Friday, November 6, 2009
Boise State won big against San Jose State last Saturday, but they picked up an even bigger victory when Oregon destroyed then-No. 4 USC by 27 points the same night. The Broncos are now 8-0 and have been rolling through the Western Athletic Conference. But their best win of the season came in week one, when they defeated Oregon at home.
Voters were surely tempted to move Oregon into the top 5 after the Ducks’ thrashing of the mighty Trojans on Halloween. But they had to remind themselves that this was the same team that had lost to Boise State back in September. Oregon is now ranked No. 8 in the BCS, just behind Boise State, who falls in at No. 7.
Thanks to Oregon, the Broncos picked up an indirect win against USC. The Ducks will likely now run the table in the Pac-10 and win the conference championship. And it makes me wonder: Are the Broncos better than any team in the Pac-10?
After watching Oregon win big against USC, I am fully confident that the Ducks can defeat any team in the country if they are playing well. No one beats the Trojans by 27 points, but Oregon pulled it off last week.
We will likely never know if Oregon could topple Florida or if Boise State could defeat Texas for the National Championship. The biggest debate I have been hearing about Boise State right now is whether or not they will qualify for a BCS bowl over TCU, not about their chances for a national title. The computers even have Oregon ranked ahead of Boise State, despite the direct win the Broncos own against the Ducks.
Obviously, the system is a mess. Last year, undefeated Utah rolled over Alabama in the Sugar Bowl. The Utes had no problem with the Crimson Tide, the same team that led eventual national champion Florida at the end of three quarters in last year’s SEC Championship Game. I couldn’t help but wonder how Utah would match up against Tim Tebow and the Gators.
A lot of people have discussed the possibility of a playoff in college football, but it’s time for the NCAA to take action and make a major change. This week’s top 10 features seven undefeated teams, more than I ever remember there being at this point in the season. It’s impossible to settle a debate about which team is better without finding out by watching them play on the field.
Right now, Oregon is playing as well as any team in the country. I’m sure the Ducks wish they could have that game against Boise State back, but they have done a great job moving on after the loss. As long as Boise State stays undefeated, the Ducks have no shot at making the National Championship game.
Until the BCS system is fixed, we will have no way of knowing who really is the best team in college football, especially when multiple teams go undefeated in the same season. An eight-team playoff would provide seven matchups that would all feature the teams that most people would want to see.
March Madness captivates the nation every year like no other sporting event does, as workers all across the nation drop their TPS reports and Palm Pilots and keep a watchful eye on their brackets for three weeks.
A college football playoff would be a hit. Maybe some NCAA officials are worried about the possibility of TCU knocking off Florida or Boise State pulling off an upset of Texas for a national title.
These are the kinds of upsets that have put the Madness in March, and the same kinds of upsets that we will likely never get to see in January or December.
Toland: Voting bias spans coast-to-coast
West coast bias also prevalent in college football.
National college football preview
Staff writer Case Keefer previews the nation's college football action. There are ...
Morning Brew: The BCS is a sham
Placing TCU and Boise State against each other in the Humanitarian Bowl ...
Missouri out for revenge against Oklahoma for ...
Championship games around the country help shape the BCS bowl bids.
Goble: Small schools deserve a chance
Non-BCS schools are ranked too low in preseason polls.
Dufek: How the Big 12 is challenging ...
With so many talented teams, it’s unlikely a national title contender will ...
Jayhawks need help to move up BCS ...
Jayhawk fans may be new to having to calculate the chances that ...
Morning Brew: Ignorance is bliss
The impossibility of accurate predictions keeps football season exciting.
OK-State Cowboys quietly coming back
Here are some games from around the country that warrant watching this ...
Morning Brew: Thursday night football
Montemayor suggests games to watch to tide students over until Kansas football ...
Senior writer talks Kansas sports
Dennis Dodd, senior writer for CBSSports.com discusses Kansas men’s basketball and the ...
Blog: Initial reactions to the first BCS ...
Trevor Graff goes over the current BCS standings and explains what each ...
BCS Bowl Breakdown
Analysis of this season's bowls.
Bern: Michigan was overrated
Appalachian State’s 34-32 victory over Michigan may have been historic, but columnist ...
Wheeler: College postseason should change
Every year in December and January, the nation’s top college football teams ...
Shroyer: BCS isn’t only judge of top ...
Kansan Shawn Shroyer kicks off the debate about the first BCS rankings ...
A glance at the week in college ...
Tennessee at California is the only top 25 match-up this weekend. Other ...
Roesler: ESPN overlooks the Jayhawks
The network focuses on the negatives of the team instead of the ...
Nation: November 5, 2007
This is what happened this weekend in college football.
Appalachian State raises more questions about ranking ...
At the end of each college football season, a normally controversial bowl ...
Another exciting week of college football
After some thrilling and unpredictable games in week one of college football, ...
Brew: Wacky weekend brings BCS shake-up
Three of the top five teams in college football lost this weekend, ...
Losses on top jumble BCS standings
As top two teams fall short, rankings see last-minute scramble before bowl ...
Dufek: The upsets are coming
In terms of upsets, 2008 has been a pretty mild season. But ...
Brew: Does College Football compare to College ...
BCS bowl game can’t keep with the thrill of March Madness
Bowls put Big 12 rep on the ...
The Big 12 should have an easy ride, but one upset could ...
Big 12 ‘mismatches,’ border rivalries, top defenses ...
This weekend in college football, fans experience Big 12 “mismatches,” Butkus Award ...
LSU loses No. 1 spot; Callahan loses ...
Among the weekend’s college football highlights: LSU lost to Arkansas 50-48 in ...
Shroyer: Time is now for BCS playoffs
Playoff system would need plenty of planning, but it couldn’t be much ...
Overheard: October 26, 2007
These are some comments overheard for this weekend's games
Nation’s weekend pigskin roundup
TEASE
Mizzou vs. Texas Tech highlights offense
Looking across the nation, another No. 1 team may fall this weekend ...
Big 12 fares well on opening weekend
Missouri won, Kansas State lost and, unlike the Big 10, all four ...
Who’s the best in Texas?
If Michigan beats Wisconsin Saturday, the Wolverines would be undefeated in the ...
Blog: The most wonderful time of the ...
With so many sports in action it can be hard to keep ...
Games of the week include four unbeaten
Several top-ten teams hit the road this weekend as conference play gets ...
Upsets aplenty across conference, nation
The Jayhawks didn’t play Saturday, but there was plenty of reason for ...
Here’s a recap of Saturday’s college football ...
What happened this weekend in college football.
Teams continue nonconference play in ‘Hangover Saturday’
Some high-ranked football teams struggled this weekend against lesser-ranked teams. The tough ...
Football polls undergo major changes
After the first eight weeks of college football, fans may be surprised ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID