Dufek: Imagine life without Jayhawk football

Was the weekend a little lackluster without Kansas football, or was it just me?

Yes, there were some wild upsets in college football and Major League Baseball had some exciting play-off races, but something seemed off.

Can you imagine life without Jayhawk football every weekend?

At first glance this seems like a pointless question, but according to kuhistory.com, at one time it came very close to being a reality.

In January 1910, the future of football at the University of Kansas was hanging by a thread. A proposal to eliminate the sport was put in place by J.W. Gleed, a member of the Board of Regents. William Allen White, a regent at the time and the person for whom the School of Journalism is named, seconded the motion.

The Regents defeated the motion, but agreed that some changes needed to be made to the sport. The debate surrounding football continued for the next several months.

A large majority of students and alumni fought to keep football at Kansas, but they were going against some solid arguments for elimination.

Problems during the 20 years of football before 1910 included: The death of an opposing player from Doane College in Nebraska after injuries suffered during a game in Lawrence; rumors of alcohol and drug use by players of opposing teams before games; ineligible player activity at the University; the firing of Coach Harold S. Weeks, who was accused of having a relationship with a freshman girl in 1904; and the breaking of conference rules by the University when it spent more than $400 on training tables for players.

It was apparent that Jayhawk football needed help if it was going to survive. The conference and local citizens were aware of it.

A cartoon in the Feb. 7, 1910 issue of the Kansas City Star shows a man, who represents Kansas, holding a woman, representing football, over a cliff and the other members of the Missouri Valley Conference running to save her.

In the end, the conference came through, adopted new rules and the threat to remove Kansas football faded.

But by using the butterfly effect and our imagination, let’s discuss what life would be like without Kansas football.

When hope seemed dim for Kansas football in 1910, word leaked out that the team would use spring practices to get ready for a possible shift to rugby. The Kansan even wrote an article attempting to interest students in the game.

So Kansas, hypothetically, could have been a rugby powerhouse. But when football was allowed to continue, rugby faded out of the spotlight. Today, rugby is a club sport at Kansas, and it’s far away from being one of the top two athletics revenue makers.

The University would be vastly different without the revenue and publicity football brings in. The commercials played for the University during televised games attract students from different cultures and geographical regions. There is no denying that sports play a factor when some students make a college choice. Recent achievements such as an Orange Bowl victory and a National Championship in basketball undoubtedly had an effect on this year’s enrollment jump.

Without football, Kansas probably wouldn’t be a member of the Big 12. It would have more than likely stayed in the Missouri Valley Conference when the Big 8 formed, and would have become a 20,000-plus school that focused strictly on basketball, such as Southern Illinois University.

As a mid-major it would have been tough for even a school such as Kansas to achieve the kind of success it has in basketball. Gonzaga University is one of only a few mid-major schools to become a consistent threat and even it has not reached the Final Four. Others, such as George Mason University, make the Final Four for a year, but have no consistency. Since 1966, the only school to win a NCAA basketball championship from a non-major conference was the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, in 1990.

Kansas might have become a FBS Conference (D1-AA) football school. Kansas’ fans would have gotten to watch a structured play-off system, similar to the NFL, instead of the chaos that is the BCS, so there would have been one bright spot if that had occurred.

Now, there is nothing wrong with being a FCS school or having no football team at all.

However, in my opinion, Saturdays wouldn’t be as fun without Todd Reesing’s seven-second scrambles, Dezmon Briscoe’s spectacular catches, Daymond Patterson’s big returns, Mike Rivera’s hard hits, Darrell Stuckey’s game-breaking plays and the fans waving the wheat. That’s why I am grateful to those students, faculty and alumni who fought to keep football alive at the University nearly a century ago.

 

Related articles

University says Final Four may not increase ...

The University saw a bump in enrollment following the 2008 championship, but ...

/news/2012/apr/10/university-says-final-four-may-not-increase-enroll/

Another night on the pitch

Johnny’s Tavern owner is a big part of the Kansas Jayhawk Rugby ...

/news/2009/nov/06/another-night-pitch/

Kansan's OK with living in the shadow ...

KU basketball traditions don't come close to clout and money of UT's ...

/news/2010/jun/21/kansans-ok-living-shadow-texas/

Editorial: Kansas should consider conference split from ...

With the future of the Big 12 unclear, Kansas officials should consider ...

/news/2011/sep/12/editorial-kansas-should-consider-conference-split-/

Dufek: Kansas Athletics remains a juggernaut

KU fans shouldn’t fret just yet. As the football team records its ...

/news/2008/oct/21/juggernaut/

Scheduling weaker teams more common

Big schools usually get an easy win, while smaller schools receive money ...

/news/2008/oct/09/scheduling_weaker_teams_more_common/

The woes of realignment

In the past year, the Big 12 has experienced the most turbulent ...

/news/2012/apr/25/woes-realignment/

Rugby tournament draws teams from across the ...

This weekend’s tournament, at the Jayhawks’ Westwick Rugby Complex, pitted the collegiate ...

/news/2008/sep/29/KURugby/

Football schools improve basketball programs

Athletics Department hopes to follow the lead of other schools and make ...

/news/2007/mar/01/football/

Appalachian State raises more questions about ranking ...

At the end of each college football season, a normally controversial bowl ...

/news/2007/sep/06/Wheeler/

What's next for the Big 12?

The loss of two teams will drastically alter the Kansas schedule in ...

/news/2010/jun/15/whats-next-big-12/

Play Like a Girl

Women's rugby players kick butt and form friendships

/news/2007/apr/19/play_woman/

Morning Brew: Smaller conferences shut out

Only a few mid-major teams will get a shot at at-large bids.

/news/2009/feb/24/morning_brew/

Kealing: ‘Sports was my entry into journalism’

From Marian Washinton’s last game the president’s visit to Kansas, there are ...

/news/2007/may/10/kealing/

ACC makes latest move in conference realignment ...

The future of the Big 12 hinges on Oklahoma's Board of Regents ...

/news/2011/sep/18/acc-makes-latest-move-conference-realignment-bonan/

Morning Brew: Thankful for sports

Sporting events are often taken for granted, but are an important part ...

/news/2010/nov/28/morning-brew-thankful-sports/

Brew: Farewell Kansas Sports, I will miss ...

The experience of sports and the band is what has kept Jonathan ...

/news/2011/dec/07/brew-farewell-kansas-sports-i-will-miss-you/

Welcome to Kansan sports section

You’ve been sustaining your sports appetite on bits about Barry Bonds and ...

/news/2007/aug/13/welcome/

Morning Brew: Linebackers awaits bowl destination, beards?

Kansas linebackers, Joe Mortensen and Mike Rivera, along with teammates waits for ...

/news/2008/dec/05/morning_brew/

Football player gives back to area children

Linebacker Mike Rivera schedules his classes so he can visit local schools ...

/news/2008/oct/08/football/

KU students enjoy varied sports traditions

Game days and Traditions Night anchor the school’s sport history.

/news/2010/aug/16/ku-students/

Johnson: Two can share the spotlight

Kansas has the potential to become a major contender in football as ...

/news/2007/oct/10/johnson/

Big 12 Realignment: SEC shuts down Missouri ...

The SEC rejected a report that it had offered Missouri a spot ...

/news/2011/sep/20/big-12-realignment-sec-shuts-down-missouri-specula/

KU baseball pitcher drafted by Yankees

Shaeffer Hall chooses the Yankees after two other Major League offers.

/news/2009/jul/14/hall/

Williams: Athletics enriches experience

Universities with sports culture aid academics.

/news/2009/oct/09/column_athletics/

Gray-Little asks Nebraska and Mizzou to stay ...

KU chancellor Bernadette Gray-Little urged her Nebraska counterpart Monday to remain in ...

/news/2010/jun/07/gray-little-urges-nebraska-stay-big-12/

Morning Brew: Anyone can play AD

A new Facebook game, ESPNU College Town, lets users build a campus ...

/news/2010/sep/28/morning-brew-anyone-can-play-ad/

Big 12 conference remains unstable

And then there were nine...

/news/2011/aug/31/big12-conference/

Matson: Road to Final Four full of ...

Cinderella teams may cut Kansas’s championship dream

/news/2012/mar/07/jayhawks-watch-out-road-final-four-full-danger/

Brew: Reasons why you should watch rugby

It’ll never reach same level of popularity as football, but rugby deserves ...

/news/2011/sep/06/brew-reasons-why-you-should-watch-rugby/

Brew: Jayhawk fans need to broaden their ...

Sports fans need to show support to the football team the same ...

/news/2011/may/02/jayhawk-fans-need-broaden-their-horizons/

Dwyer: Football revenue trumps basketball tradition

Basketball may be king at Kansas, but football is king in realignment.

/news/2010/jun/22/dwyer-football-revenue-trumps-basketball-tradition/

Kansas could win two titles

The Kansas Jayhawks are nationally ranked in the top five in both ...

/news/2007/nov/07/kansas_could_win_two_titles/

Boat subsidy keeps sports fee increases at ...

The athletics department said it won’t increase all-sports pass fees next season.

/news/2008/mar/27/passes/

Kansan’ should honor its promise to cover ...

/news/2005/mar/10/opinion_letters_kansan/

Two Jayhawks sign free agent contracts

Holt will join the San Diego Chargers, Rivera the Chicago Bears.

/news/2009/apr/28/free_agents/

Dufek: How the Big 12 is challenging ...

With so many talented teams, it’s unlikely a national title contender will ...

/news/2008/oct/14/dufek/

Missouri announces progress in conference realignment

At a press conference Friday at UMKC, Missouri officials announced plans for ...

/news/2011/oct/21/missouri-announces-progress-conference-realignment/

Leaving a lasting legacy

As Hemenway prepares to retire, he and others look back at how ...

/news/2009/may/04/leaving_legacy/

Governor wants to improve school ranking

Parkinson calls for tougher admission standards.

/news/2009/sep/10/governor_wants_improve_school_ranking/

Comments

History revision required. KU did not go from the MVC to the Big 8, it went from the MVC to the Big 6, which became the Big 7, then the Big 8 and now the Big 12.

Sign in to comment