Thursday, July 23, 2009
Administrators at the University of Kansas are considering perhaps the biggest hit to student privacy rights in decades.
A new proposal would allow housing officials to enter a student’s dorm room, scholarship hall room, or University apartment if there is “probable cause” of alcohol or drug use. This new policy is an effort to decrease underage and excessive drinking on campus.
Students on the Student Housing Advisory Board have already approved the change in policy, and it appears as if Student Senate will have the final say in the matter.
Current housing policies only allow police or housing staff to enter a student’s room with verbal consent or a warrant granted by a judge. Officials in the Department of Student Housing should not be afforded rights not granted to law enforcement agents, except in cases of medical emergency.
Although the University should be commended for trying to curtail excessive drinking, taking away students’ privacy is not the only — or best — way to accomplish that goal.
The recent medical amnesty program, which allows students to call for help with an intoxicated friend without the possibility of disciplinary or legal action, was a positive step in encouraging more responsible drinking behaviors. This program gives students no excuse to sit by or ignore a friend in need and could possibly save lives.
The recent changes in policy are an obvious attempt to mend the University’s alcohol policy in light of the recent deaths of KU freshmen Dalton Hawkins and Jason Wren.
Although it is encouraging that the University is trying to do more, this recent proposal goes too far.
Neither Dalton Hawkins nor Jason Wren died in a dorm room. Hawkins was found dead near a University scholarship hall reportedly after a night of drinking at local bars. This proposed policy would only encourage students to drink in other places, much like Hawkins did the night of his death. And it makes little sense to say this policy could have prevented Wren’s death. Wren was kicked out of Oliver Hall after repeated drinking violations. If this policy had been in effect at the time, Wren would likely have only been kicked out sooner.
Administration officials should be applauded for implementing a mandatory alcohol education program. Education and awareness will go much further than taking away students’ privacy.
But these positive steps forward don’t rectify several steps backward. The administration is considering other drastic measures that come shockingly close to infringing upon students’ First Amendment rights.
In a “Summary of Alcohol Initiatives” the administration identifies reviewing “the University’s chalking policy” and mandating training for members of student media outlets (The University Daily Kansan, KJHK, and KUJH) to implement “socially responsible advertising.” It is frightening any time any authority seeks to control a media outlet — student run or otherwise. Any restrictions on chalking, which have been proposed, would be a blatant hit at First Amendment rights. political groups, student clubs and businesses all use chalking as a way to reach students. This is something the administration should not regulate or take away.
Alcohol deaths are sad, tragic and everything possible should be done to avoid them. But recent proposals by University administration go too far and ask too much of students. They shouldn’t be allowed to infringe on students’ privacy or freedoms of speech and expression. Students should petition the Student Senate to vote against the proposal to enter a student’s room without permission.
And administration officials should rethink their proposed policies. Sometimes all it takes is one or two good ideas to make a huge difference. There is no doubt that administrators have good intentions, but their methods are flawed and need reworking.
— — Edited by Derek Zarda
Editorial: Policy infringes on student privacy
Proposed changes to the Department of Student Housing's policies could limit some ...
Student Senate reviewing alcohol policy
A subcommittee is considering changes that would let University employees enter dorm ...
Editorial: KU needs stronger policies on alcohol
The Kansan supports establishing tighter controls on underage drinking.
Alcohol related deaths could impact dorm privacy
Change to policy could eliminate need for search warrants in dorms.
University re-examines privacy policy
Following Jason Wren’s death, University considers allowing parents more access to student’s ...
Memory of Jason Wren educates students about ...
The Sigma Alpha Epsilon pledge died of alcohol poisoning in 2009.
A sobering reality
Two years after Jason Wren's death, what has changed?
Editorial: Student Senate votes to protect student ...
Larrabee discusses alcohol-related policy.
University’s alcohol initiatives considered good start
Researchers say new initiatives must control alcohol consumption in entire Lawrence community ...
A sobering conversation
University struggles to address the complexities of alcohol policy in the wake ...
Father calls for change after son's death
Jay Wren says both fraternity environment and his son are partially to ...
New alcohol policy fails to pass
The student rights standing committee voted no to allowing senior staff members ...
Matney: Jason Wren Initiative reminds students to ...
It is KU students' responsibility to remember and learn from the tragic ...
Editorial: Join Senate subcommittee to examine alcohol ...
Students should voice their opinion as members of the University.
A staggering tragedy
Friends and family look for answers while struggling to cope with an ...
Hartz: FERPA not the real problem in ...
Even if the policy changed, enforcing it would be nearly impossible.
Shorman: Dry-campus reconsidered
Bringing alcohol back on University property; possibility with a new provost.
Task force meets about campus alcohol problems
The new University Alcohol Task Force considers pre-game drinking and campus chalking ...
Alcohol policy adds amnesty, parent notification
The University’s revised alcohol policy also includes an online assessment for incoming ...
Letter: Fraternity has changed since death
Fraternity has implemented changes to house policies and rules.
Housing proposal aims to stop alcohol abuse
A Student Housing recommendation would allow staff to enter rooms under suspicion ...
Editorial: Survey data may be skewed
Alcohol information could be incorrect because of the way it was gathered.
Wren lawyer says police investigation may not ...
Greek organizations might also be changing alcohol policies as Wren family files ...
Autopsy report confirms student died from alcohol ...
After nearly four months the report reveals that Jason Wren's blood alcohol ...
Concert to be held in memory of ...
Sigma Alpha Epsilon is holding an alcohol-free concert, proceeds going to Jason ...
Editorial: Hazing code needs more clarity
KU has placed the Phi Gamma Delta fraternity on probation, but the ...
Excessive and accepted
Lawrence, KU culture may contribute to students' high levels of alcohol consumption.
Face-off: Risks too high
Wren family files suit against SAE
Lawsuit alleges the fraternity provided alcohol to Jason Wren and broke fraternity, ...
Editorial: Alcohol policies flawed
Administration is taking the right steps, but there is room for improvement.
Mourners gather for Hawkins’ funeral
Family and friends grieve for “Big D” at the Tuesday service.
Editorial: Why can’t of-age adults drink at ...
Freshman found dead on campus was Mt. ...
The freshman was known as goofy and hilarious to his friends.
Editorial: Chalking restrictions strike at free speech
New restrictions on sidewalk chalking should concern all students.
University changes alcohol policy, adds amnesty clause
Officials will notify parents of underage students who violate alcohol or drug ...
Concert held in memory of Jason Wren
The event at Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity raised awareness about alcohol safety.
Jason Wren’s life commemorated
Students, friends, family gathered on the front lawn of Sigma Alpha Epsilon ...
From left: Kimberlee Hinkle, Libby Johnson and Hannah ...
1 comment
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
Comments
Editorial: Proposed policy infringes on privacy
Alcohol deaths are not the only issue at hand. Constant litter and destruction of hallways are also a problem that the halls face. This is a great idea because the RAs still have to work with persons who have to be very careful how they act with their responsibilities.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID