Bank regulations protect against overdraft

Jessica Janasz didn’t think twice before swiping her Commerce Bank debit card to pay for a $10 haircut.

The next day and one debit card purchase later, she checked her online account and realized she had been charged $55 in overdraft fees.

“I thought it was absolutely ridiculous that I was charged so much,” said Janasz, a junior from Overland Park.

Janasz isn’t alone in her frustrations with overdraft fees. According to a 2008 report by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., nearly half of people ages 18-25 incur fees each year for attempting to withdraw more money from an account than is available.

Big Bucks

Banks in the United States stood to collect $38.5 billion in overdraft fees in 2009, according to data from Moebs $ervices, an economic research firm.

However, new Federal Reserve regulations set to take effect this summer will soon cause banks to face stricter rules for charging overdraft fees.

The Federal Reserve regulations will require banks to explain overdraft policies and get written consent from customers who enroll in overdraft protection programs. The alternative would be for customers to have bankcard withdrawals denied when the checking account has no money.

Even with the changes, consumer advocates are demanding more protection. Director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America Jean Ann Fox said the new Federal Reserve regulations don’t go far enough.

Fox said the regulations don’t protect consumers from disproportionate charges, additional fees assessed when charges aren’t paid and charges from using paper checks.

“Competition hasn’t disciplined banks and the Federal Reserve hasn’t taken the necessary steps, so Congress needs to take action,” Fox said.

The Consumer Federation of America is supporting the passage of House Bill 3904 and Senate Bill 1799, which would “amend the Truth in Lending Act to establish fair and transparent practices related to the marketing and provision of overdraft coverage programs at depository institutions, and for other purposes,” the legislation states. Both bills have been held up in committees since the fall.

U.S. Rep. Dennis Moore is a chairman on the Financial Services committee that is currently considering House Bill 3904. He said the Federal Reserve regulations were a step in the right direction, but more should be done to protect consumers.

“Congress needs to ensure a $2 cup of coffee doesn’t end up costing the consumer $40 in fees,” Moore said through e-mail.

Robert DeYong, director of KU Center for Banking Excellence, said students don’t need to wait for the law to offer protection from overdraft charges.

“The best way to avoid fees is to keep track of what you spend,” DeYoung said. “You shouldn’t write checks or use debit cards without writing it down in a bank book.”

Daniel Rezaiekhaligh, a senior from Kansas City, Mo., said he learned to be more diligent about checking his account records after he was charged $80 in fees from Bank of America for a $1.80 purchase.

“Once you have it happen, you’ll see it’s such a scam,” Rezaiekhaligh said.

Rezaiekhaligh said it helps to keep track of finances, but banks also need to be more responsible for telling their customers about overdraft charges.

“Banks will notify you about anything else, but not about overdrafts,” Rezaiekhaligh said. “You never hear, ‘Hey, not only are you out of money, but we’re charging you $25 more dollars.’”

In a statement about its overdraft policies, Commerce Bank said, “Commerce Bank has invested in providing more information and services to help customers effectively manage their finances to avoid overdrafts.”

A Bank of America representative did not respond to an interview request.

With the new regulations set to begin this summer and more legislation pending Congress, banks will soon have to readjust their policies.

In the meantime, Fox, from the Consumer Federation of America, has one suggestion: “Leave your debit card at home.”

Check out Braden Katz's article for more information about debit cards and overdraft charges.

— Edited by Sarah Bluvas

 

Related articles

Editorial: Students pay for bank policies

Overdraft fees are too high.

/news/2010/mar/02/students-pay-bank-policies/

Overdraft fees affect student finances

New bill could change the way banks deal with people who overdraw ...

/news/2009/dec/10/overdraft-fees-affect-student-finances/

Consumer concerns of debit card plan answered

After public outcry, Bank of America has listened to it’s customers

/news/2011/nov/01/consumer-concerns-answered/

Katz: Debt-it cards

Banks are unfairly profiting off of vulnerable citizens.

/news/2010/mar/01/katz-debt/

Letter to the Editor: Governments, not banks, ...

Government regulations harmful for banks and people.

/news/2010/mar/03/letter-editor/

Editorial: Increases in ATM fees unreasonable

With banks considering following Bank of America’s decision to raise prices, alternatives ...

/news/2007/sep/20/Editorial/

Editorial: The semester might be over, but ...

A look at some important things to keep up with this summer.

/news/2010/may/06/editorial-semester-over-still-stay-opinionated/

Essential life skills: Balancing your checkbook

In case of emergency, read quickly.

/news/2010/nov/11/essential-life-skills-balancing-your-checkbook/

Students find themselves maxed out

It can be easy to accumulate large credit card debts while in ...

/news/2009/jun/30/credit/

/comments/cr/33/13694/#c10173

/videos/2009/nov/06/454/

Doing Without: Money

Absence makes the heart grow...?

/news/2011/apr/28/Manual-doing-without-money/

Credit card scam put to an end ...

/news/2005/aug/26/credit_card_scam/

Law restricts ownership of credit cards

A co-signer is now required for people under 21.

/news/2010/feb/22/law-restricts-ownership-credit/

Hertz to offer rental cars to students ...

Four rental cars will be available to rent on campus next semester ...

/news/2011/nov/30/hertz-rental/

McCroy: ObamaCare Gives Federal Government Too Much ...

With the recent supreme court debates about ObamaCare, we must think back ...

/news/2012/apr/03/mccroy-obamacare-gives-federal-government-too-much/

Private loan market evaluated

The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Department of Education are ...

/news/2011/nov/20/private-loan/

Corrigan: ObamaCare not right for all

ObamaCare puts into question the power of the federal government, and suggests ...

/news/2012/mar/30/corrigan-obamacare-not-right-all/

Personal Finance class keeps money in your ...

Students learn about how to budget, save for future.

/news/2009/apr/23/personal_finance/

Paying at the pump? Some stations prefer ...

Rising gas costs causing higher credit card company fees for gas stations.

/news/2008/jun/29/cash/

Identity theft can affect anyone

"I immediately realized something was not right," Melanie Krumsick said.

/news/2009/apr/06/identitytheft/

Scott: Society continues to stereotype government

The fear of big government still sticks with Americans.

/news/2010/oct/20/scott-society-continues-stereotype-government/

Westar pays for environmental violation

The Topeka-based power company agreed to pay $500 million for violating the ...

/news/2010/jan/28/westar-pays-environmental-violation/

/comments/cr/33/13694/#c10135

Williams: Economy causes strife for students

Economic problems suck.

/news/2008/mar/31/economy_causes_strife_students/

Identification cards get new look

New card design fails to impress KU students, and they still prefer ...

/news/2008/jun/03/identification_cards_get_new_look/

Smart shopping

Tips on how to save money while surviving seasonal rushes and scams

/news/2007/nov/29/smart_shopping/

All tabbed out

/news/2005/nov/11/bar_tab/

On The Record: August 24, 2007

Today's OTR features theft of the textbook, bicycle and debit card variety.

/news/2007/aug/24/otr/

Discussing the future of energy

Brownback and 13 experts of energy and regulation debate energy business and ...

/news/2011/apr/14/discussing-future-energy/

Oral contraceptive prices on the rise

Changes in federal laws have made it hard for colleges to offer ...

/news/2010/oct/26/contraceptive-prices/

Facing the music

For 13 students sued by the music industry, the risks of illegal ...

/news/2008/apr/30/facing_music/

Letter to the Editor: Pro-choice protection

New amendment would make it hard for insurance companies to cover abortion.

/news/2009/nov/20/letter-editor-pro-choice-protection/

Downtown retail competes with new restaurants

In the past year, five stores closed and were replaced with eateries ...

/news/2010/mar/08/downtown-retail-competes-new-restaurants/

Editorial: Policy hurts student groups

The Kansas Union currently charges groups selling products or charging admission $100 ...

/news/2010/may/05/editorial-policy-hurts-student-groups/

Romance can boom or bust on Valentine’s ...

The holiday is a great opportunity to boost relationships, but also leads ...

/news/2010/feb/12/romance-can-boom-or-bust-valentines-day/

Committee discuses student fee increase

The rising cost of fuel and other products along with the desire ...

/news/2007/oct/30/committee_discuses_student_fee_increase/

Lowell: Two steps forward, one step back

Allowing off-shore drilling is a political compromise, but keep big picture in ...

/news/2010/apr/09/lowell-drilling/

Students deal with life after house fire

All 13 students escaped without injuries, but fire and water damage destroyed ...

/news/2011/sep/12/house-fire/

Davidson: Tips for recovering from spring break ...

After vacation, financial reality sets in.

/news/2009/mar/23/davidson_tips/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment