Oberthaler: What Will Wright gets wrong about evolution

If LOLcatz, Battlestar Galactica and Mr. Potatohead procreated, you’d get the newest video game sensation, Spore. It’s the brainchild of Will Wright, who created The Sims, which turned out to be the best-selling PC game in history.

Spore is similar to The Sims, in that players control the evolution of their creatures. The evolutionary premise of Spore is quite innovative, but when science and pop culture meet, scientific accuracy always takes a back seat to amusement (see “Star Trek,” “Frankenstein,” “The Brave Little Toaster”).

photo

Spore isn’t trying to teach us evolution — it’s trying to take up space on your hard drive. Here’s what you should take with a grain of salt:

WE ARE ALL REALLY CUTE ALIENS

Life in Spore begins when an asteroid hits earth, depositing multi-celled bacteria that laze about until a player starts adding limbs and allows the bacteria to reproduce. Spore deserves a nod for including a scientifically supported background story, but the “space stork” is only one theory. Other scientists think organic material, such as amino acids and proteins, was grown in the right temperature, light and chemical conditions in some unfortunate prehistoric time when computer games couldn’t stunt their productivity.

NO NEED TO SAVE THE WHALES

Spore is infused with a humans-as-divine-beings mentality. While the creatures don’t resemble us, the game assumes that our conditions as land-dwelling, group-cooperating strategic thinkers led to our survival. This is why the game is so popular: It feeds our egos by allowing us to control life.

As June bugs have proven, you don’t need much of a brain to resist extinction. Surviving on land doesn’t guarantee better survival, either. Whales, the largest aquatic mammals, actually developed from land animals. Evolution requires a pull-yourself-up-by-the-bootstraps mentality. Organisms survive if they can use limited resources in a small area, not if they can conquer the universe.

IF YOU SUCK AT LIFE, MOVE PAST GO

Spore allows you to skip entire stages completely after you have played the game once. Unlike in Spore, species don’t seek out new ways to succeed unless their environment or genetic makeup demands it. In Spore, advancing from level to level is expected.

SEEING GOD BEHIND THE CURTAIN

Saving your thatch hut from burning to the ground in the tribal phase depends largely on what type of arms, legs and eyes players give their creature at the start. Like the real world, creatures with the best-fit characteristics flourish. However, Spore doesn’t notice that evolution isn’t a decision. Organisms don’t choose how they look. Biodiversity arises from genetic mutations and environmental pressure. Giving players a God complex ignores the basic mechanism of evolution — natural selection, not divine power.

But the point of Spore isn’t for the Board of Education to dispatch librarian patrol over all K-12 computers. Players can overlook the simplified representations of evolution because Spore isn’t a learning tool: It is science appropriated for entertainment.

If Spore didn’t have the God complex built in, we’d be doing the same old thing — making secret ugly Sim characters out of our siblings.

Oberthaler is a Wichita junior in English.

 

Related articles

Saha: Evolution is not 'just a theory'

Monica Saha dismisses presidential candidates who don’t accept evolution

/news/2011/sep/06/evolution-not-just-theory/

Darwin debate remains amid celebrations

The University has arraged multiple events recognizing Darwin’s scientific impact in conjunction ...

/news/2009/feb/04/darwin/

Oberthaler: How voters can help the state ...

/news/2008/oct/26/oberthaler_how_voters_can_help_state_boe_evolve/

That's disgusting: beer pong

/news/2008/aug/28/s_disgusting_beer_pong/

Catch of the week: Meg Ruggieri

Our weekly peek at a fish in the KU sea.

/news/2010/dec/02/catch-week-meg-ruggieri/

Fire and brimstone alienates mainstream American public

/news/2006/jan/26/vierthaler_opinion/

Roesler: Three new 'Heisman Hawks' emerge from ...

James Sims, Jordan Webb and Justin Springer step up and stand out ...

/news/2010/sep/14/heisman-hawks/

That's Disgusting

Shoo fly, don’t bother me (or puke on my food)

/news/2007/sep/13/s_disgusting/

Oberthaler: Why male birth control may not ...

/news/2008/sep/28/oberthaler_rats_why_idea_male_birth_control_may_no/

That's Disgusting: Dirty Laundry

Dude...gross.

/news/2011/oct/20/s-disgusting-dirty-laundry/

Thibodeaux: Football team still need to find ...

The Jayhawks lack consistency in their playing ability.

/news/2010/sep/19/thibodeaux-football-team-still-need-find-its-rythm/

Atheists lead a discussion to educate public

People have the chance to ask questions of a belief system they ...

/news/2007/may/10/soma/

In "God Particle" we test

Two KU professors join in an international experiment to find the “God ...

/news/2009/dec/03/news-particle/

Barking up the evolution tree

/news/2005/nov/16/ne_tree_life/

Oberthaler: Tongue in Beak

Gobble up your week's dose of satire.

/news/2008/sep/16/oberthaler_tongue_beak/

Women’s team’s talent not enough to win

Women’s basketball will need more than skill to beat Texas tonight in ...

/news/2009/feb/11/womens/

Catch of the Week: Steven Lacour

A weekly peek at a fish in the KU sea.

/news/2011/nov/03/catch-week-steven-lacour/

That's disgusting: not wearing socks

The sock was invented for a reason.

/news/2009/sep/10/s_disgusting_not_wearing_socks/

Hitting the open road

The best (accessible) destinations for a fall break road trip.

/news/2009/oct/08/hitting-open-road/

Household health

Staying healthy is as easy as keeping clean

/news/2008/may/01/household_health/

Curing the common zit

The secret to greak skin is not necessarily in how often you ...

/news/2006/feb/02/health/

Spring Clean

/news/2006/apr/20/jp_springclean/

Jayhawks feel at home on road

With success on the road and half of the Big 12 games ...

/news/2010/feb/11/undefeated/

Battle the bar fatigue

Not in the mood for the atmosphere of a bar? Here are ...

/news/2011/may/12/play-department-battle-bar-fatigue-weekend-options/

Kansan Departments

Your guide to surviving the week.

/news/2008/jul/11/kansan_departments/

Free: Time to clear up some misunderstandings ...

Here are a few word that should enlighten the enlightened.

/news/2011/may/06/free-time-clear-some-misunderstandings-atheism/

Iowa State Gameday

Take a glimpse at Iowa State football, Kansas' opponent this weekend.

/news/2009/oct/08/iowa-state-gameday/

Final: Jayhawks beat Aggies, 42-16

The Jayhawks try to get their record back to .500 by beating ...

/news/2010/sep/25/pregame-kansas-plays-host-new-mexico-state/

This weekend

Tallgrass Prairie National Reserve

/news/2009/oct/01/weekend/

Campus group organizes event to celebrate Darwin ...

The Society of Open-Minded Atheists and Agnostics (SOMA) has booked a guest ...

/news/2011/feb/07/campus-group-organizes-event-celebrate-darwin-day/

Witches and Rituals and Spells Oh My!

A small group of witches and pagans sit on the floor around ...

/news/2005/apr/07/jayplay_features_witches/

Celebrity Dish: Mario Little

Stars share, for better or worse.

/news/2012/jan/25/celebrity-dish-mario-little/

Selby lands in Lawrence, discovers broken finger

Josh Selby, the top overall recruit in the 2010 class, finds out ...

/news/2010/jun/08/selby-lands-lawrence-broken-finger/

Folmsbee: Don't 'believe' in evolution

Theory is something that is to be accepted.

/news/2009/nov/18/folmsbee-dont-believe-evolution/

1 ... 2 ... 3 ... OCD

Trying to break free from obsessing about obsessing

/news/2009/apr/09/1_2_3_ocd/

Wiccan, not wicked

These witches don't ride on broomsticks or conjure potions

/news/2007/oct/25/wiccan_not_wicked/

Players hold down fort for charity

/news/2005/feb/17/news_campus_holdem/

Morning Brew: SEC full of strong recruits

Rivals.com rankings show fourteen five-star high school seniors in the Southeastern Conference

/news/2009/feb/06/morning_brew/

Kansas in heat: Clean oral sex

Tackle the sticky world of relationships.

/news/2011/may/05/Contact-kansas-heat-clean-oral-sex/

Morning Brew: Breaking down sports’ best names

Read about Longar, Mookie, Coco and more.

/news/2010/feb/24/morning-brew-breaking-down-sports-best-names/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment