Tablets are advancing, but still limited

Tablets are the latest, hottest tech item for students and many are eagerly awaiting Apple’s iPad 3 announcement in March.

“Tablets provide a different user experience,” said Tim Reeb, a junior from Haysville and technology specialist at the KU Bookstore. “A lot of the user interface is simpler, streamlined and easier to access.”

Reeb owns a Motorola Xoom tablet given to him by the department of electrical engineering, but if he were to purchase a new tablet, he said he would pick the Asus Transformer over the iPad 3. Reeb said that the newest iPad will play catch-up to the Transformer, which has been on the market since last April.

The Transformer Prime, released in Dec. 2011 at $500, uses a quad-core processor, 32 GB of hard drive space and can dock into a keyboard port that has USB inputs. Whether students should rely solely on a tablet or still have a computer depends on each student’s needs. According to Reeb, tablets work well for surfing the internet, playing music and writing documents, but computers are best for editing music and photos.

“Tablets are all about content consumption, whereas computers are all about content creation,” Reeb said. A study conducted by The NDP Group suggests that only 10 percent of tablet users rely on their tablet for all of their computing needs. For students, this could mean that it is more practical to invest in a laptop than a tablet.

However, Corey Beckmann, a junior from Overland Park and an Apple sales associate for iCafe, said the iPad 3 is a significant improvement to the tablet market. While most features on the iPad 3 have yet to be confirmed, Apple announced that it will include a retina display, which provides a higher resolution than Blu-Ray.

“You will notice a difference because the fact that it’s higher quality than a Blu-Ray disc already tells you that it’s going to be amazing,” Beckmann said.

Apple plans to announce more details about the new product on March 7. The iPad 3 will likely be on sale a few weeks later, but until then, any specs about the device are rumors. Beckmann said that some of the rumors he has heard include the iPad 3’s 4G network access, a similar price as the iPad 2 — $499, an 8-megapixel camera and a quad-core processor.

Right now, the iPad is only meant to be an extension of a computer, and Beckmann said if he had to choose, he would buy a MacBook Air instead of an iPad 3.

“Right now, tablets are just too limited,” Beckmann said. “But I’m looking forward to when that changes.”

— Edited by Christine Curtin

 

Related articles

Tablets given away to engineering students

VP of Google Maps and Google Earth and a Kansas electrical engineering ...

/news/2011/sep/12/tablets-students/

Mac gains popularity on campus

KU Bookstores have seen a recent boom in Mac sales.

/news/2008/mar/13/apple/

Electrical engineering students receive $500 incentive

Freshmen in the electrical engineering and computer science program will receive Android ...

/news/2012/feb/23/tablets-engineering/

E-textbooks will change teaching and learning

E-readers in the classroom will alter both teaching and learning on campus.

/news/2012/jan/16/e-textbooks/

Studies show iPad has health benefits

Researchers say children who have CVI respond to the iPad.

/news/2011/oct/11/studies-show-ipad-has-health-benefits/

Apple iPad may help visually impaired children

University research on iPads shows a promising lead in the treatment of ...

/news/2011/oct/10/apple-ipad-may-help-visually-impaired-children/

The University plans to implement ebooks throughout ...

Officials explore ebook technology options with companies including Apple, Microsoft and Dell

/news/2012/feb/20/plans-implement-ebooks/

Engineering student creates game on Android tablet

An alumnus donation gives students hands-on and real-world experience

/news/2012/mar/05/engineering-tablet/

Good bad and ugly advice: on unexpected ...

Three of our columnists take a humorous stance on a serious subject.

/news/2011/feb/02/good-bad-and-ugly-advice-unexpected-pregnancy/

Brinker: Late Apple CEO's memory unrealistic

Steve Jobs embodied unrestrained capitalism, which makes his glorification seem odd.

/news/2011/oct/31/brinker-late-apple-ceos-memory-unrealistic/

More textbooks could be offered digitally

New applications allow e-textbooks to be readable on iPhones and the iPad.

/news/2010/feb/19/more-textbooks-could-be/

Med Center requires identical computers

After the implementation of the new tablet computers at KU Med, 75 ...

/news/2006/oct/04/computers/

Salsbury: Change isn't necessarily improvement

With changes in technology, enjoy the journey.

/news/2011/oct/19/salsbury-change-isnt-necessarily-improvement/

Moreland: Publishing companies in the digital world

Now that Nooks and Tablets are taking over, the future of print ...

/news/2012/mar/01/moreland-publishing-companies-digital-world/

Keeping personal information from cyber crime

Personal information can be accessed by hackers and thieves in an instant ...

/news/2012/jan/29/keeping-personal-information-cyber-crime/

The Age of Mobile Applications

Apps provide students with ways to improve productivity or thwart it

/news/2011/mar/03/age-mobile-applications/

Students, faculty must change passwords for stronger ...

/news/2005/sep/13/password/

Warner Brothers switches to Blu-ray

Major movie studio dumps High Definition titles

/news/2008/feb/01/bluray/

ResNet outsourced to Apogee

Apogee, the country’s largest residential network internet provider, takes over Internet service ...

/news/2011/sep/20/resnet-outsourced-apogee/

Student atheist’s video wins award

Chris Redford’s documented transformation to an atheist earns him online recognition.

/news/2010/mar/30/student-atheists-mini-documentary-wins-award/

Welcome to the World of 'You'

Move over Facebook, step aside MySpace: a new online community called YouTube ...

/news/2006/aug/14/youtube/

KUnited opens first DVD rental kiosk

Students can rent movies and games at the kiosks.

/news/2010/apr/29/kunited-opens/

Calling a Collins Comeback

The old moves were finally back. Collins could cut, shoot and finish ...

/news/2008/feb/11/calling_collins_comeback/

App helps advocate for peace in the ...

Falling Whistles visits the University, introducing its new app "FW+Faces" on Wednesday.

/news/2011/oct/24/app-advocates-congo/

/photos/2010/nov/03/12960/

The Gaming Diet

Getting in shape with video games can be as fun as it ...

/news/2009/aug/20/gaming_diet/

Get your Kix

/news/2005/jan/27/jayplay_bite_department/

The Rise of the E-book

Textbooks or a Tablet: What would you prefer?

/news/2012/jan/31/rise-e-book/

Complications surround new library-printer system

Students are frustrated by the lengthier process now required to print documents ...

/news/2012/jan/31/confusing-printers/

Facing the music

For 13 students sued by the music industry, the risks of illegal ...

/news/2008/apr/30/facing_music/

Man donates $100,000 for research

/news/2005/aug/19/100_man/

Anchutz Library turns 20

Once uveiled, the more spacious building will soon be an epicenter of ...

/news/2009/nov/13/Anschutz-library-turns-20/

The future of books

As e-books become popular, technology changes the way we read.

/news/2010/feb/04/future-books/

/photos/2010/apr/08/10781/

Accelerate your computer

How to shift your computer’s performance into high gear

/news/2008/oct/09/accelerate_your_computer/

Digital Design changes the face of architecture

The new movement trades out paper and pen for computers.

/news/2010/sep/08/digital-design-changes-face-architecture/

Spencer showcase examines photography in the digital ...

Interactive exhibition allows visitors to be a photo editor for the day.

/news/2010/aug/23/spencer-showcase-examines-photography-digital-age/

/photos/2010/apr/07/10773/

Allen Fieldhouse available anytime with online replica

Brian McClendon, KU alumnus, commissioned Google to create a 3-D version of ...

/news/2011/may/02/online-replica-allows-people-view-allen-fieldhouse/

Uppers keep students studying all night

/news/2005/may/02/news_campus_studying/

Comments

“You will notice a difference because the fact that it’s higher quality than a Blu-Ray disc already tells you that it’s going to be amazing,” Beckmann said.

No, in fact you will not notice a difference because on a 10" screen your eyes cant physically see the difference between 720p and 1080p (Blu-Ray). Not to mention that basically zero media is distributed commercially at resolutions higher than 1080p. It will however cost you money more and run your battery down faster. But hey, its a nice talking point for a sales pitch!

^Actually, you will notice a difference. Maybe not from 720p to 1080p, but from the current iPad screen resolution. He's right because the current resolution is 1024x768, and with the supposed next resolution being 2048x1536. That's a noticeable difference. Think iPhone 3GS to iPhone 4. And you're right. Nearly zero media is distributed at resolutions higher than 1080p. However, it has to start somewhere and the reason for the resolution to be as high as it is, it's probably more for apps and web browsing clarity than viewing videos, etc. And because of the pxel density, it will STILL be sharper than it was before. How do you know it will cost more money? Don't you think Apple will compensate for draining battery life by throwing in a better battery? My 2 cents.

Actually higher pixel density does not always mean a better picture. Too high a density on a small screen can mean increased noise. Too much sharpness can also decrease the quality of an image. These problems are exacerbated when displaying a non-native resolution as you WILL be doing much of the time on a 2048x1536 screen for the foreseeable future. That being said, I know Apple knows what they are doing and I'm sure the display will look great. My gripe was that the guy I quoted essentially says, "It will be better because its got more pixels", which is just terrible logic. More pixels does not always mean better picture, there is a breaking point at which it will actually become worse.

As for the cost and battery life comment, I meant in comparison to the same tablet at a lower resolution.

Sign in to comment