Oberthaler: How voters can help the state BOE evolve

As a denizen of a college town, my encounters with children are rare and brief and they leave me wondering the fatality rate from roller skate shoe inserts. The children I see mostly are in the playground next to the Dole Institute. My concern for children has amplified, and not just because the playground also connects to the Center for Experimental Biology.

State Board of Education elections are approaching on Nov. 4. This means the evolution debate is off the back burner again and tasting like burnt PTO fundraising kettle corn. For the past four years, the Board has had a 6-4 conservative majority. However, only one Board member is running for re-election. The Board, and the state science curriculum, is again up for grabs.

The BOE doesn’t seem germane to college voters. Most simply vote down the party line on the ballot anyway. However, uninformed voting produces ramifications even for post-secondary students.

First, evolution is almost unanimously accepted by professionals in every scientific arena. Failing to teach evolution properly in public schools misrepresents academic discourse. It also prompts tepid approaches to the subject from teachers, which results in incongruent knowledge among students.

Unsystematic curriculums inadequately prepare children for higher education and inhibit interest in science-related fields. Scientific inquiry from adolescents is especially pertinent now, when innovative biology and chemistry can benefit from advanced technology, which cures fatal diseases, harnesses new medications and uploads my consciousness onto my computer so I don’t have to keep re-typing my Facebook password. Children may be loud and dirty, but their bowl cuts and Aeropostale polos comprise future opportunities.

The Kansas evolution debate is not insular. A great portion of the country already assumes we still churn our own butter, and our ongoing evolution debate makes us seem just as archaic to the rest of the nation. You can bet generalizations about our incompetence won’t stop at high school diplomas. Kansans, including KU students, are all lumped under the same steeple-bearing roof of ignorance. The Bible Belt isn’t just seen as a giant yellow girdle of wheat on the waist of America – others consider it a constricting element upon the knowledge and credibility of all of us, not just grade school children. Electing a candidate who won’t amply this negative image is crucial to improving everyone’s reputation.

In the local district, the Democratic candidate is Carolyn Campbell, a state legislator who has been involved with the Topeka Public Schools Board of Education since 1995. She trounces Republican candidate Bob Meissner in public service and political experience. She adamantly supports teaching evolution.

In comparison, Meissner has been a practicing dentist for the past 31 years. He served on the Shawnee Mission School Board of Education for 12 years. He ran four years ago for the Board but lost to Democrat Bill Wagnon. Under Meissner, health class curriculums will benefit greatly from increased Timmy the Tooth cartoons, but science will suffer. Meissner does not believe in outright banning evolution, but he does support “the debate over different theories” of life origin within the scientific discipline. This all sounds open-minded, but “alternative views” usually mean a candidate is cradling intelligent design under a coat of objectivity, which is one deadly conceal and carry law.

There are plenty of other reasons to elect either candidate. Schools need adequate funding and effective teachers. But they also need officials who are acutely aware of appropriate curriculums. Take the time to elect someone with that knowledge.

You’ll be at the polls anyway, right?

— Oberthaler is a Wichita junior in English.

 

Related articles

Kansas' evolution standards have hurt its reputation

The Kansas State Board of Education's stand in the evolution debate has ...

/news/2006/aug/14/school/

Anti-evolution stance hurts University recruitment

/news/2005/sep/21/ne_research/

Two theories of science debated

/news/2005/feb/01/news_state_creationism/

Letter: Palin's theological certainty endorses irrational proposals

/news/2008/sep/11/letter_editor_palins_theological_certainty_endorse/

Darwin debate remains amid celebrations

The University has arraged multiple events recognizing Darwin’s scientific impact in conjunction ...

/news/2009/feb/04/darwin/

University admission standards under review

An admissions task force formed by the Board of Regents approved recommendations ...

/news/2010/nov/08/university-admission-standards-under-review/

Faculty boycott hearings on evolution teachings

/news/2005/apr/14/news_state_evolution/

Oberthaler: What Will Wright gets wrong about ...

/news/2008/sep/14/oberthaler_what_will_wright_gets_wrong_about_evolu/

New exhibit shows importance of evolution

/news/2005/oct/26/ne_evolution/

Know your Student Senate candidates

Learn more about the candidates for Student Senate

/news/2009/apr/14/know_your/

Freshmen campaign in senate elections

Candidates for five Student Senate seats introduce themselves to their fellow students.

/news/2009/sep/08/freshmen_senate_elections/

Puliltzer Prize winner examines debate

Edward Humes’ new book ‘Monkey Girl’ tries to explain the evolutionary debate ...

/news/2007/mar/29/evolution/

Campus group organizes event to celebrate Darwin ...

The Society of Open-Minded Atheists and Agnostics (SOMA) has booked a guest ...

/news/2011/feb/07/campus-group-organizes-event-celebrate-darwin-day/

Poole: Correcting rumors about Sarah Palin

/news/2008/sep/23/poole_correcting_rumors_about_sarah_palin/

Folmsbee: MCAT forgets purpose, puts focus on ...

The medical school examination stresses rote memorization, not scientific literacy.

/news/2009/apr/07/folmsbee_mcat/

Folmsbee: Science Nobel Prizes Overlooked

The American public loses interest in important Nobel Prize winners in science.

/news/2009/oct/31/folmsbee-science-prize/

Folmsbee: Science Nobel Prizes overlooked

Scientists from around the world were honored with Nobel Prizes, but the ...

/news/2009/oct/21/folmsbee-science-nobel-prizes-overlooked/

Editorial: Prepare yourself for up coming elections

Register and get informed in preparation for elections.

/news/2012/mar/06/editorial-prepare-yourself/

/comments/cr/33/8326/#c4197

Poor funding sacrifices education

/news/2005/jan/26/opinion_perspectives_zafar/

University student sets sights on Kansas House ...

William Stewart-Starks, Whittier, Calif., senior will run as a Libertarian in the ...

/news/2008/jun/19/representative/

/comments/cr/33/15965/#c13119

Website wants to create informed, involved voters

The University is a contributor to the Midwest Democracy Project, which employs ...

/news/2010/oct/26/informed-voters/

University professor brings anti-evolution discussion to campus

Topics included anti-evolution history, current issues and its impact on American culture.

/news/2012/feb/19/anti-evolution/

Folmsbee: Darwin day recognizes evolution's importance

200 years after Darwin's birth, many Americans don't accept the theory of ...

/news/2009/feb/12/folmsbee_darwin_day/

Moore wins race for U.S. Rep. in ...

Educational policies and wide appeal secured Moore’s place in Congress.

/news/2008/nov/05/moore_wins/

Letter: Religion and evolution don't have to ...

It's possible to accept evolution while also holding religious beliefs.

/news/2009/feb/05/letter_religion/

A question of identity

The Comanche Nation informed KU that a professor who claims he's Comanche ...

/news/2008/may/02/question_identity/

First speakers in intellgent design series say ...

/news/2006/jan/30/attorney/

Leaving a lasting legacy

As Hemenway prepares to retire, he and others look back at how ...

/news/2009/may/04/leaving_legacy/

Voters may not turn out

Even the historical nature of this year's election may not be enough ...

/news/2008/nov/03/turn_out/

City officials: Students can vote on local ...

Registering to vote in Lawrence gives students access to local elections and ...

/news/2008/oct/21/students_can_vote/

Student reflects on running for school board

After winning a seat, Wichita graduate student Vanessa Sanburn looks forward to ...

/news/2009/apr/17/student_reflects/

Holmes: Svaty is best pick for Democrats’ ...

Holmes on the best man for the left.

/news/2009/sep/09/svaty_best_pick_democrats_next_gubernatorial_candi/

Brinker: Social issues still key

The GOP race will come down to who has the best social-issue ...

/news/2011/sep/26/social-issues-still-key/

Motivated by a passion for results

Libby Johnson and Gabe Bliss are the KUnited candidates for Student Senate ...

/news/2011/apr/10/motivated-passion-results/

Student Senate freshmen elections end today

Twenty-four freshmen are running for Student Senate. Candidates submitted biographies to the ...

/news/2007/sep/05/student_senate_freshmen_elections_end_today/

Saha: Evolution is not 'just a theory'

Monica Saha dismisses presidential candidates who don’t accept evolution

/news/2011/sep/06/evolution-not-just-theory/

Atheists lead a discussion to educate public

People have the chance to ask questions of a belief system they ...

/news/2007/may/10/soma/

Comments

"For instance, did you know that the Catholic Church is adamantly against young-earth creationism AND intelligent design?"

I suppose the words "We believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, of all that is seen and unseen" Don't mean a lot to you then?

The Catholic Church is not adamantly against creationism, Pope Benedict himself has said the Universe is an "intelligent project." The Vatican astronomer who published the paper embracing evolution was fired shortly after the paper went to press. If you can't hold to the very basic and creedal beliefs of the Catholic Church, why bother being Catholic?

em1

I have been teaching biology at a Kansas Catholic School for the past 13 years. Our biology curriculum is strictly evolutionary based. No creationism, no intelligent design. I'm sure if the Pope was against evolution, it would not be the basis of our biology curriculum.

Your quote of part of the Creed also doesn't have anything to do with evolution or science for that matter. It is a faith statement. Certainly, Catholics, as well as other Christians, believe that God is the "maker of heaven and earth", but nothing rules out evolution as the method of how life has changed since its inception approximately 3.8 BYA.

Sign in to comment