A family of debaters

BERKELEY, Calif., — The pairings are announced and the squad has 45 minutes to get everything set for a pivotal round of debate against Liberty University. Dylan Quigley and Sean Kennedy don’t let the nerves get the best of them but they are increasingly aware that they need one more win in order to head to the elimination round, and thus be eligible to compete for the national championship.

Quigley, a senior from Wichita, paces around the room rubbing his dark beard in sheer focus while organizing the cards he and Kennedy, a senior from Leawood, will be reading from during their debate. It’s not just them though — they have their unwavering coaches by their side helping them with some last-minute objectives.

The coaches are in it as much as the debaters.

This debate team is truly a family, with one head coach, nine graduate student coaches and four alumni, all there to support the six debaters.

Though serious about its objective, this team knows how to keep the mood light.

On the way to day three of the National Debate Tournament, a day in which the results could prevent a second KU team from qualifying for the elimination round, the mood is buoyant.

The witty remarks, laughter and anecdotes from team members and coaches alike help ease everyone’s nerves on the trip to the debate site.

The team doesn’t allow the gravity and prominence of competing for a national title to stifle their jovial demeanor. But with only thirty minutes until the debate begins, it’s all business.

Kelly Winfrey, a graduate student from Cheyenne, Wyo., and Lindsey Shook, a graduate student from Tulsa, Okla., sit in deep concentration in front of their laptops attempting to track down more evidence to further their argument. Mick Souders, a graduate student from Anacortes, Wash., chats with Quigley about the arguments; doing so ensures there won’t be any holes in their defense.

After three days of debating at the National Debate Tournament at the University of California-Berkeley, only one KU team remains standing.

The University was one of only five schools to qualify three teams for the national tournament.

Dylan Quigley, a senior from Wichita, and Sean Kennedy, a junior from Leawood, received a unanimous vote from all five judges Monday night in the team’s debate against a Northwestern University team, keeping Kansas alive in the competition for the national title.

The pair will continue today in the single-elimination octofinals, which are arranged similarly to an NCAA bracket.

The team of Patrick Kennedy, a junior from Leawood, and Christopher Stone, a senior from Derby, was knocked off by Wake Forest University in the last of three rounds of debate Monday.

The third KU debate squad of Matthew Peterson, a senior from Wichita, and Mark Wilkins, a sophomore from Topeka, fell out of the tournament Sunday after going 2-4 in its rounds.

The opposing team walks in. The KU team hushes. Their discussions are now classified.

Scott Harris, head coach of the squad, is on his computer printing off cards he has just cut — “cutting cards” is the lingo for abridging the author’s claim to easily present arguments.

Kennedy is absorbed in what he is reading as he rubs his wrinkled forehead, pushing back his hair from his face. Harris begins whispering to Kennedy. Their exchange is too quiet for anyone else to hear, but their discussion is crucial.

This continues for the remainder of the preparation. Then the three judges arrive.

Winfrey, Shook, Souders and Harris leave.

Some of them are off to judge two other schools debate. Some are off to scout other team’s arguments. And some just don’t want to throw off the KU team.

“Alright, rock chalk guys, have fun,” Shook adds before leaving.

Quigley and Kennedy succeed in winning their fifth debate and qualifying for the elimination round.

But the win isn’t just theirs.

They credit their coaches. They’re the ones who fill in the holes.

“Since the coaches have been doing this for so long they often can find different kinds of evidence that the squads may not initially think they need,” said Ben Warner, a graduate student from Price, Utah. “They can analyze the evidence in a more thorough manner than debaters.”

But to Quigley, the coaches are more like the moms and dads to this family of debaters. The coaches want to make sure the teams are mentally and physically strong. They calm them down when they’re angry, cheer them up when they’re sad and help in any way possible.

The arguments have been worked over since the topic — whether or not to decrease the United States’ nuclear arsenal — was announced in June.

The coaches are now fine-tuning every intricate detail of each side of the argument.

The leader of the pack

Head coach Harris is in the zone.

He’s preoccupied with all kinds of affirmatives, resolutions and counter plans. His focus is 100 percent on his teams. And 100 percent on winning.

Harris writes arguments for this tournament all year, researching things for the debates that no one knows about until the moment they’re needed.

Team members revel in having him as head coach.

“The joy he gets from fighting an argument or from the process of what we do is really cool and it’s really infectious,” Shook said. “In that way it’s a lot of fun working with him because you can’t help but love debate when you’re around him.”

What team members can’t get over is his habit of pulling all-nighters throughout the five-day tournament. The word is eating chocolate and sipping milk help him stay awake.

“He is an aberration,” Shook said. “If you asked any random person that’s around here they would say that Scott’s ability to stay up all night is almost unsurpassed.”

His dexterity will continue today, the last day of the tournament, where rounds of octofinals will finally be held.

This is the day the nation’s top debate teams will go head to head in the supreme psychological battle of the year.

This is when the real competition for the national crown starts.

— Edited by Sarah Bluvas

 

Related articles

Two KU debate squads qualify for tournament

KU is one of only two universities to rank two teams in ...

/news/2010/feb/19/two-ku-debate-squads/

Kansas debate takes first at Wake Forest

The team defeated highly competitive schools last week, including teams from Harvard ...

/news/2010/nov/28/kansas-debate-takes-first-wake-forest/

Debaters look for a repeat national title

Three teams from KU compete at the National Debate Tournament

/news/2010/mar/22/debate-story/

Debate team wins Wake Forest tournament

University of Kansas debaters defeated highly ranked teams to take first place ...

/news/2010/nov/24/debate-team-wins-wake-forest-tournament/

KU debaters moving toward national crown

Debate team's success is bittersweet after men's basketball loss.

/news/2010/mar/21/debaters-moving-t/

Debate team competes for sixth national championship

Kansas makes its 44th appearance at the National Debate Tournament in March.

/news/2010/feb/24/debate-team/

Two debate teams qualify for elimination round

Two KU squads still eligible to compete for national title.

/news/2010/mar/22/two-debate-teams-qualify-elimination-round/

Jayhawks' national championship hopes cut short

Michigan State against Kansas on final day of debate tournament.

/news/2010/mar/24/jayhawks-national-championship-hopes-cut-short/

Jayhawk debaters snag national title

After 26 years, Kansas earns a victory at the National Debate Tournament.

/news/2009/apr/01/jayhawk_debaters_snag_national_title/

KU debaters officially out of national tournament

Final team loses to Michigan State University.

/news/2010/mar/23/ku-debaters-officially-out-national-tournament/

KU qualifies two teams for debate tournament

The University is sending a second team to the national tournament in ...

/news/2011/feb/22/debate-tournament/

Debate teams head to Dallas for nationals

A rich history, including four national champioships, will follow debaters to Dallas, ...

/news/2007/feb/28/debate/

Debate duo wins title at Harvard

Two members of the KU team take first place in the national ...

/news/2008/nov/11/debate_duo_wins_title/

KU debaters look to repeat history

Three KU teams are competing for the national title for the first ...

/news/2010/mar/20/ku-debaters-look-repeat-history/

/photos/2010/mar/22/10506/

The life of a debater

Constant research and hard work are key to the University’s nationally ranked ...

/news/2012/feb/07/debate-team/

Debate team ends season on top

During the season, the team won first place at four tournaments and ...

/news/2008/may/02/debate/

Debate team has impressive season standing

Considering the No. 1 ranking the it received, the impressive outcome of ...

/news/2007/nov/01/Debate/

/photos/2010/mar/20/10445/

Rhetoric remains subject of debate

Emotion, reason difficult to balance in abortion protest tactics.

/news/2009/sep/29/rhetoric_debate/

Golf places fifth in home tournament

First place UMKC had 10 fewer strokes.

/news/2011/sep/20/golf-places-fifth-home-tournament/

Debate team worth the work

KU debate has qualified for the national debate tournament 39 years in ...

/news/2008/feb/08/debate/

KU’s club volleyball national team earns second ...

The national team fell to Iowa State in Sunday’s Kansas Spring Classic ...

/news/2008/mar/10/volleyball/

/photos/2010/feb/24/9797/

/photos/2010/mar/22/10493/

/photos/2010/mar/22/10504/

Blog: Predicting the Big 12 men's basketball ...

Sam Kovzan gives his take on where each Big 12 team will ...

/news/2011/oct/25/blog-predicting-big-12-mens-basketball-final-stand/

Roesler: Three ‘Hawk Heisman’ hopefuls

If Kansas had any hope of a Heisman, it would go to ...

/news/2010/aug/31/roesler-three-hawk-heisman-hopefuls/

Brew: Barkley busts the Big East's chops

Charles Barkley ruffles feathers with comments about the Big East.

/news/2011/mar/29/barkley-busts-big-easts-chops/

Playing for a title in Allen Fieldhouse

Each intramural basketball league has the championship in Allen Fieldhouse.

/news/2012/mar/04/playing-title-allen-fieldhouse/

Men’s ultimate Frisbee to play at Nationals

A group of guys looking for a good time has evolved into ...

/news/2007/may/08/frisbee/

Big 12 fields top volleyball teams

The Kansas volleyball team could have a tough season ahead of it, ...

/news/2007/aug/17/volleyball/

/photos/2010/mar/24/10512/

Bigger is not always better

NCAA Tournament expansion could weaken March Madness hype.

/news/2010/feb/10/bigger-not-always-better/

/photos/2010/mar/24/10518/

Jayhawks finish tournament in sixth

/news/2005/may/02/sports_golf_mens_results/

/photos/2010/mar/24/10511/

Sports Brief: October 26, 2007

Here's what's happening in sports for October 26, 2007

/news/2007/oct/26/sports_brief_october_26_2007/

Defensive strength highlights spring game

Kansas' spring football game was marked by a lackluster offense and a ...

/news/2008/apr/15/spring_football/

Sarraf: Jayhawks peaking at right time

Despite early exits in the past two NCAA tournaments, Kansas fans can ...

/news/2007/mar/14/sarraf/

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment