0

Satyagraha

Haiti Efforts Taken The Wrong Way

Religious groups are often first in helping after disaster strikes. In the face of disaster, their speed and precision can outmatch larger groups or governments. Although the individual contributions of these groups might not be much, collectively, they represent a crucial piece in disaster recovery.

This was especially evident in 2005 with Hurricane Katrina. Many religious organizations were on site, already helping days before many government agencies even got there. These groups provided essentials to the victims including food, blankets, shelter and evacuation assistance.

The efforts in Haiti seem to be more balanced among churches, governments and other organizations than Katrina was. However, once again, religious groups are playing a huge part in providing relief.

Nonetheless, there is a line between effective relief and taking advantage of a terrible situation. Objective Ministries, along with a handful of other organizations, have crossed this line.

Objective Ministries is currently launching a “relief effort” with their new product, The Proclaimer®. The Porclaimer is a “rugged, self-powered audio Bible that can broadcast the New Testament in the jungle, desert, or even on the moon!” The group is currently asking donations to send these $157 glorified radios to Haiti.

On their website, the main marketing point of Objective Ministries is that the Proclaimer can “produce enough comforting decibels of Gospel to be clearly heard by 300 homeless and injured people.” Where that statistic comes from, I don’t know, but its validity is questionable at best.

It doesn’t matter if five, or 500 people can hear the radio. For a society in which the vast majority of its citizens live on a dollar a day, $157 could be spent in a multitude of better ways.

Objective Ministries also promotes this program by saying how now “we can turn this tragedy into an opportunity to release Haiti from the bonds of Voodoo and it’s (sic) Satanic pact.”

To say that this tragedy is an opportunity to promote a religion seems to undermine one of religion’s main purposes: to show compassion to humanity.

Churches and religious organizations should do what they can to help those in need. In fact, my favorite thing about religion is its capacity to help others. But there is a difference between genuine help, and a religious marketing ploy.

The people of Haiti don’t need fancy solar powered radios (that’s right, it can be powered by batteries, solar power, a hand crank or an AC adaptor). They need food, clean water and a place to sleep.

Comments

Shauna, this was a great letter. I thank you for bringing it to light. As a tourist stuck in the Superdome, after finally being bussed to Dallas, we were welcomed with a meal at a rest stop created by a Christian group. It almost brought tears to our eyes. Still there were some fundamentalist fringe unrelated to them that were simply trying to get us to convert to their beliefs.

The same thing happened to a couple of us as we walked from the Dallas Convention Center to a taxi. There again was another fundamentalist trying to convert us, rather than offering any type of sympathy or a listening ear.

That is definitely NOT what I need or want when I'm in dire straits or survival mode.

Paul Harris Author, "Diary From the Dome, Reflections on Fear and Privilege During Katrina"

I’m not sure why Ms. Blackmon’s piece appears in two separate locations, but I will post my comment in both places.


Religious groups seeking to share their faith in Jesus Christ to those suffering in Haiti are not “taking advantage of a terrible situation.” By derisively describing these efforts as a “religious marketing ploy,” Ms. Blackmon reveals her contempt for the spiritual welfare of a hurting people.

It’s certainly fair to suggest that money going to Haiti may be better spent on things besides an audio Bible. But while we in the United States may dismiss the value of a “glorified radio,” this may be a priceless gift in a land without a functioning electrical grid. Also, this is a private charity…if this is a priority to those who sacrificially give their hard earned money, why should we disparage their efforts?

Finally, it’s inappropriate to suggest that this group is not showing “compassion to humanity.” That is precisely what they are doing. As Ms. Blackmon concedes, Christians are providing food, water, and shelter. They are also offering spiritual nourishment and the hope found in the Man of Sorrows. To insist that they can only provide the former and not the latter is wrong.


Haiti very much needs God, as do we all.

Sign in to comment