Monday, September 15, 2008
When people are worried about taxing cigarettes and liquor to help reform something as necessary as the health care system, I get disappointed.
Smokers are the last group of people I’d expect to hear complain about such a thing. All the people I know who smoke hand them out to anyone wanting to bum one. Why all the fuss then?
Gov. Kathleen Sebelius would propose a package of health care reforms that includes a 50-cent tax increase on cigarettes, according to an article in the Lawrence Journal-World.
But there are people against this measure. So I have to ask, how else are we supposed to get money for such a thing?
A sin tax, usually a tax on cigarettes and booze, is supposed to be a tax on a product that harms people and causes damage to society. If we don’t wish to finance health care reforms with a tax increase on cigarettes, I suppose there are plenty of other products that could be considered unnecessary or harmful.
But how much stuff is really unnecessary in life?
Suppose all we need to survive is shelter, food, water and clothing. Why don’t we put a sin tax on all things that are for vain hedonistic purposes?
Big screen TV tax. Car tax. Gold watch tax. Big fluffy pillow tax. Wii tax. Desert tax (after all, it isn't a meal). Wet wipe tax.
Think about how much surplus revenue the state could receive every year from such a wide stance on the definition as to what qualifies as taxable under the sin tax.
Consumer culture is as bad for you as cigarettes or booze. Look at how many people have credit card debt. For most people, this debt isn’t from medical expenses or a family emergency. People just want to live outside their means and consume, consume, consume — buy, buy, buy.
We have two options to solve this problem. Either we should tax everything under the sin tax that isn't food, water, shelter or clothing, or we should just raise the tax on a pack of cigarettes.
If we don’t raise the sin tax on cigarettes, how else are we supposed to help reform health care in Kansas — only one of 10 states that has an increasing number of people who don’t have health care.
Just tax the cigarettes and get children and the uninsured some health care.
Stewart is a Wichita senior in journalism.
Politically correct: Columnists weigh in on cigarette ...
Cohen, Thompson and Compton discuss Gov. Parkinson's proposed tax increases.
Smokers feel the heat of rising price
Legislature consider tax on tobacco for revenue.
Tan tax worries local salon owners
A 10 percent tax on tanning included in the health care bill ...
Health care plan proposes ‘tan tax’
Senate’s proposed tan tax could halt dangerous behavior but may negatively affect ...
Health Authority wants state smoking ban
The Kansas Health Policy Authority proposed a 50 cent per pack user ...
A guide to the proposed health care ...
A look at the health care bills that are being passed around ...
KU students take part in tax protests
Alluding the famous Boston Tea Party, Americans gathered in opposition of the ...
Editorial: Tobacco tax, decrease deficit
Editorial board discusses the benefits of raising the tobacco tax.
Governor’s departure poses problems
Sebelius’ acceptance of HHS secretary leaves Kansas’ future and Obama’s health care ...
Regan: Smoking taboo doesn't fly abroad
Smoking in Ireland more acceptable than in U.S.
Bill could double wholesale alcohol tax
Lawmakers propose increase to alcohol tax in response to state budget cuts
Thompson: Democrats’ reform needs strength
President Obama’s healthcare reform pushes for momentum with help from unexpected endorsements.
Editorial: Benefits of proposed alcohol tax outweigh ...
Proposed tax on alcohol would support programs that benefit the mentally ill.
Spray tan may soon be cheaper alternative
A 10 percent tan tax taking effect July 1 will not apply ...
Stewart: Conversations to avoid when you’re at ...
Stewart: Consumer culture: So easy a caveman ...
If taking it to the extreme is what a group of people ...
Obama’s speech leaves students torn
In a speech to Congress, the president discussed the future of health ...
Lawrence voters set to decide on sales ...
The tax would fund public transit in the city.
Mangiaracina: Prostitution 21st century prohibition
Legalization of prostitution will help society.
Students show indifference in health care
Young adults have yet to play active role in rallies, heated discussions.
Editorial: Why students should vote for Obama
The Kansan editorial board's endorsement
Jenkins talks health care
U.S. rep. says she’s happy to see many faces at town hall ...
Brownback focuses on taxes in State of ...
The governor hopes to eliminate income tax to bring more businesses to ...
Stewart: Would Kansas go back to Roberts?
Cosby: Healthcare in perspective
Americans can forget how advantageous our health care and medial technology are ...
City Commission votes to build new shelter
Proposed shelter in southeast Lawrence must pass second vote.
Hall Center to hold lecture with T.R. ...
Writer and NPR regular will talk health care in the U.S. compared ...
Cohen: Hopes for health care reform
Health care legislation is nearly ready for vote.
McCroy: Obama's budget spells bad news
The new budget proposed by President Obama isn't going to do much ...
Harold Godwin to speak on health care
Godwin will discuss the issues former Gov. Sebelius will face in her ...
Davidson: Our economy was drunk
Government intervention is like booze for our struggling alcoholic economy.
Group helps students grasp health care
Concerned Active and Aware Students to raise awareness about national debate in ...
Thompson: Conservative rhetoric proves harmful to health ...
'The Lawrencian' rebuffs the GOP's rhetoric.
Better Options for Bad Situations: E-cigarettes
If you’re going to do it, be smart.
Homeless Family Program focuses on keeping kids ...
The Lawrence Homeless Shelter is filling up rapidly with families looking for ...
Scott: Obama has shown courage
Obama may be starting to resemble Rodney Dangerfield.
New cigarette ads designed to persuade smokers ...
FDA will require cigarette packaging to contain graphic warnings about the dangers ...
Editorial: Show support for health care, but ...
The new package benefits students but the public option should have been ...
Cigarettes a drag on students’ wallets
KanUquit helps students grapple with financial, health concerns associated with smoking.
From left: Kimberlee Hinkle, Libby Johnson and Hannah ...
1 comment
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
Comments
Stewart: Finance health care with larger sin tax on cigarettes
We only have two options? Wow, I would have thought maybe some non-hyperbolic middle ground could have been reached.
Stewart: Finance health care with larger sin tax on cigarettes
I liked the direction you were going with this, until the 8th paragraph, where I cringed at your misuse of "desert" in place of "dessert". (As tasty as dry land does sound...) Funny -- I just wrote a column for our Collegian yesterday about my frustrations of misusage of homonyms, such as "our" and "are", "they're," "their" and "there," and I must say, I'm quite disappointed that a journalism major just made that error. From then on, my opinion of your column went downhill. And I agree with empirelucas, there has got to be a happy medium somewhere.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID