Boultinghouse: JFK miniseries a threat to accuracy

Today’s History Channel programming includes Ax Men, Pawn Stars and Ice Road Truckers, shows about the American Northwest logging industry, arctic trucking operations and the items in a Las Vegas pawn shop, respectively.

Although entertaining, I don’t actually learn any valuable history after watching an episode, save for snippets about the respective industries and information about the items people pawn,

For me, it used to be fine that the History Channel had a couple of programs that didn’t actually engage history. The personalities of the truckers, loggers, and pawn operators are entertaining, and when compared to the other trash on television, it’s possible to find a lot worse. I can let it slide that the History Channel markets these shows on contemporary culture as its primary programs, instead of informative documentaries or groundbreaking research, until now.

The History Channel’s tendency to back away from actual history is fine when the topic is overweight truckers and the good ol’ boys in the pawn shop. But in the first script of a potential television miniseries over the Kennedy family, historically accurate, knowledgeable scenes are missing.

For starters, director Joel Surnow, creator of FOX’s “24” and outspoken conservative, defended his upcoming miniseries as a “dramatization,” implying that the historical errors that several prominent historians have identified in the script can be ignored.

Some of the alleged inaccuracies are dramatic conversations between President Kennedy and his advisor Theodore Sorensen. Sorensen says these conversations never occurred. Other details, such as the implication that President Kennedy first proposed the Berlin Wall, are simply made up, according to Kennedy scholars.

In one of many sexual references, the filming calls for a Secret Service agent to approach the president as he’s having sex with another woman. Scholars claim that negative portrayals such as this demonstrate Surnow’s right-wing political agenda in creating the film. These scholars are speaking out in a video by liberal filmmaker Robert Greenwald cautioning people to be skeptical of the Surnow’s representation. When people tune into the History Channel, they assume that what they’re watching is historically accurate.

Now, these same people will watch “The Kennedys” and use it to refine their outlook on the Kennedy presidency and the other events of the 1960s—for the worse if Surnow keeps the historical errors in the series. The History Channel should not allow this miniseries to run unless Surnow drastically reforms his political attack job into an accurate representation of the Kennedy administration. Defending Kennedy’s presidency is not my intention here; I’d be saying the same thing if a left-wing filmmaker invented aspects of a conservative president’s life. While Kennedy did have several extramarital affairs, they should not be the defining element of his presidency.

If “The Kennedys” is any indication, looking past the politics and realizing that history should be treated with the utmost accuracy (especially from a program airing on the History Channel) is a concept losing precedence to entertainment.

— Boultinghouse is a sophomore from Girard in history and journalism.

 

Related articles

Boultinghouse: 3-D diminishes quality, art of films

What is the impact of an entirely 3-D Hollywood?

/news/2010/feb/01/boultinghouse-film/

Most E-mailed: March 13, 2007

Want to know what people are talking about? Here is a list ...

/news/2007/mar/13/most_emailed/

Boultinghouse: The ethos of today's logos

As some companies age, their logos become more youthful.

/news/2010/feb/15/boultinghouse-ethos/

Bailey Hall

The home of numerous liberal arts programs is also on the National ...

/news/2009/apr/17/bailey_hall/

Blastoff! Student to participate in NASA Twitter ...

Tristan Moody has been selected to take part in a Tweetup next ...

/news/2011/jun/20/blastoff-student-participate-nasa-twitter-event/

Getting your game on

How to keep your relationship from becoming a real-life version of Mortal ...

/news/2010/mar/04/getting-your-game/

Kansas Cities

El Dorado

/news/2009/jan/22/kansas_cities/

Boultinghouse: Understanding language leads to understanding cultures

Students should take advantage of the opportunities offered by our University to ...

/news/2010/apr/22/boultinghouse-understanding/

Students attend journalism career fair

Students met with potential employers at the journalism career fair.

/news/2009/mar/04/career_fair/

'Spring Awakening' shows Wednesday at Lied

The racy musical uses rock 'n' roll to explore sexual coming-of-age.

/news/2010/oct/26/spring-awakening/

Murrell named Rhodes Scholar

Kelsey Murrell, a senior from Kearney, Mo., became the 26th University of ...

/news/2011/nov/20/rhodes-scholar/

Sophomore Hallie Steele dies, reportedly in Kansas ...

Steele was a communications major who died July 14 but few details ...

/news/2011/jul/14/sophomore-hallie-steele-dies-reportedly-kansas-cit/

/weblogs/beak/2011/feb/24/beak-staying-warm-campus-activities/

The Beak: Debut edition, with Naismith, Maddow, ...

On-campus news-you-can-use from our latest experiment, a daily blog.

/news/2011/feb/23/beak-debut-edition-naismith-maddow-mojgani-and-mor/

Brinker: The value of ignorance

Has the American culture come to support under-education?

/news/2010/mar/31/brinker-value/

Boultinghouse: A little discomfort can be a ...

The media should show reality-- but use a little judgment.

/news/2010/apr/12/boultinghouse-little/

KU students share their passion for cooking

Nancy Griego and Nina Riley, University of Kansas seniors share their passion ...

/news/2010/feb/15/ku-students-share-their-passion-cooking/

Brinker: Obama deserves an objective progress report

Evaluating what has-- and hasn't-- been accomplished in the past year.

/news/2010/jan/27/brinker-obama/

Health committee stalls medical marijuana bill

Congress is not expected to discuss the Kansas Cannabis Compassionate Care Act, ...

/news/2011/mar/31/health-committee-stalls-medical-marijuana-bill/

Bennett: Freeing Libya and the world is ...

Congrats on your "freedom," Libyans, but Obama's war on Libya was unconstitutional ...

/news/2011/aug/25/libya-free-usa/

Editor's note

Rhythm of the chips

/news/2008/feb/21/editors_note/

Podcast: As Heard From The Hill

Episode five of KJHK's As Heard From The Hill. The weekly radio ...

/news/2008/feb/27/podcast_heard_hill/

The Beak: Staying warm with on-campus events

On-campus news-you-can-use from our latest experiment, a daily blog.

/news/2011/feb/24/beak-staying-warm/

From basketball to baseball

Kansas center to throw ceremonial first pitch in Royals-Twins match-up.

/news/2010/apr/23/basketball-baseball/

/weblogs/hermes-accoutrements-is-about-accepting-for-female/2012/apr/13/oakley-sunglasses-accept-apropos-the-absolute-situ/

Blackmon: Bring a theologian back to residence

KU needs to resurrect valuable program.

/news/2010/feb/04/blackmon-bring/

Business school names new dean

KU alumna Neeli Bendapudi will take over as dean of the School ...

/news/2011/apr/19/business-school-names-new-dean/

So good, it's mad

Reporter Molly Martin explains the fascination behind Mad Men.

/news/2010/sep/30/so-good-its-mad/

University receives more than $245,000 in grants

Grants given to Spencer Museum of Art and KU Libraries

/news/2011/may/11/university-awards-over-245000-grants/

'Once in a lifetime' opportunity

Making the journey for Barack Obama’s inauguration

/news/2009/jan/20/once_lifetime/

Most E-Mailed: Sept. 14, 2007

Want to know what people are talking about? Here’s a list of ...

/news/2007/sep/14/most_emailed_september_13_2007/

/weblogs/a-hrefhttpwwwcaravanmarketcomau-reldofollowcaravan/2011/jun/11/caravan-parks/

Student Senate launches new website

The site is part of Student Senate's larger rebranding effort.

/news/2010/nov/18/student-senate-launches-new-website/

/comments/cr/215/757/#c15784

Dwyer: Snubbed teams deserve explanation from NCAA ...

Colorado, Alabama, Saint Mary’s and Virginia Tech were glossed over in favor ...

/news/2011/mar/14/dwyer-snubbed-teams-deserve-explanation-ncaa-selec/

Podcast: As Heard From The Hill

Episode 12 of KJHK's As Heard From The Hill. The weekly radio ...

/news/2008/apr/30/podcast_heard_hill/

University student named as Rhodes scholar

Kelsey Murrell became the University's 26th Rhodes scholar after a year-long application ...

/news/2011/nov/27/rhodes-scholarship/

Kansas houses gladiator in training

6-foot, 190-pound Cody Kennedy will drive to Austin, Texas, to try out ...

/news/2008/feb/01/gladiator/

Music review: El-P - Weareallgoingtoburninhellmegamixxx3

KJHK’s weekly guide to sonic consumption.

/news/2010/sep/16/music-review-el-p-weareallgoingtoburninhellmegamix/

Politically Correct: The ethics of torture tactics

Our panelists offer their opinions on whether torture should be permitted in ...

/news/2010/mar/05/politically-correct/

Comments

What is the defining moment of Kennedy's presidency?

I look forward to the denouncing of the historically innacurate Oliver Stone(d) movie, "W." Otherwise, this piece reads as left-wing paranoia, not objective journalism.

Did you have the same reaction when "W" was released? If not then you have some personal problems.

Sign in to comment