Beecher: Kansas faces recruiting woes

For as long as he’s been on campus, there have been whispers that Mark Mangino may not be the most agreeable character. But they were subtle musings, the kind of thing everyone seems to think here, yet no one says. And even now, we don’t know much that’s any more concrete than that. The whispers have gotten louder, certainly. But I certainly don’t know whether they’re true or not.

What I do know is this: In light of the football team’s recent struggles, it would not be altogether surprising if this controversy, ultimately, results in Mangino losing his job.

And I know that scares me, because Kansas would have a very difficult time finding a head coach who could match Mangino’s success.

Of course, hiring a new head coach is always something of a crap shoot. Do you go with the hot shot young coordinator, or do you opt for the coach who’s won big at smaller schools? Perhaps you take a gamble on a virtual unknown, or maybe you throw money at a big name candidate. Whatever route you choose, there are multiple examples of similar choices that could fail.

Charlie Weis had never been a head coach before Notre Dame handed him the reigns to its storied program. Another disappointing season with first-ever lows, and Weis looks to be on his way out.

Rich Rodriguez, only in his second year at Michigan, had a bevy of success coaching West Virginia. But his winning ways have, thus far, not followed him to Ann Arbor.

And these programs are two of the most prevalent in the history of college football. They have tradition — and more importantly, resources — that Kansas football could never hope to match. Most importantly, both have the ability to recruit the entire nation.

That’s a luxury Kansas doesn’t share. Nor does Kansas have the most bountiful of local recruiting grounds. Instead, the Jayhawks are forced to compete against schools which are bigger, closer and more football-centric for middle-tier Texas preps.





All of this is not to say that Kansas cannot be a quality football program. What it does say is that the program ought to be viewed with perspective.

The stadium is too small. And even with its small size, the fanbase clearly doesn’t value the football program enough to fill it weekly.

The new facilities are great, and necessary, add-ons. But they’re still nothing compared to the palaces that exist elsewhere in the Big 12.

And again, Kansas’ location dictates that, almost certainly, it will never attract blue chip recruits.

That’s the program that Lew Perkins would have to sell a potential head coach on. And no matter how gifted a pitch man Perkins is reputed to be, the facts dictate that Kansas would have to settle, somewhat, in its hypothetical search. There would be no proven BCS-conference winners, and no highly-touted coordinators who have aspirations of landing bigger jobs.


All of this talk is, admittedly, a bit premature. I don’t know what Mangino did or didn’t do and I don’t know what will happen once the facts do become clear. But even amidst the malaise, I remember what Kansas football was before Mangino arrived. And, what’s worse, I know how easily it could be that again.

— Edited by Alicia Banister

 

Related articles

Morning Brew: The real meaning of Thanksgiving

The holiday is a time for food and football, even Kansas football.

/news/2009/nov/24/morning-brew/

Vernon: Weis still utilizes players from Texas, ...

New football coach continues to look to Texas, but not as heavily ...

/news/2012/jan/31/vernon-weis-utilizes-texas/

Morning Brew: Make me coach

Columnist gives his choice for the next football coach.

/news/2009/dec/08/morning-brew-make-me-coach/

Matson: KU football offseason generates buzz

Weis’ experience attracts recruits to build program.

/news/2012/jan/18/football-generates-buzz/

Kansas football lands Charlie Weis

Charlie Weis becomes the 37th head coach of the Kansas football team

/news/2011/dec/11/kansas-football-lands-charlie-weis/

Beecher: Why has football team failed?

Beecher attempts to find out who is at fault for this season’s ...

/news/2009/nov/05/why_has_football_team/

Final reactions to Mangino’s departure

Former and current players express thoughts on the resignation of the former ...

/news/2009/dec/10/final-reactions-manginos-departure/

Coaching uncertainty reaches recruits

Absence of head coach makes courting new players a difficult task for ...

/news/2009/dec/09/coaching-uncertainty-reaches-recruits/

Junior-college players to sign with Kansas football

Within two months, coach Weis has recruited seven junior-college transfers, eight high ...

/news/2012/jan/31/junior-college-players-sign-kansas-football/

Despite losses, top recruiting classes have potential

Kansas’ recruits, though inexperienced, have the potential for success with the proper ...

/news/2011/oct/26/gill-focus/

Kansas football coaches’ pedigrees attract top recruits

Jayhawks’ newest players wanted to stay loyal to their former coaches, who ...

/news/2012/jan/17/football-coaches/

The Jayhawks welcome the signatures of 17 ...

Football team inks eight junior college transfers and nine high school recruits ...

/news/2012/feb/01/football-recruiting/

Weis and Crist start a new KU ...

Former Notre Dame quarterback, Dayne Crist, transfers to Kansas and plans to ...

/news/2012/jan/25/weis-and-crist-start-new-ku-football-era/

Gill will continue recruiting

Despite a losing record his first season, football coach Turner Gill plans ...

/news/2010/nov/29/gill-recruiting/

Weis making strides as new head coach

Using his past experience, Weis is attempting to change the culture of ...

/news/2012/jan/16/weis-strides/

Dodd: Mangino’s flash of emotion tells a ...

An uncharacteristic display of passion by the Kansas coach gives clues to ...

/news/2008/nov/03/dodd_manginos_flash_emotion_tells_big_story/

Kansas aims to compete with Big 12’s ...

Lew Perkins says his goal is for Kansas to beat powerhouses like ...

/news/2009/oct/21/kansas-compete-big-12/

Morning Brew: Don't give up hope yet

Given time, the Jayhawks will build a better team with new coach.

/news/2010/sep/06/morning-brew/

Webb nails 43-yard field goal

/news/2005/sep/08/sp_webb/

Speculation surrounds search for a coach

The list of coaching candidates to replace Mangino is lengthy.

/news/2009/dec/07/speculation-surrounds-search-coach/

Memories of rant live on

Four years removed from notable press conference, Mangino’s comments still resonate with ...

/news/2008/nov/13/memories_rant_live/

Goble: Football team’s leadership restores faith

Statement issued by next year’s seniors shows a united desire to overcome ...

/news/2009/dec/09/football-teams-leadership-restores-faith/

Carpenter: Zenger knows football

Turner Gill still has time to grow, but athletic director Sheanon Zenger ...

/news/2011/nov/02/zenger-future/

Beecher: Focus on future, not past

Fans, players and coaches alike are constantly looking forward to ‘next year.’

/news/2010/may/06/beecher-focus-future-not-past/

Morning Brew: Damaged reputation

Mangino’s recent troubles and the investigation into Kansas football hurt the program.

/news/2009/nov/20/Morning-brew/

Mangino resigns from KU Athletics

Coach leaves after internal investigation.

/news/2009/dec/04/mangino-resigns-ku-athletics/

Kansas football program has improved

The success of the team stems from Whittemore and improved facilities.

/news/2009/sep/18/football/

Editorial: Search for new football coach begins

How Mangino's replacement interacted with players in the past will be an ...

/news/2009/dec/07/search-new-football-coach-begins/

Gill wins recruits the right way

The head coach's genuine character is the perfect complement to his plan ...

/news/2010/mar/09/gill-wins/

Gill making positive changes to Kansas football

The Jayhawks are a brand new team this year thanks to coach ...

/news/2010/jul/28/gill-making-positive-changes-kansas-football/

Loss to Texas extends week of woes ...

In a week consumed by questions of Mangino's job status, road trip ...

/news/2009/nov/21/loss-texas-extend-week-woes-football/

Beecher: Fussing about free throws

Beecher capitalizes on his Scrooge-like side to critique faulty free throws made ...

/news/2009/dec/03/column-beecher-free-throws/

Football strength coach sculpts team

Chris Dawson: Kansas football's man behind the curtain.

/news/2009/oct/28/football_strength_coach_team/

Mangino enthusiastic about upcoming season

Coach Mark Mangino spoke to Kansas fans in Wichita on Wednesday evening ...

/news/2007/jun/07/mangino_enthusiastic_about_upcoming_season/

Mangino molding a successful squad

/news/2005/aug/12/mangino_column/

Meier to return to practice

/news/2005/sep/08/meier_return_practice/

Beecher: Use perspective when calling for Bowen’s ...

The defensive coordinator is in his first year and missing star players ...

/news/2008/oct/29/beecher/

Brew: Snyder defines KSU success

Kansas State coach Bill Snyder ranks among coaching elite because of his ...

/news/2011/oct/24/brew-snyder-success/

2009's top stories

Kansan.com’s most-viewed stories show a year of tragedy, controversy and basketball.

/news/2009/dec/10/2009-top-stories/

Morning Brew: A bowl of oranges wakes ...

With a prestigious bowl under its belt, the football team is now ...

/news/2008/aug/27/morningbrew/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment