers. Using generational nicknames, such as “baby boomers” for those born between 1940 and 1960 and “Generation Y” for those of us born between 1982 and 2001, can actually cause division within the workplace. Kathy Buzad, assistant director for the American Federation of Teachers, a trade union, says these labels promote expectations of the certain behaviors associated with each category.
“We really have a problem with the stereotyping of behaviors,” Buzad says. “People say that younger workers don’t care as much as older workers do, but that isn’t true. We need to be very careful of this categorizing. It can cause divisiveness in the work place.”
In her experience working with teachers and union organizers, Buzad says she has not noticed a difference between her older and younger employees.
A final reason that could account for the differences between older and younger employees is work environment. Paul Marquardt, a client relations manager for Embarq, provides internal consulting to the Internet and phone service company from a human resources perspective. According to Marquardt, older members of the workforce feel these work ethic difference exist because younger employees weren’t exposed to as much manual labor as the older employees.
“Now that we’re moving into a more technological age, many folks think that a younger person’s work ethic must be lower,” Marquardt says. “People tend to glorify the way things used to be as how things should be, and that’s just not true.”
I'll be watching you
Opportunity calls
How to get the most out of your internship.
Guest Column: Non-traditional students have the same ...
On top of graduation, job recruitment, older students have to maintain an ...
Balancing act
Students prove that attending class and working a job on the side ...
Latter-day stripper
Tori — as she is known on stage — has been dancing ...
The A to Zzzzz's of Napping
Are you a napper?
Job placement rate worries professionals
Career experts see hope in the future for job opportunities despite recent ...
Students still finding work on campus
Despite the recent recession, on-campus employers are still hiring student workers.
Buser: Don’t blame Facebook: Narcissism is old ...
Social networking sites not to blame for Generation Y selfishness.
A guide to the proposed health care ...
A look at the health care bills that are being passed around ...
Students juggle work and class schedules
Increasingly, students find they must work long hours and try to make ...
Excessively Passive Aggressive
Beyond sticky notes
Facebook: Best friend or worst enemy?
Your Facebook profile can help or hurt you in job searching
Lawrence's landlord: a developer's story
Doug Compton, owner of First Management, has helped guide Lawrence's development for ...
Johnson County stigma doesn’t always stick
Students from Johnson County make up 41 percent of the University’s population. ...
Ghost world
As winter approaches, downtown Lawrence’s sizeable homeless population must deal with crowded ...
CITIZEN DOLPH: A rare look at the ...
You may not recognize his name, but Dolph Simons Jr., chairman of ...
Grad Check
What's happened to Kathy Daneman since she graduated?
Student works through college selling Mary Kay
Freshman Pamela Carper has a unique college job: She's a Mary Kay ...
School of Business Career Fair
The School of Business Career Fair begins today in the Kansas Union. ...
Age gaps
Age is just a number.
Why internships matter for students
A deflating economy and a shrinking number of jobs keep market tough ...
Overworked students' dangerous race against time
Is too much work and too little time putting students' health at ...
In the life of ...
An adult novelty store employee
Making the case for a cause
Life inside a health care access clinic with a woman who sees ...
Single and Sparkling
To hell and back
A fight outside Naismith Hall began Thor Nystrom's year-long journey into the ...
Malicious Intimacy
Four students' experiences with domestic violence.
Elderly caregiving opens new career options
Home Helpers, a Lawrence caregiving business, is one of the several establishments ...
Republicans demand Sebelius sign budget
Without it, GOP senators say they won’t allow the state to pay ...
Navigating a competitive job market
University works to improve students’ employment prospects during tough economic times.
Veterans’ transition not always smooth
Everything from receiving educational benefits to socializing with civilians can be a ...
Crocs Craze Comes to KU
The unsettled life of Sarah Bregman
How one student's tumultuous past gave her a chance for a better ...
Hirschfeld: Don’t be language prejudice
Some people judge a person’s linguistics by the color of their skin. ...
Sleepless in Lawrence
Between midnight and 5 a.m., some Lawrence residents are wide awake.
Widower librarian shares wife's KU legacy
In the life of ... a Merry ...
So what's it really like to be a Merry Maid?
Spring breaks will end with graduation
One of college’s luxuries doesn’t follow students into the working world.
Some graduates in insursance limbo
Many insurance companies drop coverage after graduation, find out what you can ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Now hiring: Lazy college graduate
Nice article! An amazing statistic from an AOL/Salary.com survey: the average American worker wastes 2.09 hours a day at work, mostly surfing the web. The book I wrote for seniors transitioning to life after college, The Gradspot.com Guide to Life After College, has a section on confronting boredom in the workplace. If anyone's interested, it can be downloaded for free at Gradspot.com/book.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID