Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Lauren Bornstein’s column entitled “Intersex athletes face unfair rules” left me speechless. I simply could not believe what I was reading. Personally, I don’t feel Caster Semenya was treated wrong or unfairly. I think the International Association of Athletics Federation had every right to, and should have, made Semenya take a gender test.
I did a little research of my own, and found out that Semenya has internal testes, which we all know to be male genitalia. She lacks a womb and ovaries and has a testosterone level more than three times that of a normal woman. You say that other people are deciding her gender for her, but all the results seem to point to her being a male.
I completely agree with you regarding her being called a hermaphrodite; that is totally false and an extremely ignorant thing to say.
The issue, as a whole, I have no problem with. If she thinks she’s a woman then so be it; it’s none of my business. The problem begins when she tries to compete in a woman’s sport with a body that is technically male. That is unfair to all of her competitors, who you claim to be exhibiting “poor sportsmanship.” They have every right to be upset if they are competing in a woman’s sport against male athletes.
No male would ever be allowed to compete in a woman’s sport — why should it matter what sex he thinks he is? Semenya is an excellent athlete, but she should be competing with athletes of the same sex.
You say that forcing Semenya and other female athletes to prove their sex shouldn’t be done, but that’s exactly what needs to be done. Competing in a woman’s sport, all participants should be female.
I referred to Semenya as a “she” out of respect, because that is what she believes she is.
— Chris L. Brown is a sophomore from Fort Scott.
Bornstein: Intersex athletes face unfair rules
Athletes who don't conform to the standard dichotomy are at a disadvantage.
Sexually (inter)Active: What is the purpose of ...
Three panelists weigh in on how "roles" continue to define relationships.
Coming out into freedom
Queers and Allies will host a speaker Tuesday in honor of National ...
Embrace the F-word
Identity crisis: Lauren's story
Lauren is a female who takes masculine roles in lesbian relationships.
Cohen: How Palin’s campaign made me appreciate ...
Phillips: Title IX has gone too far
Coach Henrickson may have to say goodbye to the men she has ...
KU student named top deaf athlete
Bornstein: Respect from others starts with respecting ...
Discrimination toward bisexuals from within LGBT community creates conflict.
Pride Week events demonstrate need for gender-neutral ...
Transgender students face fear and humiliation with simple male and female decisions.
Mixing it up
Mixed-gender living is common during college years — and often looked at ...
Osterhaus: Traditional image of anorexic female ignores ...
Just like women who become ill, men have similar psychological or self-esteem ...
Balancing the burden of birth control
A new contraceptive pill could soon give men the opportunity to take ...
Was Harry right?
Testing whether men and women can be just friends
Thornbrugh: What book Western Civ should have ...
McLeod: There’s an abuse double standard
Male abuse victimes increasing while social norms allow the ‘weak’ woman to ...
Hirschfeld: Why won't the Red Cross take ...
Christian mother vocalizes her joy of sex.
Devoted mother shares her joys of sex and gives tips on how ...
Faking it lets women live up to ...
Women discuss their secrets to faking an orgasm.
University celebrates 40 years of women’s athletics
Marlene Mawson’s induction and rowing boathouse dedication highlights weekend devoted to women’s ...
Bledowski: Safety cannot be neglected during sex
Safe sex must remain, as always, a priority.
Mixed gender living situations work out
May is National Cohabitation Month.
Swingers
Cyndi walks in the front door of a very familiar home. Her ...
Lytton: Women's holiday should be celebrated by ...
Potential of International Women's Day goes unrecognized in the US, where few ...
Durbin: Ignorance breeds gender inequalities
Women, men are capable of same things.
Certain behaviors increase need for STD testing
Health centers follow the motto, better safe than sorry, when it comes ...
Transgenders share stories of perseverance
The International Transgender Day of Remembrance was this past Saturday.
Beauty of the fairer sex
Both women and men performed in "Genius of Women," a talent show ...
Funny Females
We've come a long way since "I love Lucy."
Bornstein: Second-class citizenship
Same-sex marriage ensures equal rights for all U.S. citizens.
Bledowski: New research finds some things to ...
Dissertation on sexual habits of students prods privacy.
Bornstein: Sexuality isn't simply about blowing smoke
Percentage of people who smoke is above average in LGBT community.
Dealing with injuries
After two Jayhawks tore their ACLs during this basketball season, The Wave ...
Blakeborough: Society needs changes, but to start, ...
Sexism is here, it’s just not as easy to spot as it ...
Love and lust in college
From one-night stands to long-term relationships, students’ perceptions of the collegiate dating ...
She Rocks
For years, women were excluded from the boys-only rock ‘n’ roll club. ...
Bornstein: Battling with — and under — ...
Prohibiting openly gay men and women from participating in the military benefits ...
Alumnae top Forbes’ 100 Most Powerful Women
Two graduates rank within top 10 in Forbes Magazine’s 100 Most Powerful ...
GSP-Corbin celebrate rich history
With very few gender exclusive residence halls left, GSP-Corbin takes the opportunity ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
Good work Chris Brown.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
Chris Brown, you are wrong. Technically speaking Caster Semanya is "technically" intersexed, but has a working vagina. And prior to the test and race, she didn't know this. So, if tomorrow, you woke up and found out you "technically" have fallopian tubes, should we "technically" consider you a female?
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
I know this was directed toward Mr. Brown and not me, but if I woke up and found that I had fallopian tubes, then yes, I should technically be considered a female.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
The purpose of having separate events for women and men is to create a fair ground based on differences between sex, not gender. Thus, it is irrelevant for these purposes what gender an athlete considers themselves to be.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
Well if you have a penis, but you have fallopian tubes, I doubt that you would start declaring yourself a female to the world.
And "technically" speaking, a doctor would still consider you intersexed if you have both, not one or the other. Caster is not considered a male by doctors, she's considered intersexed.
The question boils down to, do we want to exclude intersexed people from competing in mainstream sports, despite the fact that they never had a choice about the body parts they were born with? If that is what we want to do, what other groups of people should we start excluding because they have what some consider to be an "unfair disadvantage"? There is a big difference between born a certain way, and changing your body to become something else with hormones and steiroids.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
This person does not know the difference between the words "gender" and "sex" and therefore his entire argument is invalidated from the second paragraph. Nice of the Daily Kansan to humor him, though. I guess he's only a sophomore, so he has plenty of time to take a class in Women's Studies, or any other humanities for that matter...
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
Nice try Texas...but no, his entire argument isn't invalidated (though I might agree your dripping contempt for his academic status invalidates your comment).
I know you think you're a lot more sophisticated than this mere sophomore, but Mr. Brown provided a thoughtful and lucid analysis to a complex issue. All you did was lampoon his education - a personal attack. Is that what they taught you in Women's Studies? Pretty impressive stuff...
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
I did not mean to "lampoon" his education, just say that he has lots of time to keep learning. His use of the word "gender" in the second paragraph is, in fact, incorrect. I simply pointed out a flaw in his argument as I see that you have done many times in the past, RTBatKU. After all, isn't that what these comment boxes are for?
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
If you were simply pointing out his misuse of the word, then why didn't you simply correct it instead of fallaciously stating it invalidates his entire argument?
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
Texas and Linguo:
I think you are both far too confident in labeling Mr. Brown’s use of the term ‘gender’ as incorrect. You seem to have seized upon the definition you approve of and simply ignored competing views.
I hate to rely upon this in support of my point, but Wikipedia (by no means a superior authority) notes that, as “a term, ‘gender’ has more than one valid definition. Colloquially, it is used interchangeably with ‘sex’ to denote the condition of being male or female in any type of organism. In the social sciences, however, it refers specifically to social differences such as but not limited to gender identity.”
The article goes on to state that while “the idea of gender as a social construct is favored in many social sciences, especially gender studies, in the hard sciences, research links biological and behavioral differences in males and females as determining factors for gender . . . in humans and other species.”
You two may contest the way Mr. Brown used the term and even argue that the gender studies-approved definition should reign supreme (which I would not find very persuasive). But this wasn’t what you did. Instead, you simply seized upon his use of “gender” as incorrect and contradictory to his argument. I don’t think your position or tactic can withstand scrutiny.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
I'm not willing to write off an individual's entire argument because I disagree with their use of a term of art. I'm not willing to dismiss an opinion as irrelevant and misguided because I don't like their viewpoint. I think it's disingenuous to suggest that you would find merit in Mr. Brown's writing had he only altered his word choice.
Letter to editor: Gender tests necessary
First of all, the use or misuse of the term 'gender' shouldn't be the main focus here. I agree that gender should be used in relation to a person's identity, while sex should be used when speaking of physical anatomy. Nevertheless, Chris's use of 'gender' in a way which does not coincide with my definition does not invalidate his argument.
I do, however, disagree with his opinion on multiple accounts. First, having testes does not automatically make one a male. As the athlete in question has both male and female anatomy, she is considered intersexed. I respect Chris's choice to use the same pronoun choice as Caster Semenya's gender. That is how she recognizes herself, and that is how she should be recognized by others.
Now this is where we get into more of a gray area. If we are to have sports which are segregated by sex, we need to pay more attention to intersexed athletes. Chris says that it's unfair to all female athletes to have an intersexed competitor in their midst. Is he assuming that being male is simply the more dominant sex when it comes to sports? In that case, wouldn't an intersexed athlete be at a disadvantage to compete against all males?
Should we have intersex sports as well as male and female? How many intersex athletes are out there? I would assume a lot less than male or female. Would this have an impact on the recognition that one receives when winning?
Personally, I think requiring athletes to prove their sex is opening up a totally different can of worms. How far is too far? Maybe we should have a little room in every sports center where athletes drop their pants to prove their sex before a competition.
...
Can I volunteer for that job?
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID