Wednesday, September 30, 2009
Students proudly wearing and buying shirts from Joe College can thank business owner Larry Sinks for fighting a legal battle with Kansas Athletics Inc. that ended in a settlement in July 2007. But the battle isn’t over.
A federal judge ruled Monday that Sinks owes Kansas Athletics Inc. $667,507 in attorney fees and court expenses after the settlement ended with Sinks awarding Kansas Athletics Inc. $127,337 in damages for “trademark infringement.”
Jim Marchiony, associate athletics director, said the shirts created confusion in the marketplace and ultimately took money away from student scholarships funded by license revenue. Marchiony told the Lawrence Journal-World that Kansas Athletics Inc. earned about $2 million per year in licensing revenues.
“Every unlicensed shirt sold means a licensed shirt isn’t being sold,” Marchiony said, “Larry Sinks is still selling shirts that are not acceptable.” Marchiony said any blue shirt with “Kansas” was a KU trademark.
Clark Siebert, Pretty Prairie senior and owner of a Joe College T-shirt, said he thought most students knew the difference between KU shirts and Joe College shirts, and the latest amount Sinks had to pay was “ridiculous.”
“He’s just trying to make a living with his T-shirt shop,” Siebert said.
Marchiony, however, said Sinks had been contacted on multiple occasions to correct his illegal practices and Kansas Athletics Inc. did not want to go to trial.
“The amount is something we don’t have a real feeling about,” Machiony said, “It’s the message from the jury.”
Sinks, who was not available for comment Tuesday, told the Lawrence Journal-World that he didn’t have $667,507.
Sink’s attorney, James Tilly, said he wasn’t sure what Monday’s ruling meant for Joe College’s future. He said if Sinks made the decision to file an appeal, the case would move to the 10th district federal appeals court in Denver, the next step in this process.
Alex Herman, Hays third-year law student, said Sinks had 30 days after court ruling to file an appeal under federal law.
“This is clearly a devastating decision,” Herman said, “I assume this would put him out of business.”
Herman said he didn’t like seeing the shirts and thought they confused people who weren’t familiar with the store, but he also said he saw the value in having an independent business.
“On one hand he should have known the risk, but at the same time it’s tough to see a business owner shaken down by the university,” Herman said.
Marchiony said the intention was never to put Joe College out of business, but rather see that Sinks not continue selling shirts that breach trademark infringement.
— — Edited by Betsy Cutcliff
Project turns into Joe College fundraiser
Students host a concert to raise money for Larry Sinks’ legal fees.
Joe-College.com faces off with Athletics Department in ...
Local apparel store’s famous T-shirts “Muck Fizzou” may become a thing of ...
Joe College trademark battle continues
The Athletics Department and Joe College were unable to agree in a ...
Unlicensed: A T-Shirt Tale
Meet Larry Sinks, the man behind JoeCollege.com and its controversial T-shirts.
Battle over unlicensed T-shirts proceeds
The University sited trademark infringement against a local T-Shirt vendor in a ...
Joe-College.com company may be shut down
Swimming team shirts with sperm on them are not the kind of ...
Joe College to close its doors for ...
Customers can buy marked down shirts until final day of business Wednesday.
Jury rules against Joe-College.com
The T-shirt retailer must pay the University more than $100,000 and desist ...
Minster: KU athletics greedy for revenue
The KU athletics department wants to bring down Joe-College.com for not paying ...
Mangiaracina: We won’t be national champions in ...
The cost of school spirit: labor in ...
Labor practices behind licensed KU apparel are difficult to track, but organizations ...
Letter: Why I decided not to shop ...
Editorial: Trademarks probably not violated
The University has pending legal issues with Joe-College.com, which may be illegally ...
Editorial: Shirts hurt University’s image
The University of Kansas is linked with many outstanding people and accomplishments. ...
Bud Light team-colored cans causing stir
University expresses concern about blue and red cans promoting underage drinking.
Montemayor: Fan Cans not the problem
Universities accuse Anheuser-Busch promotion using team colors of causing underage drinking.
University continues to clash with T-shirt vendor
KU adds 10 shirts to a lawsuit against Joecollege.com.
Student finds void in KU merchandise
After several months and hundreds of dollars, Miller has turned his idea ...
Robinett: T-shirts go to waste
Some students can’t reap benefits of free T-shirts because there are rarely ...
KU apparel stores compete in saturated market
With as many as 15 places to buy KU gear in Lawrence, ...
Mangiaracina: The dirt on the turf
Robinett: Rivalry shirts get uglier
A T-shirt celebrating a victory for racism tarnishes the tradition more than ...
University to replace ‘Muck Fizzou’ slogan
Last year, ESPN announced that it would not show KU students wearing ...
Letter to the Editor
Game day and rivalry shirts should reflect positive spirit of KU. Slogan ...
Winning T-shirt slogans revealed
The contest to create new slogans to replace the “Muck Fizzou” shirt ...
Move to Arrowhead affects more than fans
Although the fans and players have been affected, Sports Dome has seen ...
Player sues for Title IX violation
Former football sues University for not letting him play another year of ...
Alumni group bashes new font
This summer the KU Athletics Department decided to adopt the official KU ...
Morning Brew: Don’t waste 2009 T-shirts
KU should follow the lead of a Tennessee football T-shirt donation.
McLeod: T-shirt issue borders on censorship
Offensive or not, the “Muck Fizzou” shirt is still embodiment of student ...
KU Final Four T-shirts to be donated ...
Businesses that pre-ordered KU Final Four T-shirts are now forced to donate ...
Editorial: Senate relationship compromises constituents’ interests
The Senate failed the students (and Senate’s own rules) by keeping a ...
Editorial: Athletics shows support for academics with ...
Potential donation from the Athletics Department to the academics at the University ...
Businesses cash in on political t-shirts
Demockratees and other businesses are catering to heightened interest in the wake ...
NCAA suspends Selby nine games
The NCAA ruled that Josh Selby must sit out nine games for ...
Adidas contract provides more than Nike
Nike left non-revenue sports behind and only provided for men’s basketball and ...
No more dough from Joe
Joe’s Bakery closed Friday for the second time after concern from its ...
United Students candidates fined
Two campaigning violation charges against the coalition were dropped while two resulted ...
Students start clothing label
Three KU students found inspiration in a TV show to start their ...
Varitety of colors find their way into ...
As a rainbow of greens, pinks and oranges seep into the usually ...
Kansas Jayhawk fans hold aloft a reproduction of ...
2 comments
Erin Saupe, a Ph.D. student from St. Cloud, ...
1 comment
0 comments
Armed robbers continue to threaten.
3 comments
Lecture from Greg Mortenson, co-author of New York ...
0 comments
KUnited presidential candidate Libby Johnson and vice presidential ...
1 comment
Comments
Joe College battle not over
Any blue shirt with Kansas is a KU trademark? It is downright frightening that the Athletics Department has the hubris to think they can copyright the combination of a primary color and the name of a state.
Joe College battle not over
I mean copyright law, not constitutional law.
Joe College battle not over
No, Hendrix. A JURY determined that they violation trademark law, which I'm guessing never of us completely understand. Sinks ignored court orders, multiple times, and continued to make the shirts anyway.
Oh, and Lauren Hendricks: students shouldn't thank Larry Sinks at all. Remember, the licensing revenue lost would have gone to scholarships for students, mostly non-athletes. What an incredibly biased way to start a story.
Joe College battle not over
I don't dispute that some of the shirts do violate copyright law; but I am questioning the university claiming to extend that protection as far as they did. What's next, copyrighting the shape of the state of Kansas because it used to appear on the Allen Fieldhouse Court?
If you recall, the jury found some of the shirts to violate constitutional law and others not to. Let's leave the determination to the jury; my comment specifically referred to Jim Marchiony's comment.
Joe College battle not over
Hendrix, stop blowing smoke out of your ass. You know nothing about the legal proceedings that went on in the Sinks trial. That entire store was a blatant copyright infringement, not matter what Sinks' printed signs said. Wake the hell up.
Joe College battle not over
Hey, how about we tone down the animosity a little bit? Sheesh.
Joe College battle not over
For the second time, I said that I fully agree that many of the shirts are copyright infringements. Where did I specifically defend any shirt other than one that would have the word "Kansas" on the color blue, and why are you attacking me for supposedly being ignorant? I've been in the store and I know exactly what's in there, and I didn't say anything about the signs on the front of the store. Calm down. The only thing I was referring to was Jim Marchiony's statement, which none of you have responded to; you've just attacked me for no reason.
Joe College battle not over
If I hear "you can't trademark colors" or "I can't believe KU thinks it can trademark the word "Kansas"" one more time I think I'm going to vomit. Admittedly, intellectual property is not the most straightforward field of the law, and it doesn't surprise me that a bunch of undergrads (or laypersons on the ljworld, for that matter) don't understand it. But please, educate yourselves before directing such inflammatory remarks toward the athletics department. I'm sorry if this is a shock to you, but color schemes and words can constitute a trademark. Even "Kansas," white and blue. Furthermore, in this case, if the overall context of a design has the tendency to confuse people who see it as to whether it was officially licensed by KU, then it is an infringement of KU's trademark if it is not licensed. You can dislike the law all you want, and I would encourage you to write your legislators if you feel strongly enough about it in order to overhaul the current state of intellectual property law. However, until such a thing happens, KU is absolutely within its legal rights to go after Joe College. End of story.
Joe College battle not over
^ Miced.
Joe College battle not over
I like Joe College, I know the University doesn't sell those. I understand they violated laws, shame on them. But, seriously ... it's just a shirt. I honestly don't think the scholarships would have benefited very many people. KU doesn't hand a lot of money out. It sucks, but I still love the school. However, I also love Joe College & wish the Athletic Department would just leave them alone. The students love the shirts, they are worn all across the state. I've seen six year olds wear them and sixty year olds wear them. You go to any Jayhawk game and a vast majority of the shirts there are Joe College shirts. Is somebody a bit jealous? . . Only kidding, but it could be seen that way a bit.
Joe College battle not over
RCC, thanks for giving people yet another reason to dislike lawyers. Let me apologize for the lowly undergrads who don't understand all the complexities of property law. It must be so difficult for you to endure. Hang in there, sport.
Any law student or lawyer knows that there are always two sides to the argument and courts are always going different ways. Can color designate trademark? The USSC heard a case on it as late as 1995. The benchmark for allowing a color as a trademark is set fairly high. Are you a law student? Would you be this big a snob responding to a classmate's comment in class?
Joe College battle not over
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I'm just a caveman. I fell on some ice and later got thawed out by some of your scientists. Your world frightens and confuses me! Sometimes the honking horns of your traffic make me want to get out of my BMW.. and run off into the hills, or wherever.. Sometimes when I get a message on my fax machine, I wonder: "Did little demons get inside and type it?" I don't know! My primitive mind can't grasp these concepts. But there is one thing I do know - Joe College t-shirts are dumb.
Joe College battle not over
Yo, Joe College, I'm really happy for you, and imma let you finish, but tshirthell had one of the best t-shirts of all time!
Joe College battle not over
10,000,000 points for the Caveman Lawyer reference. That is all.
Sign in to comment
Or login with:
OpenID