Morning Brew: Big 12 North up in the air

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Before the season began, a lot of jokes were told in which Bill Snyder figured prominently in the punch-line. The only thing saving Iowa State from similar disrespect was the fact that, frankly, no one cared enough to bother.

Now, however impossibly, Kansas State and Iowa State sit one and two, respectively, atop the Big 12 North standings. Even still, conventional wisdom dictates that this anomaly cannot and will not persist.

Bill Snyder couldn’t possibly resurrect Kansas State football again, this time in only one year. The Wildcats just aren’t talented enough. Sure, they’ve improved. But the bubble will burst when they head to Norman this week.

And Iowa State is, well, Iowa State. Iowa State does not play for conference titles; the sun will rise in the morning; the sky is blue. All three truths seem equally self-evident.

So no, the Cyclones and the Wildcats will not figure prominently in the Big 12 North title hunt. It just can’t happen.

But if not them, then who?

Missouri? Kansas? Nebraska?

All possible, certainly if pre-season predictions are taken to mean anything. After all, it was supposed to be the Jayhawks and Cornhuskers battling for dominance in the Big 12’s lesser half. Maybe, if Blaine Gabbert performed superlatively and Missouri received a few breaks, the Tigers could sneak in a challenge. But we’re well past the point of pretending that anything said about college football in August has any relevance left.

Even granting that, the beginning of the college football season seemed well in line with how things were supposed to go. Nebraska’s offense looked good enough, and its defense appeared dominant. The inverse could have been said of Kansas, owners of an iffy defense and explosive offense. And it even looked as if Missouri might get that superlative play from Gabbert that would enable it to mount a challenge.

Then conference play began, and things got weird.

Kansas beat Iowa State, which beat Nebraska, which beat Missouri. Kansas State destroyed Texas A&M, which did the same to Texas Tech, which embarrassed Kansas State by 52 points.

And so, using the transitive property of sports, we can clearly see that none of this makes any sense. Which is precisely why Kansas State and Iowa State could, easily enough, remain on top of the Big 12 North. Not because either team is particularly good, but because none of their competitors are either. With this degree of parity, the old cliche about everyone being capable of beating everyone else actually rings true. And so the question shouldn’t be “Why Kansas State and Iowa State?” but rather, “Why not?”

— Edited by Jonathan Hermes

Beecher: Video games predict Kansas wins

Kansas handles Iowa State without trouble and ends up earning another BCS ...

/news/2009/oct/01/beecher-video-games-predict-kansas-wins/

Beecher: Football loss recalls the ’90s

Familiar Jayhawk loss to Bill Snyder’s Wildcats is as unwelcome as the ...

/news/2009/nov/09/beecher-football-loss/

Big 12 North football previews

Big 12 North football previews for Nebraska, Iowa State, Colorado, Missouri and ...

/news/2009/aug/20/big_12_north_football_previews/

Dodd: Big 12 North teams have a ...

Kansas and Missouri were supposed to reign in the Big 12 this ...

/news/2008/oct/20/Football_Column/

North has what it takes

The usually South dominated Big 12 now sees competition from the North.

/news/2007/oct/31/north_has_what_it_takes/

Beecher: Thursday not for small teams

Missouri and Nebraska square off this week in the unexpected time slot.

/news/2009/oct/08/beecher-thursday-not-small-teams/

Brew: Snyder defines KSU success

Kansas State coach Bill Snyder ranks among coaching elite because of his ...

/news/2011/oct/24/brew-snyder-success/

Women’s Big 12 Conference competitive

A run-down of The Big 12 women’s conference

/news/2008/jan/29/womens_big_12/

Breckunitch: Football season will be good

Spring game invites speculation about the Jayhawk football’s chances for Big 12 ...

/news/2009/apr/10/breckunitch_football_season_will_be_good/

Big 12 sees upsets and surprise victories

Kansas State wins again, and Nebraska and Missouri are defeated.

/news/2009/oct/26/big-12-sees-upsets-victories/

Roesler: Dramatic future for Big 12 North

Possible outcomes in the conference give fans food for thought.

/news/2009/oct/06/roesler/

Missouri's Smith captures national honors after victory

/news/2005/oct/25/big_12_notebook/

All eyes on the Sunflower Showdown

After two Big 12 South upsets last week, the Big 12 North ...

/news/2007/oct/04/Big_12/

Beecher: To the victor should go the ...

Kansas’ Border Showdown victory should earn reparations from Missouri.

/news/2008/dec/03/beecher/

Nebraska clinches spot in Big 12 title ...

Kansas State’s season, hopes of bowl bid end abruptly after loss.

/news/2009/nov/23/big-12-title-game/

Big 12 fares well on opening weekend

Missouri won, Kansas State lost and, unlike the Big 10, all four ...

/news/2007/sep/04/nation/

Carpenter: Kansas football faces tough competition

With Nebraska and Colorado departing from the Big 12 in July, Kansas ...

/news/2011/may/04/carpenter-kansas-football-faces-tough-competition/

Montemayor: Jayhawks lost their spark

Another disappointing weekend for Kansas played out on the national stage.

/news/2009/oct/26/montemayor-jayhawks/

Tigers shoot for North Division Title

Missouri started 6-0 last season but dropped five of their next seven ...

/news/2007/aug/13/preview/

Football team must follow two-step plan

Jayhawks can regain honor by beating Kansas State and Missouri.

/news/2010/oct/11/two-step-plan/

Kansas State preview

/news/2005/aug/31/sp_kansas_state_preview/

Kansas hopes to win Big 12 North

/news/2005/aug/31/sp_berk_column/

Tough schedule may slow K-State football team

With a rough non-conference schedule on top of road games against Texas, ...

/news/2007/aug/16/ksu_preview/

Beecher: Cinderella football season strikes midnight

Jayhawks have fallen from last season’s peak, but fans still have reason ...

/news/2008/nov/12/beecher/

Big 12 football review

/news/2005/oct/18/big_12_football/

Wiebe’s women’s Big 12 basketball update

Andrew Wiebe’s take on the Big 12 women’s teams

/news/2008/feb/05/wiebes_womens_big_12_basketball_update/

Wheeler: Snyder, Mangino have similar coaching careers

Bill Snyder made remarkable progress with Kansas State during his first five ...

/news/2007/oct/22/wheeler/

Big 12 loses four games in week ...

Other conference teams rebound from poor early-season performances.

/news/2009/sep/21/big_12_loses_three_games_week_3/

Beecher: Jayhawks root for Missouri?

Sympathy might explain why Kansas fans cheer for Tigers.

/news/2009/mar/25/root_missouri/

Wiebe: Big 12 women's basketball rankings

Andrew Wiebe looks at the women's basketball teams of the Big 12.

/news/2008/feb/19/wiebe_big_12/

Oklahoma still the cream of the Big ...

Don’t expect an immediate change in Kansas’ rankings despite a good recruiting ...

/news/2011/feb/09/oklahoma-still-cream-big-12/

With football, expect the unexpected

Kansas' up-and-down record shows that nothing can be predicted.

/news/2010/oct/12/football-expect-unexpected/

Race for the Big 12 title

The Big 12 Conference regular season has reached its halfway point. The ...

/news/2008/feb/06/race_big_12_title/

Carpenter: Pac-12 a good home for Kansas-Missouri ...

With the Big 12’s future in question, Kansas needs conference options.

/news/2011/sep/14/Kansas-big12/

National college football preview

Staff writer Case Keefer previews the nation's college football action. There are ...

/news/2007/nov/22/national_college_football_preview/

Big 12 boasts three of nation’s best

In recent years, Texas and Oklahoma were the only consistent representatives for ...

/news/2007/nov/07/big_12_boasts_three_nations_best/

Big 12 Media Day: Overview of Big ...

See how next Football seasons looks before it starts.

/news/2009/jul/29/big_12_media_day_overview_big_12_teams/

Big 12 teams win all but one ...

Texas Tech lost the only Big 12 game by one point to ...

/news/2009/sep/28/big_12/

Basketball Preview: Nov. 8, 2007

The national title is up for grabs this year in college basketball. ...

/news/2007/nov/08/Basketball_Preview/

Breaking down challengers for conference crown

Kansan writers examine the Big XII men's race.

/news/2009/oct/28/breaking-down-challengers-conference-crown/

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment

Or login with:

OpenID